This cliffhanger is awful because not only we have to wait for a while before season two, but season two seems to be more about their past life. While I'm super curious about what happened in the past, this would mean it will take us even longer to know what happens in the present time. I hope the flashback is concise and not as long as Eternal Covenant flashback. That one lost its momentum due to the flashback taking forever to finish. I personally enjoyed sprinkle of flashbacks more than an entire season of flashback.
Same, and that used to be one of my favorites. I eventually read the rest, but I don't think it ever recovers from the lost momentum. I hope this one doesn't fall for the same trap. The flashback should serve as an explanation of what happened, and not as a distraction that makes us forget and lose interest of the present time. I say 5-10 chapters maximum. Any longer would hurt the pacing. The second season should not just be about the past life.
That, I didn't have the problem, because unlike Office Hero, both main characters reincarnated, in Eternal Covenant, Sol doesn't. For him, Brian and Ian are the same. Even then, Sol understood that Ian may not feel the same, so he never forced Ian to be with him nor does he forced Ian to get Brian's memories. This is why Sol kept secrets from Ian. He wants Ian to keep his own autonomy and not binded by his past life.
That said, the problem of that series isn't that. It's actually the pacing. I get the importance of the flashback, but it's a problem if the flashback is way longer than the present time. By the time, the story returns to the present, it's difficult to get reinvested into the story. So far, Office Hero has a very good pacing. It juggles the flashbacks and present time way better than Eternal Covenant. I hope the author keeps it that way.
The names of the characters in this series are based on stars and other natural things.
Byeol - Stars
Sung Woon - Sung is also stars. Woon is cloud. Both main characters have stars in their names, hence the title, Between the Stars.
Hyesung - Comet
Taeyang - Sun. The side couple's chapter is titled, Between Comet and the Sun.
Other side characters have the same theming.
Sung Woon sister is Galaxy.
Taeyang's older brother is Moon, and his younger brother is Earth.
The blond-haired guy is Sea. The doctor is Sky. these two are supposed to be the third couple if the author ever decided to make it.
Other miscellaneous trivia, Taeyang's moles are based on constellations. The front corresponds to Hyesung's birth month Capricorn, and the back corresponds to Taeyang's birth month Cancer.
Now that we know what the title means, it's actually really hilarious in hindsight. The ML is correct. He is lucky. Everything goes his way. He got the MC served to him on a silver platter. Yet, somehow these two idiots made the whole situation ten times harder than it should be because neither of them communicate their feelings. It's like someone hit a blackjack, but instead of proclaiming their win, they take another card to ruin it.
How do you write a long love story involving two people who are already in love? Add in a bunch of misunderstanding, miscommunication, characters that refuse to communicate, and characters that have stunted emotional capacities. This story would have ended in 5 chapters if the characters are just being honest. One of my favorite BL has less than 30 chapters because the couple actually talk. When it ended, I wanted more. This one though, it's like a test of patience whether I can read it until the end. What a waste of the gorgeous art.
I get what you're saying, and I actually hate the miscommunication trope too. But the problem here is that even if they had talked, even if the MC had tried to confess his feelings to the ML in the first two or three chapters, I don't think it would have changed anything. The ML is literally an immature child who doesn't give a fuck about anyone, and you can't even deny that. He's fully aware of how he behaves, yet he doesn't actually do anything to change himself. That's literally his whole personality.
So even if the MC had communicated his feelings, I don't think the ML would have taken them seriously enough for anything to change. That's why I think something more drastic was needed to get through to him, something that would force him to understand the consequences of his actions. Sometimes, a person who is fully aware of their own flaws still refuses to change until they actually have to face the consequences of their behaviour. And I think that's exactly what the ML needed. He had to experience something that would finally make him understand how badly he'd been treating the MC and why his behaviour was wrong.
Honestly, I think this could have been handled in 20 chapters if the author had wanted to. But since miscommunication is the main trope, the author is obviously going to drag it out for 100 chapters instead.
I respectfully disagree. I feel the way you think is exactly what the MC is doing now - jumping to conclusion. The MC never tried because he already decided he knew the answer. Generally speaking, misunderstanding and miscommunication tropes are there to drag the inevitable, because if the truth be known, then there is no more drama to be had. The author had to make the characters do everything except for speaking their minds, because the author knew there is not much story to tell otherwise. I would respect this story much better if the MC spoke his mind earlier and got rejected, and we can focus on the ML problem after that, rather than using the ML problem as an excuse of why the MC cannot spit it out.
Chanran hard carries this series. While the plot in general is interesting, it works so well because Chanran's charm is off the chart. While I don't usually like someone who is good at everything because they scream Mary Sue, Chanran somehow manages to be relatable in spite of it. Perhaps part of it is owed by the humorous translation. The references never fail to make me laugh.
Since a lot of people are confused and getting some details wrong, or feeling there is no progression, here is the summary of what happened so far.
- Dohu and Juheon reunited after 4 years. Juheon pretended not to know Dohu.
- Dohu tricked Juheon to reveal himself, but Juheon didn't want anything to do with Dohu. He went as far as to pay Dohu to quit his job. Dohu refused.
- Juheon found out Dohu's drunken habit now includes Dohu going back to Juheon's old apartment. Juheon momentarily let Dohu in. Dohu used this chance to tell Juheon his feelings. Juheon was shaken, but steadfast in rejecting Dohu.
- Juheon noticed Dohu hasn't been eating, so he invited Dohu to eat. Once again Dohu used this chance to ask Juheon if there was other reason to him leaving.
- Juheon didn't tell Dohu, but it was revealed Juheon's aunt threatened Juheon in regard to Dohu. Combined with his trauma of being abandoned, Juheon chose to leave Dohu.
