Comments of New York New York

what a crazy story also why was the second volume just a mystery murder thriller why did we change the plot so much

AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHH

im not sympathizing with the serial killer, but if he had met mel when he was younger (and if they were similar in age), before he became all twisted, they would've fallen in love and run off. mel needs someone who loves him devotedly and in turn, will reciprocate in kind, and joey would fall for mel's kindness and love him with all his heart, which he deserves. ofc, granted that joey's psychopath tendencies were not innate but developed due to upbringing.

My heart could not stop beating. Mixed emotion till the end.

This is so amazing. Huhu. I can't. Uuugh. My heart

I don’t get over the cheating part so that’s disappointing to me

AHHHHHHH THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL FR

Dropped at the very first chapter
Lost my faith in the yaoi fandom one more time after seeing the rating -_- this shit is pure garbage. The seme is toxic and abusive, he fucking deserves to die!!! My baby uke deserves soooooo much better uggghhhhh....I HATE THIS. Also, why tf would you justify cheating??? Cheating is cheating no matter what the situation is

Omg mels life needs a break

Ch3. I just can’t believe he’d cheat on Mel twice. Not only that, but that Mel forgave him. I wish I’d been his mother or something so he didn’t have to live this life
The rest was aaight and awesome but poor Mel. A lot of people disappointed him in his life.. I’m glad that he was happy in his last years.

i cried a lot. it's wholesome, fantastic, awesome, just amazing. seriously. it hurts, but it is lovely at the same time.

Goodness gracious. It was like a rollercoaster that dipped into underground for the most part. So much assault. So much hate. Mel was such an absolute angel. He deserved happiness and a faithful partner. Ugh. I hate Kain for cheating so much. I hated his guts. He improved, yes, but at the expense of Mel!

Im just so overwhelmed and i feel like stabbing a fictional character.
**edit
Still! F you kain. I love you both. Im bawling my eyes out amd sniffing like an addict

5 Stars! I am not a fan of this "old style" art but honey! This story! Honey I was in tears ! I wish the author would give us more of their happy time together. It felt a little bit rushed. Maybe 1-2 chapters more after the whole "horror" would be better.
Otherwise amazing. I wish I would find a love like this.
It hurts double coz I am 6 months after a break up from my 4,5 years relationship.

Read from bookmarked. Seems like it’s good? Idk

I’m not going to lie, I wasn’t feeling this at first (chapters 1-4) but holy shit it ended up being so worth it. I cried my ass off.