Huh

i look at ratings when i look for something very specific, but other than that i give the story a go if it's 8.0 or up. i can't really rely on ratings tho bc sometimes i find really good comics and the rating is low

I usually don't read comics that are lower than 8,6. My favorite stories are shounen ai, which means that I like soft love stories. When i see that the rating is around 7,5 I presume that the story has things like rape, or an awful translation.

I rarely read anything below 9.0. It depends on your taste but most yaoi (bl) under this rating often have r@pe or not clear consent sexual activities. Sometimes its the art or if the story doesn't have a clear plotline. If the story is 8.9 then it just means that people have been rating the story with 4 stars.

You're missing out on a lot of very good stories. Most of the 9 above here are smut. Maybe a few years ago that would apply, but now with the proliferation of ripped licensed webtoons here that are mostly smut, the ratings have become meaningless.

Really? I’ve read a lot of things, could you recommend a few stories?

I just did a quick glance of your reading list so I just chose what I think you might read (as I said, there's plenty of good ones):
http://www.mangago.me/read-manga/josou_danshi_to_menhera_oji_san/ - 7.8
http://www.mangago.me/read-manga/metro_dog/ - 8.0
http://www.mangago.me/read-manga/samejima_kun_to_sasahara_kun/ - 8.3
http://www.mangago.me/read-manga/intertwining_lives/ - 8.6
http://www.mangago.me/read-manga/yasashii_anata/ - 8.6
http://www.mangago.me/read-manga/40_x_40_chikuwa_kaigi/ - 8.6

You also have New York, New York in your planning, so Love Circus, maybe?

Thank you so much <3