Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.

Two translations

Swalker November 7, 2026 6:36 am

Maybe it is only me (and absolutely no hate to any of the uploaders. Thank you for doing it!) but it does bother me a little that basically all works lately have two versions, that end up with only the official translation updating in the end.

Maybe it is because I enjoy fan translations a lot and it reminds me of when I started reading on this s site. Author notes about the word choice, cultural things or just commentary was a highlight of a work. And because I in a very one sided way liked to imagine how someone got to practice the languages because they enjoyed it.

But as I said. No hate to the person uploading the official translation. Appreciate the time, effort and possible money spent on doing it. Just reflecting over a trend and pondering over how things have changed now that more media gets a translation and is sold worldwide.

Responses
    Spud November 7, 2026 4:32 pm

    Man, now that you mention it, I feel nostalgic about the days of fan scan groups. Ggs, rose squad, and naonoholics were my bread and butter for a while! There's fewer active scan groups now, so I find so much joy when they upload despite the rampant LLM output. I understand why a scan group might prioritize the release of officials, and I think it's nice when they're being respectful of the author.

    I started preferring officials because they became more enjoyable to read compared to the rise in poor translations, MTL, and now "AI" (god I have so much to say about llms). Too many uploads now don't have the same consideration and etiquette towards translation and the author's work. I miss the etiquette of well-formed scan groups and power solo translators...