Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.

Judging Random Shoujo Fantasy

I will judge and rate random romance fantasy manhwa/hua/nga based on the art, the plot, the pace, and the character designs.

To be fair when judging the plot, I will try my best not to spoil too much by giving some vague examples on what's going on or avoid to be too specific with the details.

But regardless what I said, pls remember it's just my opinion, whether I like it or not, give these authors a chance and see whether you agree with me or not.
All(63) / manga(56) / photo(7)

I took care of him, but he came back obsessed with me

 8.9(415 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s):
Genre(s): Webtoons / Josei / Shoujo / Fantasy / Historical / Romance / Supernatural

7/10
TW: SLAVERY
This manhwa changes artstyle 3 times throughout the story, and personally I love the 1st artstyle more. The other 2 styles make it look like any other shojo isekai. Nothing special.
For the plot, tbh just cliche shojo isekai that you can find anywhere, but I think the author could've made the story a little bit more interesting, bcs not gonna lie, the story is kinda boring and repetitive; fml caught in dangerous situation, she got framed, ml saves her, repeat until the end.

18 07,2025

I'll Protect You, Daddy!

 8.9(151 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): Honeychou,Ttm
Genre(s): Webtoons / Shoujo / Drama / Fantasy

2/10
Both the art and the plot is just baaaddd. I feel like if this is the first time the artist(s) working on manhwa, they should have pick something easier to draw like highschool drama comedy instead of fantasy isekai. There's a lot of panels that the artist(s) didn't render at all, bad anatomy, and (this is just my pet peeve) all the women there have unrealisticly long hair lmao even the children

18 07,2025

I Became The Youngest Sister-in-law Of The Male Leads In A Tragic Reverse Harem

 9.4(869 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s):
Genre(s): Webtoons / Shoujo / Comedy / Drama

10/10
THIS IS SO GOOD
I love everything about this manhwa, the fml, the ml, other support characters, world building, art, character development.
None of the interactions between either of the characters awkward/forced. It's so refreshing to see the sisters behave like normal siblings, not brainless npc who overly obsessed with their youngest sister. The fml is also behave like her age; spoiled, cry alot, but still lovable and not annoying.

18 07,2025

SSS-Grade Cafe in Front of The Dungeon

 9.2(156 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s):
Genre(s): Webtoons / Shoujo / Comedy / Drama / Fantasy

8/10
The art is fine but a little bit inconsistent, like there's some panels where they look kind of stiff, but over all pretty good.
The fml vibes kind of remind me of "The Duchess' 50 Tea Recipes" fml but it's coffee instead lol. But the plot itself more like "Solo Leveling". Cliche but interesting. Definitely recommended (◍•ᴗ•◍)

18 07,2025

I Became an Extra in a Parenting Story

 8.4(396 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): Jerry , Ha min
Genre(s): Webtoons / Shoujo / Drama / Fantasy

6.5/10
Personally, I think the art is decent, it's just not my cup of tea. The plot is also cliche (not that it's a bad thing, but if you're tired of cliche shoujo fantasy, this is not for you).
The only "unique" point of this manhwa is that:
1. The fml is NOT the villain's daughter,
2. The fml and ml dynamic remind me with geum jandi and goo junpyo from boys before flower (bully x victim)

19 07,2025

I Became the Mother of a Sub-Male Son

 8.5(129 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s):
Genre(s): Webtoons / Shoujo / Drama / Fantasy / Romance

5.5/10
Pretty dencent art but not exceptional, the plot is also mediocre and predictable (at least for now). The starting point of the story kind of remind me with "I Found a Husband When I Picked Up the Male Lead" but if it flop fast. Either way, if you're addicted to shoujo fantasy and bored out of your mind, this manhwa is ok to spend your time to

19 07,2025

The Perfect Ending Plan of a Fairy Tale Villainess

 9.2(171 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): 피치파이
Genre(s): Webtoons / Shoujo / Drama / Fantasy / Historical / Romance

8.5/10
TW: CHILD ABUSE
I like the earlier artstyle more; bigger eyes, realistic proportion for both males and females, and fluffier hair. The newer style made them look like any other shoujo. That being said, I feel like fml sometimes act like she's not an adult, and I believe her real age is older than the owner body's real age (cmiiw). I'm not saying she behave like a child, but her train of thoughts (especially in the begining arc) is questionable or rather childish-

19 07,2025

I'm glad she matured the more the story progressed.

(Also, this is artstyle in the earlier chapter!)

21 07,2025

I'm a Worthless Stepmother, But I Love My Family Madly!

 9.3(705 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): Tsuruko
Genre(s): Shoujo / Drama / Fantasy / Romance

7/10
Mediocre plot combined with good art.
Fml character is so inconsistent, like, she's supposed to be insecure, she called herself worthless countless of time (it's also literally in the title) and before she went through character development arc, somehow she's fine being the center of attention of a lot of people? It's almost like the author didn't do any research on how adult with neglected childhood behave like...
Personally, I like ml's friend more than the-

19 07,2025

(cont.) Fml, her lore match her personality.

I came () for the daily slop of shoujo fantasy and stayed for the cute shotas (I'm not a pedo) and ml's dad I know he's married but goddamn sir, pls call me when you devorced your wife

29 07,2025

What can a LIST do?

You may feel your favorite manga should be gathered together into distinct categories for your own reference and, now, you can do this with a LIST. After you've created your list or lists, you can proudly recommend them to other manga fans to showcase and share your taste in manga.