Overrated: Totally Captivated, Sekaiichi Hatsukoi, Junjou Romantica, Ten Count etc...
Underrated: Koimonogatari, all of ymz's mangas, The Best Smell (it's the best bl, period, I'm telling you).
I personally like 7days lol. Hidamari ga Kikoeru was cute at the beginning, but after a while it felt too dragged out for me.
Haven't read it yet, but I'll definitely try! (Even though I highly doubt anything will make me change my n.1 ahah :P)
And I forgot before but I'll add something.
Overrated: Caste Heaven (apart from the fact that Azusa is hot, I'll give that, there's no saving point. How people can even like Karino is beyond me. And Ogawa Chise has written much better manga).
Underrated: That summer. It's not exactly BL (or at least not only), but the character development in this one is surprisingly great.
Overrated:
- 7 Days
(the drawings look like nightmares, why would anyone read that?!);
- What Lies at the End
(the characters are all horrible people presented as good guys)
- Hogu Hagyeongsu (horrific altogether)
Underrated:
Things by Furuya Nagisa...
- Gunjou no Subete
- Kimi wa Natsu no Naka
- Number Call
Random question!
WARNING! EASILY TRIGGERED PEOPLE PLEASE LOOK AWAY!
Name a BL that you thought is overrated and underrated! You understand what i mean right? Overrated : you thought it's overly famous, underrated : hidden gems!
My opinion,
Overrated :
7 days, 10 count, Make Me Bark, Okane Ga Nai, Kuroneko Kareshi, etc
Underrated :
Shimanami Tasogare, Zankoku Na Kami Ga Shihai Suru, Hidamari Ga Kikoeru, Otouto no Otto, etc
How about you? I want to know your opinions! ;))