I agree what he does is wrong, but he also (at times... how ever small) was the only one who ... 'cared' for her when she was a fatty. like when she (I think) fainted on the street and he was the only one who helped her.
while the other guy treated her nice to look better, and he only uses people. I can't help but think if he found out he would either threaten her to be with him (In beauty form) or make her life a living hell (not that it isn't already) for deceiving him.
personally I like the bully more, but they BOTH don't have the right to have her. I think she should stand tall and drop the idea of dating them, even if only for revenge after all that makes her just as bad.
Also, food for thought, if she's in the beauty form for a long time won't she naturally lose weight? Because she's not constantly hungry in her beauty form, unlike her original form so she is eating right.... maybe. but not constantly eating should help and if that guy is her grandfather doesn't that mean she's also a beauty. That or the fact that this story is being compared to the ugly duckling here's to hope.
Oh no!!! Don΄t hurt her any more than this you disgusting bully!! You fucking jerk!! Even if he eventually becomes gentle and good i will still hate him for he had done to this poor girl... If i were her i would never date him even if he was the last man on earth!!! (╬ ̄皿 ̄)凸