Sooyona

How could she know how they acted in the past. do u remember your everyday life when u were 6? 7? 8?

Yes, I do remember how my life used to be. It's true that I don't remember every day in detail but I remember how people used to be in general.

Well... because she needs? She isn't there on her free will. She is inside a novel and need to play that role to go back to the real world. Think of the last Jumanji film where they are sent inside the game and need to finish it to go back to reality...
Honestly that's purely plot armor... cuz if she found out he is the reason she wasn't able to go home after everything... she'd probably hate him... even more if that means she won't ever be able to go home because of the changes in the plot...

No one dies in his own free will. Everybody would die one day. Isn't this a second chance for her to live?
I agree with it be a plot armor but I think the way it now makes the Fl look like a stupid person which I don't like.

That's the thing... it's not said she died... she wasn't isekaied there to live a second life however she wanted... she was told by whatever sent her there that the only way for she to return to her own life was completing the role of Biche... so I wouldn't call it a second chance... ╮(￣▽￣)╭
Oh... I also don't like it... I also don't like where this is going overall... like... giving up her og life over love or something... it would be a different case if he followed her to the real world tho...

She just thinks that. We are not sure if she will really go back. If I were her I will be scared to give up on my second chance while I'm not certain if I can go back to my first life. She just thought she heard a voice in her head once when she came to this world so we can’t be so sure that's not something she created in her head because she couldn't accept her new life.
I don’t see any problem with her staying in this world if she’s happy. What’s the difference between her first and second life? She lived in the first world as much as she did in the second world. She has a family in both worlds and lived her childhood in both worlds. I support her no matter what her choice is. But the only thing I hate when she treats the people around her as a character in the book. She forgot that they’re flesh and blood now.

How could u know the voice she heard isn't real?? She doesn't treat them as characters, well she does in her first life there but it changed. As she said she regrets not having time with her father. She just treated the twins bad cause they were terrible.

She said she wanted to have fun and be with the ml too but bc she heard a voice say she could go back if she acted her role.

She doesn't know why she went back so as a conclusion she thought she didn't did a good job and continue to do her role better
(〜￣△￣)〜

Right?
Truth is that I find weirder when the mc doesn't know if she died, like went to sleep and woke up there, and just goes oh I guess this is my life now...

People got so used to Mcs just accepting it that they forget reacting like the Mc of "Kill the Villainess" is more in tune with how someone would really react to it. And her situation is more in tune with "Happy Ending for the Time-Limited Villainess" ... just instead of being sent home someone forced her to go back in time because someone couldn't get over her death...
They need to read the first and second chapters again to understand she doesn't really want to be there...
If you want another example of how someone normal and someone abnormal would react to being sent to another world there's also "FFF-Class Trashero" as the name implies... he gets fed up with being forced to live that life and acts trashy... to the point they "summon" someone else to be a hero too to show him how he should act... his first impression of the other guy is something along: how much of a delusional lone loser otaku this guy must be in real life to be happy about being abducted like this.

They keep saying it's not certain she would be sent home... but it's also not certain she wouldn't be sent back and that someone's meddling that stopped it from happening.

If she ends up giving up returning to her world out of "love" for certain someone who is obviously involved in the turning back of time... I'll describe it in two words: Stockholm Syndrome. The only acceptable end to me would be he giving up on his life in that world to follow her to her Og world. After all why should she be the one giving up her og life and learning to live in a different world with a different family technology and whole way of life and not him?

I said we are not sure. Maybe it’s real maybe not.
You’re saying she didn’t treat them just as a character which I disagree with. She lived with her father for years. Her father loved her so much and treat her well. Even if she just considered him as an adopted father that’s enough. But what she calls him? THIS BODY FATHER!!
I think you’re just using Stockholm Syndrome wrong here. He didn’t hurt her or prison her. For him, she died protecting him so he goes back in time to protect her. How can that be him causing a harm to her? He didn’t even know she has another world to go back to. Stockholm Syndrome isn’t something we learn and use it everywhere. If she chose to stay because she is happier that’s her right.
Besides She could not go back to her world because he didn't live his life like the original novel so even if he didn’t turn the time back she wouldn’t return to her world. Are you saying he has to sacrifice all his life for her and become a killer just for her to go back to her world? He don’t want to live like that. You say she can’t chose this world because of love but at the same time you say he has to live his life as she want because of love?!!

I didn't say anything abt "Besides She could not go back to her world because he didn't live his life like the original novel"
I meant she thought that was the reason she return back in time

"Are you saying he has to sacrifice all his life for her and become a killer just for her to go back to her world?"
I was explaining to u what her situation is. I never said he has to do all of that for her. The fl is just trying to go home (the home/world she misses)

"He don’t want to live like that. You say she can’t chose this world because of love but at the same time you say he has to live his life as she want because of love?!!"
Fl doesn't know/realize she loves ml yet (that's the point of the story.) At this point fl is probably really wants to go home. The Novels original story is her only solution she knows and the voice she her

Also idk what u meant by Stockholm syndrome cause I did not mention it. I did not type anything abt poison or abuse. (Or maybe u confuse me over Nizze's reply)

I know what stockholm syndrome is
(Killing Stalking", "Star Reborn: The Queen's Return" are one of the Manhwa, Novel I read related to Stockholm syndrome)

Yeah sorry. If you get abducted from your daily life and an accomplice (someone that didn't kidnap you) who is living in the place you are held captive stops you from leaving because he fell for you and you end up giving up your normal life to stay there because you fell in love with them... that doesn't seem that far away from it.
Look... she didn't have to turn him into a tyrant. She had to be his childhood friend and die in his place as the one who killed his father. That was her role and that's what she did. You say that to him he was saving her but if he told her that soon after she woke up she would be mad af.
It's different she choosing that life cuz she is happier there than in her original world and she trying to be happy there because she believes she can't go back. And it was made clear in the first time that she chose her original life. If she heard that voice again saying that something went wrong but was not her fault and that if she killed herself now she would be sent to her world she would do it.
She made clear in the 1st chap that it was her coice to be blamed and die in his stead. He didn't have to turn into a tyrant after that but just accept her choice and death. They are both selfish in their own ways. And I dislike both.
╮(￣▽￣)╭