Was scrolling past comments after I just finished reading and saw your comment. You're not crazy, I agree with your takes. I didn't think it was mid like you said because likes it and thought it was good, but I don't think it's peak or a masterpiece like others say (words I think people throw out way too easily on this site...). I also did not like Matthew, like at all. His character irks me and yeah I thought the age gap was too much especially because Jin knew Matthew when he was a freaking kid so it weirded me out at first. I'm still not entirely okay with it but they're over 18 and both consent so technically there's nothing wrong here...

Am I crazy or was this mid. I’m not trying to be a contrarian. But I didn’t like Mathew at all. It felt like he was flushed out preoperly. Also I zoned out after the orphanage origin story BC WHAT DO U MEAN YOURE SLEEPING WITH YOUR FATHER FIGURE. Also why tf did Jin forgive Mathew so easily for drugging him. That shits not normal. Also Mathew is such a hypocrite and weird. Idk what am I missing.