This is SO underrated
I read the novel, and if you compare this to the novel it would obviously be lacking (only 11 chaps) but the author did a wonderful job with so little
Only thing that bothers me, even from the novel, was the age gap between Edmond and Haydee.. It’s clear they love each other and don’t care but the near 20 year age gap between them is hard to forget sometimes
What happened to Sungyeon after the side story ending? I read on another comment he commit suicide but idk
Istg I always see these fujoshi commenting on shounen ai asking the same shit “wHoSE tHe sEmE and UKe” wtf?? cant you guys just enjoy the story? if you’re looking for some smut then read yaoi
Also lowkey disgusting(+ironic) how yall read BL but stereotype the top/bottom role, like why tf do you use it as a qualifier of strength??? (For example somehow if someone identifies as a bottom they can’t stand up for themselves) What should matter more is their compatibility, healthy relationship, stuff like that...
literally nobody said thats what a bottom is..
if u said thats a bottom then thats how u view them...
people are asking who the seme and uke is cuz in SHOUNEN AI the smexy scenes are usually not there...so we need to know whose top and bottom so we can ATLEAST imagine..its clear from the story both of them are EQUALLY strong mentally and physically...
stop throwing hate at fujoshis just cuz SOME fujoshis are like that doesnt mean ALL of them are..
everybody has a different way of enjoying a story..some write fanfics..some imagine different scenarios..and some read the story for the sake of it with ZERO imagination..
and we like to have fun..so knowing the top and bottom is like opening a whole new world to our imagination..NOBODY SAID WE NEED TO KNOW WHO IS TOP AND BOTTOM SO WE CAN DEGRADE THE BOTTOM..tf is wrong with u?
Nobody?? A ton of people stereotype uke that way, even in lgbtq community(nasty)
“if u said thats a bottom then thats how u view them...” Sorry, are you blind or can you not read? I never said that
“stop throwing hate at fujoshis just cuz SOME fujoshis are like that doesnt mean ALL of them are...” I already knew that, but a MAJORITY of them are that way. If it doesn’t apply to you then move on stop acting salty for no reason
I’m not saying they’re degrading the bottom. I’m saying they’re stereotyping the bottom based on appearance/strength/masculinity which is wrong. I know that everyone has a different way of enjoying a story but, like I said before, that’s literally not my point. I don’t understand your comment bc it doesn’t pertain to what I’m talking about at all and I can see you didn’t get the point Read my comment again and make a response/argument that makes sense, thank you
THERE WAS ONLY ONE COMMENT ASKING "who is uke and seme"
and nobody in the comments mentioned anything bout bottoms being weak or lacking strength...urs was the only comment which brought that up..b r u h
hence ur the one who brought that up which makes it how u view them.. knowing who the uke or seme is doesnt immediately make it a yaoi...
YAOI LITERALLY MEANS NO POINT..which means its made purely for smut...
there are shounen ai's with smut but they are called shounen ai cuz it has a story aside from the smexy scenes..
like nobody stereotyped anything...
if we did stereotype then it would be quite obvious who the uke or seme would be at this point..but it isnt..so stop bout the stereotypes..
if a ton of people stereotyped then..sure okay but why were there no other comments
specifying "oh ___ would be uke cuz he looks weak/hes short/girly" or some shit...urs was the only comment...ur claiming people stereotyped without any proof...so stop embarrassing urself..
and if there is a comment out there that did stereotype..then call them out..
u mentioned fujoshi's as a whole..if ur aware that NOT ALL of them are like that..then u should've mentioned it...
its not okay to call fujoshis out in general when ur aware they all aint like that...what would the ones who legit r there for the story...like make us clowns why dont u?
im aware that the bottoms in the lgbtqia community are also stereotyped against..i have many gay friends whose "boyfriends" broke up with them cuz they werent GUYISH enough and bs like that..i admit that shits disgusting and they ARE being real jerks...i myself am part of the community(im a cis female who is pan) and see it everyday...and noone stereotyped the bttom based on appearance/strength/masculinity...
one question "who is the seme and uke" where in that is everything u mentioned...
either im blind or u dont know how to read.. ╮(￣▽￣)╭
i dont like arguing in this website...its too precious for arguments for me..so imma stop here..i dont wanna talk bout this more(づ￣ ³￣)づ
Preach girl
idk what the rest of the replies here are talking about, youre right. there so much BS especially here, as an lgbtq person its disgusting
Oh yes thank you! Tbh this seme/uke thing will not go away so soon but I wish people would shut up about it! I've seen so many people rating a manga 2 or 1 star with the comment "i expected to be the seme to be the uke." I mean how shallow could that be? And people attacked my comment in Love Stage because the main couple is gonna try (or already tried. Im not updated) switching.
