Personal Favorites

ART: 4.5 - A real stunner. Good art all around.
PLOT: 4 - Minimal but it's there and it's solid.
SMUT: 5 - WOW.
CLICHE: 2 - Only one notable scene at beginning.
ORIGINALITY: 5 - This is the stuff of which dreams are made of.

ART: 3.5 - Ok char. design and good historical detail though some scans are pretty grainy.
PLOT: 4 - Surprisingly does not revolve (too much) around sex. Good progression and integration. Char. development fairly weak.
SMUT: 4 - IF ONLY THE QUALITY WAS HIGHER.
CLICHE: 4 - Lots of rape rape turning to love love.
ORIGINALITY: 4 - European knight vs Arabian prince.

ART: 3 - Nothing much to see here.
PLOT: 2.5 - Could be stronger.
SMUT: 3 - Lots but lack of detail holds it back.
CLICHE: 5 - The rape to love trope is strong here and def. what I remember most about this manga.
ORIGINALITY: 3 - Unremarkable.
*HOWEVER THE EXTRA IS HOT AF. I GIVE THAT ONE 4/5

ART: 4 - Good detail, good art, good paneling
PLOT: 4 - Short but good progression and definite char. development.
SMUT: 4 - Good shit. Could show more dick though.
CLICHE: 1.5 - Only one scene I can think of.
ORIGINALITY: 3.5 - Beginning is definitely funny and fairly original.

ART: 4 - Generic char. design but character detail and good art more than compensate.
PLOT: 3 - Entertaining but nothing noteworthy.
SMUT: 4 - Ain't no dick but the details (abs!) make the smut still feel smutty.
CLICHE: 3 - Unrequited feelings getting requited...kinda aggressively.
ORIGINALITY: 3 - An office story, a host story, and a chef story

ART: 4 - Well drawn though char. design is fairly generic
PLOT: 3 - Nothing totally amazing but nothing glaringly poor.
SMUT: 4 - Hot even with censoring. Seme is such a playboy :p
CLICHE: 4 - "Can I rape you?"
ORIGINALITY: 2 - Ehhhh, fairly basic.

ART: 5 - Unique style, beautiful char. designs and good detail/color
PLOT: 4 - A slow burner that makes you cheer for the milestones. But...did it have to be slow?
SMUT: 1 - Keep moving people. ALTHOUGH the romantic moments are real soul soothers.
CLICHE: 4 - OMG just say how you feel!1!!11 The one big cliche, unfortunately, is what's driving the plot.
ORIGINALITY: 3 - University setting. Flashback encounter. Nothing noteworthy.

*FIRST STORY ONLY
ART: 4.5 - Excellent char. design especially for supernatural creatures and well drawn
PLOT: 2 - Personally I wasn't sure what was the end goal, felt very slice of life. Still satisfying to read but could've been more.
SMUT: 4 - Good shit. Extra limbs keep things interesting.
CLICHE: 1 - If there are then none stood out to me.
ORIGINALITY: 4.5 - Interesting world she came up with and with pretty cool char.

*FIRST STORY ONLY
ART: 4 - Looks a lil dated but good char. design and cuteness gives the manga its own charm.
PLOT: 3.5 - Short and sweet.
SMUT: 4 - Hot and passionate. No dick though.
CLICHE: 1 - Refreshing to read.
ORIGINALITY: 5 - I mean there's other yaoi with divine figures but this felt original somehow.

ART: 3 - Average.
PLOT: 5 - Very thorough. Excellent development.
SMUT: 1 - You ain't reading this for smut.
CLICHE: 1 - There are some could-be-cliches but they serve their purpose well
ORIGINALITY: 5 - The storytelling is truly among the most unique in yaoi literature.