Honestly there's been so many conflicting statements from so many different users, some say only rated or tagged ones came back or will come back, others say they got back theirs that they never rated/tagged, so who knows at this point. In any case, wait it out until at least the week ends, and then if you still don't get any reads back try e-mailing mangago yourself on Monday.
There are some who contacted the devs via email that confirm it. But give it 1-2 weeks since restoration is pretty unstable, some users have recovered unrated ones, some even have added manga they haven't read before. It's pretty wonky/weird. The paltry amount i recovered, i never tagged or rated. I never rate or tag lol at all. The restoration goes several cycles so we're not going to be entirely sure if you get yours recovered or not until everything is mostly done. The only sure thing is its true theyre prioritizing rated/tagged
If u looked at my already read a lot are not rated and tagged. These are old titles and all that came back are mostly old mangas
https://www.mangago.me/home/people/12004/manga/3/?page=4
but I did notice that none of the Manhwa BLs and other webtoons I've read and rated are back so.. I can only wait.
Damn I'm jelly you recovered yours...TT. That's interesting since you have it backwards--lots of people are reporting that they only got the ones they rated/tagged, and the mods also say they're only recovering those. Ngl your case gives me hope so I'm thankful,, and also exactly why I'd wait it out too despite the mod email. There's too many weird errors to be sure about it, so we can only wait until things are mostly finished

I had so much stuff in my lists…but never rated anything. Does this mean I’m never getting my lists back? Nothing has come back for me at all.