Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.
MangaSanctuary November 29, 2023 12:27 pm

Shiki:
Back at you, my dude.
You also need a hobby if you find the time to write all this about me and I'mGayAndYouKnowIt. I told what I had to say and you're still here provoking me...?
Blocking people, then manage to call them out like you do is a bit coward and hypocrite of you. But anyways, have fun and think what you want if that can make you feel better ^_^
However please, for the Love of God, let people have different opinions than yours, that won't kill you and this will make this comment section a better place for everyone.

    I'mGayAndYouKnowIt November 29, 2023 3:50 pm

    I'd like to add that preaching about the popularity of the manhwa in an illegal platform is dumb

    Shiki, your support doesn't mean shit. The author would have been as offended by your support. I know. I have a history of reporting mangago to authors

    Unlike you, I read my favorite BL/yaoi legally. This one wasn't worth the money

    Sanctuary and I wouldn't have shoved our comments down your throats, if you and the authors didn't shove "straight" porn or your opinions down our throats

    "Closed-minded?" Don't be so open-minded that your brains fall out. It's too late, though. Your brains have fallen out already

    MangaSanctuary November 29, 2023 10:49 pm
    I'd like to add that preaching about the popularity of the manhwa in an illegal platform is dumbShiki, your support doesn't mean shit. The author would have been as offended by your support. I know. I have a hi... I'mGayAndYouKnowIt

    "I have a history of reporting mangago to authors"
    "Your brains have fallen out already"

    You still success to make me laugh despite the toxic atmosphere, thanks for that. I know I can count on you if one day my work get uploaded against my will on this site :p

    I only hope for this Shitki and their fellows to know that every complainant reader that they encourage heavily to drop CDA, means less money and less support for the author and artist they like so much.
    They should take exemple on JustCallMeApple, a person who is often in the comment section of Into the Rose Garden; she's so friendly, understanding and makes even a Yaoi like ITRG worth reading. I couldn't even stomach that manhwa due to all the r*pe and abuse, but after speaking with that avid reader, I came to question myself if I shouldn't give it another chance and finally that's what I'm gonna do (at least for the S2 and 3). If a comment section ever needs a "guardian", she's the kind of person that I'd like to find.

    I'mGayAndYouKnowIt November 29, 2023 11:24 pm
    "I have a history of reporting mangago to authors""Your brains have fallen out already"You still success to make me laugh despite the toxic atmosphere, thanks for that. I know I can count on you if one day my w... MangaSanctuary

    We need humor to cope with the toxicity. The rawness of our fear and sadness, and the aspect of social isolation, have created the perfect conditions for unprecedented humour. It's a "safety net" that cultivates resilience and courage

    I wanted to be the person that gives you the courage to continue

    It's my first time hearing about JustCallMeApple. I'd like to meet her. She sounds like a lovely person!

    MangaSanctuary November 30, 2023 12:32 am
    We need humor to cope with the toxicity. The rawness of our fear and sadness, and the aspect of social isolation, have created the perfect conditions for unprecedented humour. It's a "safety net" that cultivate... I'mGayAndYouKnowIt

    You're already are, my friend. Tbh that dictatorship and censorship comment section is so depressing and gloomy that if not for your dark humor I'd left that place already.
    Yes, humor is a salvation and alleviates a lot of tension, and you seem good at that.

    You can find JustCallMeApple in the comment section of Into the Rose Garden, she's always there giving spoilers and infos to people. Yeah, she's nice and passionate about that story; I spent more time reading her spoilers than reading the actual manhwa =D
    I think authors of ITRG should give some royalties to her because she has a formidable sense of persuasion to make people read that controversial Yaoi and not drop it. She's an excellent story teller/spoiler teller ^^

lotus November 28, 2023 9:30 pm

Can JUJUCAT, as an uploader, stop harassing whoever who shares a topic that have a negative opinion on this manhwa?
Can they stop throwing personal attacks to commentators, assuming things and then run away after.
This is actually a coward and hypocrite behavior: at least face the mess you've created.
Can they stop abusing of their "status" whenever they see a comment that doesn't favor CDA? Aren't you too arrogant? But at the same time, acting like a puss*

Because they also upload this manhwa and has a lot of followers, they think they can do whatever they want; ridicule whoever shares a negative view on this manhwa, get people out of BL community, or ban, report people with dissident voices... What is this, DICTATORSHIP?
That's how you are, Jujucat, abusing of your "status", and you know perfectly that by throwing a nasty comment to someone, your supporters and "fans" are gonna come in mass to lick your ass and defend your pov. Someone "in your position" should've known better, however since TRASH should reveal themself sooner or later, thanks for showing your true face to us. Because you share yaoi chapters for people to eat, you think you have every right, and can behave like holier-than-you? SHAME ON YOU.

