Once and for al

Dude even that the point. It doesn't help the fact there's tons of historical inaccuracies! Erza and Gerald themselves are walking breathing historical inaccuracies!
Even author admit she did not do a good job it!

I’m speaking generally here; I’ve come across various yaoi, BL, and other titles—even those outside these genres—that contain historical inaccuracies. In some of the M/M stories, one of the characters had dark skin, yet no one complained about it. Now, I don’t know if that was back before political correctness took hold, or if it was just the hormones making people overlook everything else.

Dude I never bump in a bl with REAL HISTORICAL SLAVERY and the real historical inaccurate bl are from their own time period. This was FOREIGN AUTHOR who don't know about this time period. She even admit herself.

Also want more you want from her?! This must be the most humiliating thing ever happened to her and fact her racist fans want her back, is not helping!

If I were her I will retire immediately, so if you want you precious Under the Greenlight side story. You better accept her defeat

I’m female—I’m not sure if "dude" works for both genders (I’m not a native English speaker, which is why I use Google Translate). Anyway, before this story, I didn’t know who the author was. I defend her because she never intended to write anything racist—at least from my perspective. From my POV, I gathered that she just wanted to show the character's personality, and the slavery aspect was merely a reference or something similar. Of course, including that sentence in the introduction wasn't a smart move; calling people racist when they aren't is not a good thing. The fact that a white person saving or freeing slaves is labeled as racism (based on comments I've seen) shows that the author isn't the only one who hasn't done their homework. One last thing: there are plenty of works full of historical inaccuracies—intentional or otherwise—like Tarantino's movies.

Even if Django is historical accurate or not. It's still understand the horrendous atrocities of Black Slavery

Heck The Hateful Eight black guy was wrong but it doesn't mean we don't understand why his like that. The fact you don't understand we don't excuse them they just hate each other, Highlights you understand how Media Literacy work

Also are you new to criticism? Because we been criticizing this medias for years, in fact the White Savior Trope was invented because of Media Literacy

And main reason we still have issues of inaccuracies was years of Propaganda and The Jim Crow era that still effect to this day. (As well the atrocities of crime we did to the majority is included)

Also I called people Dude as neutral gender greeting, I even used Pal the same way. Do you want me dox you, so that I can treat you probably because I don't want that???

Okay I am going to make an assumption based on you saying that you’re not a native English speaker that you’re not from America or anywhere near it, and so you potentially may not understand or know a lot about Americas history, especially when it comes to slavery and its treatment of native Americans (if I am wrong I am genuinely sorry). But I really need you to understand just how violent and disgusting these practices were, and how they still impact the USA as we know it today. Native American children were forcibly taken from their parents and forced into boarding schools where they weren’t allowed to learn their own languages or names or histories, and were pretty much forever separated from their families. Their land was taken off them and their food source the Bison was specifically hunted down so that they would starve and their population would dwindle. African Americans were slaves and were subjected to every form of abuse possible for literal generations. It is cruel and it is violent and it is horrible, and like I said earlier the effects of this are still seen today. And so when you have an author come in and decide to write a story based on this, with no clear background knowledge of this time period and its atrocities, and present us a romance between a white man who FOUGHT in the civil war (and by the way absolutely no one said white people didn’t help free slaves, but we can see within this story that it isn’t the suffering of the slaves that is going to take presedence it’s the suffering of the white man) and a Native American who says he’s going to be his ‘slave’, I’m sure you can understand how jarring it can be. Media will always have historical inaccuracies, but this isn’t an inaccuracy, it’s just wiping away generations of suffering so the author can write some cowboy story that they clearly haven’t researched enough to actually do, so yes people have every right to be mad

Dude I know that, I 100 percent know. But again are you trying to dox yourself because I never assume your not American or you really are American to begin with.

Also it doesn't stop people living bad taste in their mouth

Also I'm gonna copy past another comment I made in case why Erza is worst portray of Native American

It doesn't help it was implied that Erza being Mix Native is a outcast of being Mix Native which make no sense in history because depending what tribe Mix Native people have settlements to live on or even some native themselves accepted them. So already a bad start?

Also Erza was implied to be product of of native woman which explains his mix heritage. Which is true in reality but the name Erza itself is not a native name but a biblical name but don't worry it was explain to me he could sent to those boarding when he was a baby. I already explained the revenge part make no sense? So I already copy my comment again

If that the case Erza should known not known his native land. Because he never taught any of it. If you think Erza mother did something, no I don't think so, because it's unlikely they keep Erza mother record besides the fact she native and also I don't think they will update on her of her son and never let her sent him letter. Erza father? That not happening because Erza is clearly mix Native as heck he mostly married a white woman and have normal white family

Even Erza escape those school he will still never know any of this, because the number of tribe of Native people in America are like million. He mostly likely living on those settlements or get accepted by a another native tribes or just find odd jobs to live by

Again the odd are freaking low I don't think it's impossible

But if it about his stolen ancestral land I already explained why the Erza willing to work like slave doesn't add up

I just realized if still about his native land. Erza could just fight for his land and leave Gerald out of this, or negotiate with Gerald so the slave part unnecessary

If still about Gerald here some reason I think?
- If is still about about revenge it still make no sense for Gerald to be part it unless
•Gerald father and his father are the same man which is incest so it unlikely
•it about Gerald association which should start of Erza asking the associate name first not slave part
•Unless Gerald rape or torture or even associated of somebody closed to Erza. Not great part in Gerald
•If still about Gerald father he should ask about him first

If not Erza should killed Gerald out of spite, so I still don't understand the Slave part

For pit sake My Little Pony made a Native Land drama better than this

I didn't explain name part properly it's because those school force native children to have English name, henceforth Erza

Also I don't the author is racism and should not get harassment but this really the results of lack knowledge and ignorance

I don't think the author is racism and should not get harassment but this really the results of lack of knowledge and ignorance

Ignored this comment towards you. I thought you were the same people and you were explaining to me like I don't know.

