:(

That doesn’t go well with the ultimate theme of the story (basically Ines having a fate she keeps straying from by choosing the wrong things) nor with how realistic this story attempts to be in terms of respecting the consequences of being with someone who isn’t in her social class.

That’s why I said alternate universe

That goes against the theme of the story. Go back and read when the Apostle was introduced. Ines never belonged with Emiliano. If it wasn’t for Oscar, a wrong choice, she never would have chosen to escape with Emiliano, another wrong choice. The story is named The Broken Ring for a reason. Everyone has their fate. Just like every timeline Ines’s parents end up together and give birth to her.

Also, the author already wrote an alternate universe with the launch of the manhwa. It was finally released as a novel last week in South Korea. Guess what it was about? Ines as a man and Carcel as a woman and it’s a romantic comedy. Everyone else keeps their original gender except the main couple. Everything the author does for TBR is all about Ines and Carcel because Ines and Carcel are soulmates.

Okay… there can still be an alternate universe where none of those rules of reincarnation existed and he gets a happy ending with her. It’s just a headcannon why are you so pressed. I love carcel too but it’s just a sad chapter for the both of them. No need to get so defensive

No. The only reason the author wrote the alternate universe is specifically for the launch of the manhwa. The Broken Ring is strictly about Ines and Carcel. The author will not violate that. Also, once this mini-arc with Emiliano ends (it’s about five chapters), that’s pretty much it for his appearance. He probably briefly shows up one or two more times still in Bilbao then that’s it. He’s barely mentioned in the side stories and the story basically ends with Ines wishing for her final death because Ines longs to rest in death eternally after living such weary lives. Emiliano is not included her wish for eternal rest.

I can make whatever headcannons I want. It doesn’t need to follow the authors goals. That’s what fanfic and fanart is about. Their own universe. You need to chill out. Touch some grass or something it’s not that serious. Who are you are to tell me I can’t ship two characters together because it’s not the authors decision. Tf

I know the first timeline carcel has 3 kids with her but that doesn’t make Emiliano’s timeline any less important. It’s just a headcannon. My comment isn’t going to change the future of this story so why even bother commenting all this shit to me. Looking at ur profile I can see you’re obsessed with this story and the characters. Just because you have your opinions on the story, doesn’t make my headcannon invalid - it’s literally just what I made up in my head. Relax broski

I hope this gets an English print cause I'd be first in line. That's such a good concept