No, I think you're absolutely right, If you line up the timeline's it makes sense, Sienna's accident was 4 years ago and our MC is currently 4 years old. I'll bet that the reason Labella went MIA for 4 months was to hide her pregnancy (possibly due to them not being properly married at that point and due to how unstable he was at the time) and probably she wasn't able to bring her newborn along the trip that she unfortunately died on.... At least from what I can tell from the timeline's it makes perfect sense.

Is Melonie his real daughter? The dukes wife ran away, got caught in the prison and had her right? She look like a mix of both, this the only explanation