Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.

My friend said yaoi manga is just pure hentai. I don’t think it is because it’s got a ...

Kise September 5, 2019 7:30 pm

My friend said yaoi manga is just pure hentai. I don’t think it is because it’s got a plot, but then my friend said there’s lots of erotic sex scenes ... so, what do you guys think?

Responses
    im baby September 5, 2019 7:37 pm

    hen·tai
    /henˈtī/
    noun
    a subgenre of the Japanese genres of manga and anime, characterized by overtly sexualized characters and sexually explicit images and plots.

    cheesecake September 5, 2019 7:40 pm

    bruh its hentai c'mon

    takame September 5, 2019 8:05 pm

    yes it is. why else would people moan whenever a yaoi is censored?
    shounen-ai is the more plot focused, non-porny side of BL if you wanted one.

    awwi September 5, 2019 8:14 pm

    It depends. Yaoi is used to describe BL with sex scenes in and that can mean a lot.
    It can mean it's a oneshot that's 90% sex but it can also mean there's one short sex scene after 50 chapters.
    Besides, there's also no distinction between sex scenes that are supposed to turn the readers on and sex scenes that are supposed to be disturbing.
    You can't say yaoi is porn/hentai because there's too much yaoi that isn't but you also can't say it's never hentai/porn because there's a lot of yaoi that is.

    Osale September 5, 2019 8:19 pm

    Like im baby said, hentai is a sub genre, so a yaoi manga could be hentai or not depending on the contents.
    The story shows a lot of explicit sex scenes? Then it can be tagged as hentai.
    The main characters only kissed or the sex wasn't displayed on page? Definitely not hentai.

    reii_301 September 5, 2019 8:37 pm

    depends whether he sees it in myreadingmanga or mangago. if u kno what i mean winkwonk

    takame September 5, 2019 8:41 pm
    It depends. Yaoi is used to describe BL with sex scenes in and that can mean a lot. It can mean it's a oneshot that's 90% sex but it can also mean there's one short sex scene after 50 chapters. Besides, there's... awwi

    saying it's porn doesn't mean in an entirely bad connotation. there's no need to justify and stuff. yaoi is gay erotica meant for female reader consumption. the whole world defines it as such.
    it ranges from full-on perverted to sexy and exciting. it's as simple as that.

    takame September 5, 2019 8:44 pm
    It depends. Yaoi is used to describe BL with sex scenes in and that can mean a lot. It can mean it's a oneshot that's 90% sex but it can also mean there's one short sex scene after 50 chapters. Besides, there's... awwi

    also, as someone who also reads hentai, there are also hentai mangas that are tastefully erotic. not everything is what people stereotypically dismiss hentai as... like disgusting and such.

    C H E R R Y September 5, 2019 8:51 pm
    bruh its hentai c'mon cheesecake

    lot's of them have sex in them but so do the shounen ai lol. Take for example [Mo Xiang Tong Xiu] The Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation, how is that hentai bruh?

    T-T September 5, 2019 8:55 pm

    hentai is straight stuff so no its not

    awwi September 5, 2019 9:04 pm
    saying it's porn doesn't mean in an entirely bad connotation. there's no need to justify and stuff. yaoi is gay erotica meant for female reader consumption. the whole world defines it as such. it ranges from fu... takame

    "yaoi is gay erotica meant for female reader consumption. the whole world defines it as such."
    German Wikipedia defines it as "homosexual relationship between male protagonists with explicit sexual content" (the mainly written by women part comes later).
    Which means everything with a sex scene in it is yaoi.
    OP wrote that their friend said "yaoi manga is just pure hentai", and no I don't think it is true.
    Hentai means porn manga/anime (in the west), so the question here is, is every yaoi porn? My answer to it is no because a series is not called yaoi based on the question "is it porn?" it's based on the question "is there a sex scene in it?".
    Like, there's an explicit sex scene between two male characters in Mr. Robot but that doesn't mean the entire series is just porn.
    There's a lot of sex in Game of Thrones but it's still not porn.

    I don't think porn is bad (I love porn and I'm actually bothered by how many BL authors forcibly add a storyline just to make the porn they're writing look deeper than it is) , but I just don't believe that every singel yaoi is porn, since porn is more than just a series including sex scenes.

    cheesecake September 5, 2019 9:13 pm
    lot's of them have sex in them but so do the shounen ai lol. Take for example [Mo Xiang Tong Xiu] The Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation, how is that hentai bruh? C H E R R Y

    they said yaoi not shounen ai, those are shounen ai

    cheesecake September 5, 2019 9:14 pm
    hentai is straight stuff so no its not T-T

    nah you get gay hentai too, im sure

    MrsHatake September 5, 2019 9:57 pm

    i disagree with people that are constantly calling yaoi hentai. i mean there are some with fanservice that are for sure porn, but hentai has a different style and feel to it (personally i really dislike it, and it feels empty).
    i feel like before it was more "hentaish", but it has developed as genre, plot is better and more diverse, no more clouds of sperm in separate panel etc [im being too specific]. there are still some where all you get is sex ofc. I would compare those to erotic movies. not truly porn, but still nsfw. also, a lot of them are like a movie with an explicit scene. (or maybe thats just me being used to nakedness and sex in movies, since every other serbian movie has to have that, even when its completely unrelated to the story ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭).

    But that all might just be me since i look at sex scenes from artistic point of view - is asshole really there, can his dick reach it, or has the artist has made a mistake, would that get uke to the hospital, are they defying gravity. you know, the usual stuff ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭

    Kise September 5, 2019 10:00 pm
    "yaoi is gay erotica meant for female reader consumption. the whole world defines it as such."German Wikipedia defines it as "homosexual relationship between male protagonists with explicit sexual content" (the... awwi

    Thanks this is how I justified it with my friend, like does that mean every movie/tv show is basically porn since most have at least one sex scene in them. So I don’t think all yaoi is porn either, unless there’s no storyline whatsoever or little off it and it’s just pure pornographic content.

    MrsHatake September 5, 2019 10:21 pm
    "yaoi is gay erotica meant for female reader consumption. the whole world defines it as such."German Wikipedia defines it as "homosexual relationship between male protagonists with explicit sexual content" (the... awwi

    thats kinda what ive wanted to say with my comment
    thats also why i prefer the "bl" or "gay manga" since i dont read it for the sex

    zinniaparadise September 5, 2019 11:29 pm

    I think the difference b/w yaoi nd hentai is that
    in yaoi , u add explicit scenes to spice up the story
    in hentai u add story to spice up the explicit scenes
    so both are DIFFERENT