Himemira's Topics (193)

I don’t think she was naive just something that’s hard to accept

Tbf, she doesn't know anything. She doesn't remember her past life, what happened or how got teleported. She only remembers her Korean name, the happenings of the book and what caused her to die. Anyone who doesnt remember anything or what they are are sure to be fearful and anxious of what's going to happen. She read in the book that ML likes torturing and killing white hair people, should she not be scared when she herself has white hair??

She isn't very smart also. You can argue and say that she knows how to read, talk, count and can tell what each object's names are, but that's it. She doesn't have any life experience besides knowing how to be nice, how to run away and hide. You can't expect her to be confident until she learns how to be confident. She doesn't even remember her previous occupation, how do you expect her to realise that ML won't kill her when she is not even educated emotionally??

Of course, I completely understand your frustration. When looked in a different way, she seems almost stupid, borderlining on useless, and I agree. But she is MEANT be useless until she learns of her powers and strengths. That's my 2 cents tho, if you disagree that's completely fine with me too, please don't take this as a way of hate directed towards you as that's absolutely not my intention.

I mean, it's realistic. You don't really expect someone that doesn't remember ANYTHING to start off being a boss bitch. She doesn't remember how she got there, her name, her age, etc.

Sometimes the gods teach us lessons we don't see until it is over?

maybe, because rulac isnt a good father? he paid ignorance to Tia condition before, not until Tia showed her usefulness.

This gave me enough reason to drop this. Another cliched historical romance. Aren't you guys tired of seeing this shii over and over again?

Yes its cliche.. But for me its very satisfied when seeing FL got revenge for everyone who torture her..

You'll understand when you find your predilection genre

tbh, its not the romance that's interesting the politics, the orchestration and finesse leoni has and does to play all these clowns like their pawns in a chess game, the romance is just the side garnish

but if its genric plot, it will be dropped with in half a ch

Bro I’m gonna drop it, I read Florentia after this but it’s clear that Matriarch was the original and inspired all these manhwa. Honestly they do it better, plus this FL is so infuriating she thinks she can do stuff but she couldn’t even do anything after her third marriage.

Well, maybe it goes to show that I have low tolerance for scraps that are being reused thru almost all of these historical romance. I'm gonna stick to Florentina til the end

Lol u act like she even had control since she was born

Honestly its just a generation thing not all of them inspired by it, but at least one was, although i feel like matriarch was good in its own right like if anything more of a realistic ver. and this is like a fantasy parallel ver.

Look bro, I understand what you're saying but

1) She's got an entire lifetime of experience (no other character does!)
2) The entire appeal of these types of transmigration novels is that they get revenge or redemption from their past lives which is what makes them super satisfying. And, newsflash, you kind of need to have some semblance of competence and not just false confidence that 'ehehe I know the future so...' to actually pull that off.

This manhwa just happens to not do this cliche well, there are still plenty of ones that do great.

I disagree. A lot of these kinds of manhwas are based on the OG ones like Matriarch and Princess.

Matriarch also had plenty of fantasy elements in this. Realism vs make-believe should not affect a story's writing.

It's not even predilection anymore. I also like reincarnation tropes and "be able to turn back time" but I can't help but notice EVERY DAMN SIMILARITIES AFTER THAT. Y'all know what I'm talking about. And it's just sick how they just indirectly copied almost every damn thing from the first og stories. It's like matriarch but change the mLs appearance. Most stories are JUST LIKE THAT.

Yeah, so clearly this isn't your predilection genre. Don't get me wrong bad writing is bad writing but if your problem is the similarities then it's just a genre you really like, not your predilection genre.
For me as long as the story is well written, logical (mostly) and the characters are enjoyable I don't care if it's the same story again and again and again.

But give me school life genre and I'll nope out if it's too similar to other works. The more time pass, the more difficult I get with this genre ╮(￣▽￣)╭

That's your opinion, obvi. My point is it's not about preferences in romance genre but the fact that the flow of the story as well as the elements, characters THEY'RE ALL COPY PASTE. there's nothing original in this. It's a good writing but out of stolen ideas from other og stories. That's what's fckd up. Like these trash authors can't come up with something original.

There's no such thing as an original idea to begin with, everything is just a recollection of different inspirations that the authors experienced. Humans aren't capable of inventing from nothing, we all build our imagination, fantasy, logic and understanding from pre-existing knowledge. Try inventing a new color for example, you simply can't. Your og stories are also "copied" from other things we don't know of.

You also underestimate good writing. You say it's copy pasted but it's not truly, there's always important details that change or yes it would be plain plagiarism. And those details make all the difference. If you don't understand what worked in the og stories and why, you'll end up using it wrong and the logic of your story then falls apart. That's what bad writing ultimately is, a failure to understand the connection and ramifications of elements in your own story.

Dude. Chill, we don’t have to get so philosophical about this, I completely agree with what you’re saying but the point of this thread was to establish we all had a common opinion about this manhwa being poor quality, that’s it.

Hmm... I think you got things mixed up, I never replied to any of your messages ?

I mean someone asked a question, I answered and they argued with my answer so I started to enter into details to explain and then out of nowhere you jumped in to tell me to chill which was utterly confusing. The conversation we were having wasn't even about this manhwa but genre in general.

(Or are you looking for confrontation ? I can match your energy if you want so just tell me cause I don't think we're on the same page)

This is a comment section, everyone can read it or reply to everything. Chill tf out .

What are you even saying bruh. Of course they wouldn't blatantly copy "everything". They're gonna change some elements like having a trash father, getting revenge to everyone who dishonored her or killed her, adopted out of nowhere by the villain, having op powers, ML who's yandere, tsundere with every move predicted and for sure falling in-love with MC was easy asf. Oh shii maybe I'm just imagining things

Are you not understanding what I'm explaining on purpose ? Since I'm not gonna repeat myself a third time I guess I wish you to find a genre you like better than the villainess genre.