Comments of Yakusoku Siren

Okay I don't understand how people can love this story so much. Im a suckered for hurt comfort but this really isn't giving that. This was not even a happy ending, just a frustrating cut. There was no resolve of anything happening to them in their childhood, there was only a blame oriented two dimensional plotline for y the younger brother had to be alone and he was never absolved of that even though realistically speaking he was not at fault nor was it his responsibility to know his own feelings yet the story puts it as if everything is fine with just the two brothers reuniting. This story is essentially agreeing with the parents reasoning for Abandoning their son by neither solving the drama nor actually framing it in the uncomfortable light it should have been if it were not agreed with.

this author’s stories r always so beautiful ;-;

I know it’s so cringe but to me this might be one of the top 50 non-yaoi manga ever

Amazing story that seems sad, but truly makes you smile. I hope everyone has someone they want to make smile like Aya does.

It’s a good read

This make me tear up a little because I have an identical twin sister. If she almost died because of me I would be really depressed and probably won't talk to no one for a while.

story about brother's reconnecting. No yaoi. Older bro had forgotten that the young one pushed him down the stairs, but forgives him and finds him. Makes him smile a 100 times.

It's so beautiful I'm crying

This story hit me right in the heart. I loved it so much and I'm so glad I read it.

decent story. art not my thing. felt like it was meant to pull at the heart strings more, but came off a lil bit soap opera. "when i grow up, i'm going to have so much amnesia!"

I love this story. The brotherly bond of these twins is beautiful. I love the older brother who cares and silently watches over the younger one and how he naively attempts to make him smile, although it doesn't really change anything. He wanted to see his little brother happy and enjoying life before returning to his life as an only child. He didn't want to forget, but knew of his circumstances. The brotherly love depicted here is so touching. A story of twin brothers, one of whom loves the other and the othee who hates himself.

I always wanted twins. But now dream gone. Beautiful story with beautiful end. I´m on verge of tears.

Twins are united after a long absence when one hurts the other. One needs surgery but won't have it until he can rectify things with his brother. Very sweet and I like the art.

Such a sweet and heart touching story about twins, it has a likeable cast, an interesting plot line and moving scenes which lead to a bitter-sweet feeling!

omg i started crying xD