People who read Haru O Daite Ita Alive

tijger

Kiixiah

Gawd I love IwakixKatou couple so much!
I was just thinking that as they were growing older, Katou was becoming more and more reliable and quite the opposite for Iwaki.
Just for a playboy and Katou’s unserious personality, I was expecting him to be the one to make past mistakes like its so shocking for it to be Iwaki.
Also damn authornim! I seriously nooo Katou I cried.
Only things I’m unsatisfied with are:
1. Really Iwaki taught Yousuke “that”? If Katou knew it would have been a fight.
2. Katou not seeing the cherry blossoms bloom on the porch.

Ichigo

Katou and Iwaki's love will forever remain one of the absolute most beautiful and pure love stories I've ever read... Katou's unexpected death put me in an actual panic, I felt my chest tightening as a lump formed in my throat! I couldn't stop crying. Their love was exemplary, and to this day it's regretful to think that the author practically ruined their own masterpiece.

Skina

DO NOT READ IF YOU WANT TO BE HAPPY
I regret so much reading this... I'm literally crying so hard ! Why ? Why did it end like that ?? They were so wholesome... I will just forget that and it will be like all this sequel were actually a movie that they filmed like for fuyu no semi ! I will stay in DENIAL for my entire life !!! Or I will go insane ! I can't stop crying it's horrible !

Quack

I hate the son sm I wish he got aborted like fuck that fag

Mapantasya

Here again to say I still couldn't accept the ending!! Everytime I visit the last chapter I'm still hoping that it will change. that's how in-denial I am. I shouldn't wish for sequel if this is the ending I get. Gosh the years I've waited for this manga it was not worth it. I will just forget this sequel. I will not rate this low since this is one of my favorite manga and my first also.

Kay766

I like to pretend that this does not exist. What a why for the author to ruin an already great manga. I really wished she would have just started a new story instead messing up this one. This story was already finished and had a great ending there was no need to go back and add more.

Ciel

I cried a lot! I live the plot! I didn't expect it. I love the first story more!

Killian

Seriously katou is dead now.

Beka

Everything was fine before the questionable decisions around half of the story. The ending was unnecessary. But the series means a lot to me so i´m not rating it that low.

Phil

This manga introduced me to the world of yaoi manga in 2013 I fell inlove with the story line, but this ending had me filling a river with tears. Sad and then happy tears, it leaves an everlasting memory of the moments I spent reading it. Thanks to everyone who contributed to this

DemonKingOfLust

Tbh the character development in this sequel is weird, at the begining Katou diagnosed PSTD, why? In the prequel before he just overprotective and simple worry to Iwaki.
And after that, many entity pops up in the story out of nowhere but in the prequel it never mentiones before.
The last one is, Katou sudden death, it reasonable if he die in some traffic accident or etc, but just like that?, and Iwaki die in the operation table that never mentioned the sickness before, he just collapse in the prequel and thats that.
.
The story is good, the dynamic and plot just like the prequel, proble > reconcile > learn somthing > making love
It suitable called it a new story not the prequel, all the plot is so sudden out of nowhere mentioned in prequel

eat more lard

"Sorry for doing the Billy Mays to Katou, and making Iwaki into a child molester. Anyway, here's space robots"

The word "Alive" in the title is the biggest troll kfjsjsks but the screentones were magnificent, as always. Can't fault the art, at least.

Grrrrl

Wish it was never written. Ruined a beautiful classic. And why? For money?

FoxSan

I made the comments few years ago, asking for justice for Katou. What I got is, the author killed him!!!!

Caijed

After all what Katou has been through.. he died of one small mistake. The ending is absolutely stupid.

Preetigrg

I cried really hard when katau diedthe ending was beautiful

Lady Red Lamp

I'm shocked I couldn't believed the ending!!! They're so cute together, I thought I could see them getting old together

`cshwiq

okay but real ending(found in sequel aka this) gave me depression WHGAT WAS THAT LITERALLY READ THIS FIR YREARS ONLY TO HAVE MY FANTASY BROKEN NITCH HELLA NAH IN MY MIND THE STORY ENDS IN THE PREQUEL NOT THE SEQUEL. i know ending cos spoilers but ill read the rest after exams :

timestamp:21

Omelette

the ending is realistically beautiful, its true we go through a lot in this life, the happy times and sad times, however as a reader I don't want this endingggg uwaaaaa... I wish they grow old together or at least katou did not die unexpectedly like that, it hurtss soo mucchhhhh, I seriously cry, I am even not in the mood for sad things tonight uwaaaaaaaaa