READ THIS after reading the newest chapter

http://www.mangago.me/read-manga/kuroshitsuji/an/manga/kuroshitsuji/v18/c095/pg-16/

Also this page clearly defined that there was another ciel....because the people who had showed in this are the ones for who the ciel regretted their death and also maybe he holds them very dear(although cant say anything for joker and doll)

Look at ciel's blood lineage, the bark under vincent's name is branched and Yana Toboso is a very detailed artist so you can't say that this theory is baseless. http://68.media.tumblr.com/1530ad68b3deb2e01b2c2e484a7b90ae/tumblr_inline_o6tq052NHR1sm83b7_500.jpg

Not my founding. just sharing what some anonymous reply to me once ^^

^ I've post this comment before and imma gonna post it again for everyone out there who dissed this theory (=・ω・=)

Yeah i had saw this earlier in manga...and was wondering what it could have been....
And i still didnt get this part...what was it trying to show?

Oh my fucking god, I'm feeling like the most stupid fuck ever. HOW DID I NEVER NOTICED THAT SCENE IN THE GREEN WITCH'S ARC. WFT? Holly christ, I'm blown away, how could I-? THAT WAS CLEARLY CIEL TALKING TO SOMEONE IN THE CAGE! NO Wait...WHO THE FUCK SCREAMED "CIEL"??? BUT- BUT IT SEEMED LIKE UNDERTAKER PUT ONE OF THEM IN A COMA???
Σ( ￣□￣||)
Aaaaagh, shit, thanks for the mind fuck

Same. The cage part was always weird to me since I saw ciel both killed and in the cage at the same time. But I never thought "Hey he might have a twin" I ignored all the weired parts that never made sense and I always thought anything said that didn't make sense was a translation mistake. I feel stupid too

But this means the story is going to get sooo much better and serious ( finally... I love all the arc but im soooo happy they are pulling them all together to form a bigger plot

I just opened the link, and can anyone tell me the first pic, that picture of Ciel in frame, is that in manga? because I feel like I have seen it before but forgot where. I may be wrong, but that pic seems like the left part of the one Agni found (the one that Agni found is the right part I guess)

I always assumed that he really got killed, but by summoning Sebastian it kinda healed him or something idk. And I remember some anime scenes that showed Ciel struggling to break free from the cult' people and then getting killed....

I dont think so...the picture that agni found seems to be a family photo...but I could be wrong

because Ciel childhood seems to wear similar clothes I was thinking that was the same picture lol. Before I found out that the color is different

That's what I thought too. But.... ow is his brother still alive after being stabbed??? (well its a manga so anything can happen...Also, I would think Ciel would throw all the family photos away immediately (if the fire didn't destroy them all in the first place). so why did they still exist. Neither Sebastian or ciel are stupid enough to not finish the job...unless its on purpose.

I've read once that it was Kuroshitsuji's official art by Yana Tooboso

OMG thank you. I was just thinking that looks similar with the one Agni found lol