I unno, if I were the guildmaster, I'd let Orc and Ayla keep their ranks and any rewards from quests, but temporarily suspend their ranking up. At most, just rank them down to D for owing up to their mistakes that, unlike many characters in this story, that acknowledge. And reminder, this is all because the quest was double booked due to an oversight from the guild. The least the guild can do is also make amends for their part and lighten their punishment.
I unno, if I were the guildmaster, I'd let Orc and Ayla keep their ranks and any rewards from quests, but temporarily suspend their ranking up. At most, just rank them down to D for owing up to their mistakes that, unlike many characters in this story, that acknowledge.
And reminder, this is all because the quest was double booked due to an oversight from the guild. The least the guild can do is also make amends for their part and lighten their punishment.