I don't think anything is wrong with creating the dj. It's a dj so the author isn't as restricted in what they can write/draw. There are people who like this type of manga. Doesn't matter how fuffy yoi is, it's still just fiction. The characters are not real people. Yes it's disturbing but the author likely did not intend for their work to be scanlated and shared with people who have no interest in their work and the genre.
I do agree.with you on a very last parts of your line but the thing is .when you have watched something that you really like and is very pure and romantic .and then get potrayed like this it does feel sad .I never said author is restricted to anything but I do think it was bad move .to made a dj like this out of yoi. Which is pure fluff.i do think it should be taken down.from here because it gore and mangago doesn't have many people here who are into that stuff
From my perspective I have to disagree because I read fucked up shit, and I've seen characters I like in a gore fucked up dj but I still think this is particularly horrible. Why? Because I just read something that just literally destroyed, RUINED someone's life. There was no stupid pleasure or illusion or whatever in it, it was just torture on the part of the character. You would know that it was just the same as killing a person if you even watched the original show whether you liked it or not. I'm not even a super YOI fan and I cried for this shit.
I will take a very famous example here.harada dj gintama where hijikata have a stokholm syndrome.it is very well like for its fucked up reason .hijikata was being chained and raped and was at the point where he thought that he don't have anyone else..it was sad his life was spoiled and it was fucked up but people liked it.why?do they enjoy people treating like dog no but sometimes it's story that is interesting..murder doesn't have pleasure in it thriller doesn't have pleasure in it people read stories which suit their mood not only for pleasure because sometimes it is interesting even it its fucked up .people like to read angsty story .do they like angst.no it's because there are times where people liek to read some angsty stuff which make them angry.to let go .no body likes to get angry now do they.see .manga make you sad .mad and angry.does that make story bad.you are feeling a emotion from here.calling a whole story bad and what happened in a story is bad are different things.story can be interesting of something bad and horrible is happening to the people.it was the reason for most people because it was yoi.
Thats why I said if you watched the original show you would know just how horrible this is. It is literally RUINING a character. The impression of yoi to anyone who watched it, they would say the same thing: it wad about a fluffy romance between 2 loving people and about chasing your dreams. The original show primarily revolved around this premise, and this shit had just ruined that very same thing: you fuck up viktor and cut his legs off and then you ruin the romantic aspect, which is almost everything yoi was based on. It was what gave viktor life. You wouldn't feel the same effect if it was any other story like what you just mentioned the GINTAMA dj. The doujin was fucked up, but it didnt target anything the character lived by, because gintama's original show wasnt anything like what happened in the doujin. You feel its more of something like a parallel universe or made up story that was horrible, but not as distressing and sad as this.
So what did you disagree on I said people disliked it because it was yoi.and you have the same point.and TBH gintama is one of my fav hijikata is strong personality.who don't take shit from anyone seeing him on a chain with his ribs hanging it's sad.they both contain psychological trauma .and are fucked up
But people didn't liked it because it was yoi.as I have already mentioned
I dont have the same point. My point is it's not just because its a yoi dj that yoi fans are hurt, coz its doesnt just hurt because its your favorite character. its because it a dj that destroyed viktors character literally, because this dj targets everything that yoi was. I made the point that that gintama dj you mentioned was horrible but it didnt feel anything realistic because the original story of gintama wasn't anything like its doujin premise. I dont love yoi like other zealous fans of yoi but I still feel so affected;
I think the main problem is not the dj it self but it was yoi dj.you know you love two beautiful fullf ball to core who are all happy and cutesy .and taste like a chocolate cake and are your favourite but then they got potrayed .in dark heavy gory way it disturbs people TBH if the çharcater was not know and made up it would have been a different story such a high risk to take yoi as gore .I think most of the people are sick and asking to delete it was because it was yoi .if this was some random characters people would have been disgusted but for different reasons .finding something disgusting in a story and finding the whole story disgusting there is a difference people find this whole story disgusting because it was based upon yoi. People liking the story but getting disgusted for what happened in the story would have happened if it were some random characters.now dislike this comment all you want many of us know here it's the truth.the main reason for the whole story to be is disgusting is because it is based on yoi.because there are people who like gorey and fucked up stuff but to random characters not for the one that people love now I would be so mad if someone does that to my hinata I can't take it .I don't think author is sick .but I think the selection of some famous çharacter was a really bad move.