Ffs, its a gay story for a reason. Man on man. Theyre both blessed to be in a relationship where you could penetrate and be penetrated. These folks are the worst type of fans.
Btw, im not only talking about sex here. Its not bad if youre just having fun on determining who's seme or the uke. Im talking about hardcore fujoshis who shit talk a manga because the seme they wanted turned out to be an uke. If youre not like that then good for you.
One comment?? Were you only checking the recent ones?
I’ve been following this bl for a long ass time now I see people stereotyping this shit all the time so stop the bs. Are you dumb
“ur claiming people stereotyped without proof...” Dude are you fr right now like you actually want me to go through every comment on this shounen ai and link you the specific ones
Yes I’m aware not all fujoshi are like that, so chill out. I mentioned that in my last comment, didn’t I?
Yeah, if I had to choose, maybe you’re blind... “i have many gay friends whose “boyfriends” broke up with them cuz they werent GUYISH enough” I do know this happens rl but way more fem twink guys (who like to top) are targeted like this
There are feminine uke all over the site, even their personality is the same way, it’s like a girl with a dick. Ah, well.. You said all this controversial shit then decided to end the argument, so whatever
Fr I see that stuff happen all the time!! They rate the manga so low bc they’re unsatisfied with the seme/uke position and it makes me so angry
I agree with this so much oh my god thank you for speaking about this.. I do read these kind of comments all the time so it pisses me off... Also at the same time I hate it when the seme refuses to bottom for the uke and idk why...
Damn idk why this seme/uke role matters so much just enjoy the story ffs
This has been going on since 2015 and we’re still stuck in the flashback. Is this gonna be done 2030??
what flashback?
no joke though it’s literally been going on forever
We’re seeing a flashback right now when they’re in mid school. Right now it’s all happy and fluff but there’s gonna be a lot of angst in the future bc they got seperated/Jian yi got kidnapped n all that drama...
What chapter are you on?
remember the early chapters where jianyi appeared at xixi's door, wearing a high school uniform from chapter 43 to 50? chapter 51 until the most recent update are just the flashbacks of what's happening in their last year at mid school before jianyi disappeared at their second day of highschool, sorry if i explained terribly. i tried.
you can see the difference in their school uniforms and they also mentioned a few times that they are middle schoolers, jianyi and xixi also planned to graduate and get into the same highschool together
Wait even while they went to the mountains and the beach?
He was already kidnapped but he was recused that's why he is living with Tian or at his brother's house whichever it is.
yes, they have not graduated from mid school yet. they are fifteen all along ╮(￣▽￣)╭ and they are also legal since the age of consent in China is 14 if you're concerned about it. and this manhua is still ongoing from 2014 till now, so many assumed that the author herself forgot the plot itself since 19 days was originally just a slapstick random comedy and not some drama/tragedy tagged shounen ai
the second kidnapping is when jianyi got into highschool, not really kidnapping since it's his own father, you can read the early chapters back to understand the timeline better(づ￣ ³￣)づ
Thank you, someone needs to make a timeline chart or something lol
it's okayy i was confused at first too (≧∀≦)
Haha i kinda agree. The author prolly forgot what the main plot is since it’s been running for a looooong time already.
The first attempted kidnapping was when Jian Yi’s Dad wanted to see him but his mom intervened. The other one was by a beggar of some sort, if I remember correctly.
WTF so he just fucked some girl, got dumped, DIDNT EVEN TAKE A SHOWER and wash away the sin, then proceeds to rape his step-brother? Mf get it together
I'm just hoping the first couple will show up here bc this already looks boring af #－.－)
Why is it that this author is so good at making incredibly unlikable, foolish, "hard-to-get" female leads ._.
Strongly agreed.
If I’m paying someone (nearly) 300 usd just to go to a fucking party and they show up an HOUR LATE
All you had to do was show up and socialize ITS NOT THAT HARD, even I’m an introvert and I’d take that deal for $300
On god I’m robbing them when the party is over