Very sorry

I’m replying to you in a single message. I’ve always heard "dude" used among guys; I didn’t realize it was gender-neutral. Yeah, I don’t live in America and I’m not American; I’ve read up on—or watched documentaries about—many parts of history that we weren’t taught or didn’t cover in depth. I don’t think she’s racist; making a mistake—whether minor or serious—doesn’t automatically make you that way. True, she didn’t quite get the point across effectively, but she did do a bit of research. She never intended to be insulting, and in fact, she apologized. Maybe she wanted to convey the historical context by citing a dark chapter of American history without getting into too much detail, but she didn’t pull it off very well. Does she still deserve the hate she’s getting online?

Girl I don't have power to stop that and I'm not giving Jaxx some laid off because she is Korean. The moment she post this manhwa is the moment she should be treated any historical author of the US which she screwed up big time

It doesn't help the fact all her twitter post including her name is a big evidence that she into the cowboys aesthetic not the history behind. Is no different when a TikToker girl said wants things like the 1930s which was a horrible time to be a woman

Also what you want me to do??? Be Fairy Godmother and go bippity boppity boo for her reaction to stop??? If I was I make this manhwa erase in time and make sure you won't post something stupid like this again!

I think I merged the answers with the other one. From my perspective, I think if she'd written a different type of story, still with those two characters, same time period, without the unfortunate line (it would have been appropriate if it had been a different historical period and different type of story, if you know what I mean) but in a different type of story (still set in those years) as happens in various historical yaoi/bl, are you saying people wouldn't have complained anyway? For goodness' sake, I'm not asking you to take to the streets and defend her by insulting everyone. She made a mistake and apologized, it's fair to say she was ignorant. I agree with you when you wrote that she's not racist and doesn't deserve the harassment. I don't have Twitter, so I don't know what goes on there. Look, people who say "I wish I lived in that historical period because..." are truly ignorant, male or female. Like those women who wanted to live in certain years because it was good and didn't know what women went through

In fact, I don't live in America. I've read about events that aren't taught in school online over the years. We did study Luther King, though. Why is it considered racist if a white man saves/frees black slaves? I think the author, by showing the part where he gave the money, wanted to understand the guy's personality and didn't want to delve too deeply into the slavery part because it's difficult to write and show perfectly. Of course, the phrase about the slave and the master would have been appropriate if it had been a different historical period and context, since it was a phrase meant to provoke the other in a certain way. It's mainly Americans who complain about this story, so why don't they also celebrate Thanksgiving? I've read that it's a controversial holiday; some consider it a time of peace, others of massacre, because of what happened. My question is just a naive one; I don't mean to offend anyone

Dude I'm glad you acknowledge this was a stupid post but you said "it's not a master and slave" except it is.

A strongest example is Rick and Morty the lastest season they keep making fun of trope and they will not do that. Except they did and leave fans disappointed. She was about to do that except the slave part has revenge. That why we have issues with this manhwa is the first place.

Also this was about fall into another problematic called "Magical Majority Trope" which is tons of Minority of a issues with this. It's basically reverse White Savior except the Minority is only benefiting the White Savior sometimes without magic or sometime with magic.

Again I'm glad it was cancelled because it's clear as day Jaxx has no idea of this situation

Ok those slave that MC are freaking dead, for starter they have no one else to go because they were sold like puppies and have no knowledge for reading and writing. Also it's unlikely some are willing to leave, because that how abuse they're

Also those who leave are gonna get recapture or worst. Because the war is still fresh so nobody is gonna believe those slave were paid to leave, also if they do it's not easy road either the Oregon trail confirm that it's not a easy travel. The traveler are white people and have slave with them but there were free slave in that road still not a easy road. So yeah those slave a freaking dead. Also this was not Oregon trail I just used that a example they're just heading the west

So yeah it's scream Ignorance and White savior

Also the Union is a complicated mess that nobody was against slavery because all of them have money on slave labor

Here the twitter that also explain that explains more details
https://x.com/SPLover1863/status/2069512321475465603

I haven't watched *Rick and Morty* in a while; I stopped keeping up with it. But let's not dwell on that. I didn't quite grasp the part about magic—the "Magical Majority Trope." Does it mean that people without magic are treated poorly, like in *Cross Ange*? I viewed it as a "cowboy-and-cowboy" dynamic rather than "cowboy-and-slave," based on these points in the introduction: 1. Ezra, a cowboy... 2. Claiming to be Gerald's slave -> he describes himself that way, but I don't think he means it literally; he uses the word to provoke. Which, as I said, was a mistake given the context; 3. On page 16, Ezra says "my ranch." If two chapters had been released instead of just one, maybe various parts would have been corrected and it wouldn't have ended up this way. Who knows? But I’m certain the intention was never to romanticize a master/slave dynamic—which isn't even part of the story. It was just a terrible choice of words by the author

*Ok those that MC free are freaking dead
Finger was not responding from the brain

*Ok those Slave that MC free are freaking dead
God dammit not again