Personally i love this so much.

Unique mix of romance and supernatural drama. Starts off like a typical contract-love story slowly turns deeper and complex story. It was so emotional, the story crafted so well! The backstory, the amnesia (kinda) plot, the unrequited-forbidden love... This manwha ruins you, really...

Not a light read, but definitely worth it if you like angsty, layered stories.

God the thing i do to re-read this for the first time again... maybe it's my thing, i love toxic and regretful man, that is my trope.

Putting that aside, it has unique plot, crazy world building and strong character development. The part when the FMC running away and the MMC tracking her down it's so good and intense, i need someone to wash my brain so i could read it again

Unique plot and handsome male lead, God i wished…

i just want him not the drama, Siyun Baek you always gonna be my top 3 yandere male lead.

Thank God I gave this a chance. I was lowkey intimidated by 204 chapters and the early art (not really my taste at first but the art gets better).

This is PEAK!!! Enemies to lovers at its most doomed. The story, character development, and world-building were all insane. Their romance was intense, messy, and honestly kinda toxic—but in a way that just works. The tension?? Crazy.

GET THE F OUT, MOVE, THIS IS SO PEAK!

I feel so empty after reading this, the story progress was so good. The redemption ark wasn't about Ian, it was about how Madelyn treated Ian in previous life. This manhwa portrayed how wars affected people really well.

God i ate the "i love you but we are not good together" arc so much and the constant doubt of deserving of love, i need another story like this, everything i need in a good manhwa is in here.

The emotional damaged that this left me...
I love angst and regretful-yearning man but this left me speechless

They were both so precious, the lack of the communication in the beginning was frustrating but the character development was so phenomenal, they grow to understand each other and forgive.

This was… a masterpiece. The story was beautiful and well written; the romance came gradually and steadily. Every encounter feels like joy and sadness.

The yearning and longing were so much to bear, I had accepted it would end in such tragedy but the ending was perfect, and both characters are perfect. Please read, i beg!

Deliciously marinated. 10 for the plot, 10 for the FL, and 10 for the romance.

I LOVE the characters and their complexity. The story is layered & every character feels like they have their own motives which makes every interaction feel so much more interesting, love love love the character development of each characters, especially FL dad & second brother.

The romance is probably one of my favorite parts. SOOO SLOW BURN. PEAK MANHWA.