I mean, even if Korean authors weren’t using this trope as much back then, Japanese manga had already been using essentially the same setup for years. I’m not saying the exact “bottom has inherited debt” formula was everywhere, but the broader trope of a poor/struggling student or character getting involved with a rich, powerful, or experienced love interest absolutely wasn’t some unheard-of concept in 2019.
Straight romance manga had been recycling the same dynamic too just without the “bottom” terminology. Poor/struggling heroine + rich/powerful guy, sometimes with financial problems or some other circumstance forcing them together. That setup had already been used to death.
So saying “it wasn’t as overused 5-6 years ago” doesn’t really make the premise inherently original. Maybe it was less saturated specifically within Korean BL at the time, sure, but the underlying plot formula itself was already an old and heavily recycled romance trope. And hindsight isn’t really the issue—I’m judging the plot based on how familiar the setup actually is, not pretending it suddenly became cliché only because more stories copied it later.

Shit plot or just the same overused plot again, idk. But if I were a writer actually trying to write something with my own brain and creativity, I’d rather stop writing than recycle the same plot that’s already been used a thousand times. Like, don’t authors ever get embarrassed writing the exact same old classic setup? The ML is a fucking playboy, the bottom has debt, and somehow that’s supposed to be a “new” story. WHAT ARE YOU WRITING NEW ANYWAYS HUH