- Juheon's shooting got sabotaged by Park Gitae, Juheon's fellow actor and Dohu's childhood bully. Gitae was jealous of Juheon, and the sabotage ended with Juheon getting injured.
- Dohu once again confronted Juheon. Juheon in severe pain, decided to play the bad guy and hurt Dohu to make sure Dohu leave him once and for all, but he couldn't 100% go through with it. The two had a very uncomfortable sex.
- Dohu didn't buy Juheon's act to push him away. Instead he reasserted his love for Juheon and forced Juheon to eat medicine and brought him to hospital.
- The two made a pact that they will meet 5 times and if it didn't work out, Dohu had to leave. Though Dohu had no intention to leave.
- Behind the scene, Juheon hired a private eye, most likely to investigate his aunt. He had some kind of a plan to bring her down. It seems that his aunt has been stalking him and made his life hell in the last 4 years, so Juheon chose to be an actor in a retaliation.
- Juheon also used the private eye to investigate Dohu relationship with Park Gitae, of which the private eye didn't tell him that Dohu had been taking medication this whole time.
- Dohu rewritten the script as a way to get back to Park Gitae, and Gitae ended up being embarassed by Juheon during shoot.
- Gitae realizing it was Dohu's fault, confronted Dohu and Dohu who had been feeling unwell recently, ended up fainting.
- Juheon brought Dohu to hospital, met with Dohu's sister and discovered Dohu has been taking medication all this time. In anger, Juheon asked his private eye why he didn't report this to him.
Anyway, those who said there is no progression are not paying attention. It is slow, very slow, but there is almost always some kind of progression each chapter. We have gone from Juheon pretending not to know Dohu, blocking Dohu's phone, to now the two having more intimate moments and learning more about each other.
We are now at a very pivotal moment, as one of the biggest reasons for Juheon leaving Dohu is his own assertion that Dohu would be fine without him and his fear of being abandoned by Dohu. Now it is revealed that Dohu is absolutely not fine without him. This opens the door to Juheon realizing that his assumption about Dohu has been wrong all along.
I just want to add regarding Juheon's family matters:
His aunt has been locking Juheon's grandfather who has dementia away for the sake of becoming the one who manages all his assets despite how the grandfather already pointed someone else to be his legal guardian. Juheon got the footage of this and intended to reveal this to the public when his popularity is at the peak, so he could go down along with his family as his revenge
For the first time, the root of Juheon's problem is revealed. Even right from the very beginning, Juheon has the tendecy of assuming everything on his own. From mistakenly believing Dohu had a crush on him, to believing Dohu would be fine without him, everything was all in Juheon's head. No matter how much Dohu tried to talk to him, nothing would go through if he already made up everything in his mind. The first step for this relationship to work is for Juheon to stop assuming things in regard to Dohu.
This author really likes to make their uke suffer and be walked all over. While the story is very well written, I'm not sure if I enjoy this archetype. Baekhee believed he has no way out of the situation, so he is choosing what he considered the best for himself, even if it's making him miserable. Pride be damned as long as you survive. Everything makes perfect sense and I feel for him, but at the same time, I wish there is a bit more backbone in this character, like a bit more fight in him. It's frustrating to watch him being walked all over, and he is self aware of what is happening, yet does nothing but accepts it.
The most unrealistic part about this story is Taeyang being unpopular. Are the people in this story blind? He is like the hottest and sexiest man in the entire series, and no girls are gawking over him? Nobody before Hyesung tell him he is hot and sexy? Extremely unrealistic. The fact that only 2 guys are into him is just unreal. It's even weirder considering his personality, mature, kind, cordial, and always helping others. The only way to make sense of this is if the story is seen through the eyes of Hyesung, and Hyesung somehow sees his hyung in rose tinted glasses and the real Taeyang is average.
Jokes aside, Taeyang is really a great character. I enjoyed the story for the most part, but Taeyang is the main reason why this story is amazing for me. I have seen some people asking for recommendation of characters like him. Despite reading a butt load of BL, I honestly don't remember anyone quite like him. Normally, cool characters tend to be more aloof, and Taeyang isn't quite aloof. Mature characters tend to be older, and Taeyang isn't that old. Physically weak or sickly characters tend to be more meek, and Taeyang despite his past is anything but meek. Sexy alluring characters tend to be promiscuous, but this dude has close to zero admirers and zero dating life. I have to say Taeyang is one of a kind, which is very rare to find in the mountain of slops era nowadays.
There is this phrase, "All the good men are taken." In real life, if there is actually someone like Taeyang, good-looking on top of having good personality, he would have already been taken. While I did mention Taeyang's personality, I also put a lot of emphasis of him being good-looking. It's this combination that made it especially unrealistic that no one other than 2 guys look his way.
As a story, I like it, but if you believe there is someone like Taeyang in real life, an actual good-looking dude with good personality that is unpopular and has never dated before, well, good luck finding one.
To be fair, the story literally explains why he avoids getting close to people (especially dating), he wants to avoid feeling guilt as his entire childhood it’s all he ever felt, like his illness was a burden to those he cared for. Hence why it took some time for him to open up to hyesung. It’s not unrealistic for nice people to remain single, it’s a choice he’s making for his own conscience. It’s definitely not a flaw in the story since it’s intentional, I think you missed that in his character writing lol :)









I like how the first time Kirato realized he liked Yuuji romantically was at the end of chapter 1. Normally, stories like this usually involved one character liking the other since childhood, but neither of them were in love as children. They were just really close friends whose relationship naturally evolved as they grew up, and we saw the entire process since chapter 1.