I've never witnessed such rude and arrogant behavior from any uploader before.

Either Jujucat let this community BE and breath, or they keep THEIR translations and uploads to themself, if they're so scared of negative comments and can't help but intervene themself - not to reply to the actual comment, but to throw a fit to the commentator and run away. This already happened a few times here already. Do you think this is fair and acceptable, people? I'm not selling my soul to the devil to get "free" yaoi. If anything I'll avoid their uploads from now on.

You guys want for every person who dislike something in CDA to drop the reading? NO WORRY, many already dropped this "BL" and people are gonna continue without you encouraging them. Infortunately, this plot has more than a few problematic, questionable points, so you'll likely be ending up amongst yourself like you wished, in the end. Enjoy loneliness.

    FoxOsnakes November 28, 2023 10:32 pm

    The problematic stuff is the best part bestie we'll have fun without bitches whining in our ears everytime a new chapter comes out

    bri ఌ November 28, 2023 11:51 pm

    are you gonna stop bitching about the hetero scenes in the manhwa? stop whining and drop the manhwa already. you’re wasting your time crying about the uploader and saying they’re “harassing” over ONE comment. its honestly so embarrassing for you for commenting on this manhwa multiple times saying you hate it. like no one gives a shit. grow up, accept that hetero scenes exist in BL.

    Capicity November 29, 2023 1:56 am

    Werent you the one who was harassing everyone because they didn’t disagree with the hetro scenes lol

    Shiki November 29, 2023 2:00 am

    You’re embarrassing.
    You’ve been going on a comment spree on this manhwa FOR DAYS, so has that “imgayandyouknowit” person who kept going on a hetrophobic comment spree.
    Yes, this manhwa has hetro scenes.
    Was juju harassing anyone? No. He simply replied back to someone who kept throwing hetrophobic remarks at him. Get fucking for real bro lol

    MangaSanctuary November 29, 2023 8:41 am

    Shiki:
    You should be the ones to be embarrassed.
    Obviously, you're talking out of your ass and don't even know that your Jujucat has systematically replied to anyone who shares a negative opinion here on CDA in a rude manner, using personal attacks on them, instead of replying to the comment. The topics aren't there anymore surely because something happened or they deleted their topic.

    But I'm not surprised by your moronic behavior. Instead of saying "I know nothing" and go on your way, you defend that person like they're your god, problem is you're completely in the wrong.
    I hope that after this, Jujucat will stop harrassing commentators for simply sharing a different opinion, if not, you'll see for yourself how your idole behaves. Though it won't be a surprise to see that even after that you keep on saying they did nothing wrong. Apparently Yaoi has eaten your brain and you've sold your sould to get more of it, how corrupted can you be?

    MangaSanctuary November 29, 2023 8:49 am

    You only confirm further away what I described in my topic:

    "... your supporters and "fans" are gonna come in mass to lick your ass and defend your pov."

    Should we give to you guys a medal for being so good and loyal to a trash person?

    I'mGayAndYouKnowIt November 29, 2023 9:06 am
    are you gonna stop bitching about the hetero scenes in the manhwa? stop whining and drop the manhwa already. you’re wasting your time crying about the uploader and saying they’re “harassing” over ONE co... bri ఌ

    You're bitching about us bitching. How are you any different?

    Some of us aren't okay with the "straight" scenes. Grow up and accept that not everyone will like the things you like

    I'mGayAndYouKnowIt November 29, 2023 9:26 am

    They say we are "heterophobic." The word "-phobic," among others, has become maddeningly confusing in current usage. All thanks to the "straight" identifying people who play the victim and refuse to take responsibility for the circumstances they are in

    Is it e.g. "mintphobic" to dislike mint chocolate ice cream? Or express that dislike? Why would it be -phobic to dislike "straight" scenes in a gay story? Are people not allowed to have preferences?

    The belief that all disparities are due to some "discrimination" implies that differences in preference do not exist. This disparity or anger is due to some of us not having an interest in the "straight" lifestyle or porn—which is hardly a character flaw or evidence of some inadequacy

    MangaSanctuary November 29, 2023 10:40 am
    They say we are "heterophobic." The word "-phobic," among others, has become maddeningly confusing in current usage. All thanks to the "straight" identifying people who play the victim and refuse to take respon... I'mGayAndYouKnowIt

    More and more, we have the "woke" movement developping in France as well, with SOME travestites/trans people doing lectures in their disguise in school to small kids. While parents are saying nothing or don't dare to express their opinion, this has caused ruckus amongst the lgbt+ community, where some gay guys are voicing their disagreement with such lectures to kiddos. The gay dudes are labelled "transphobic" by these people and bullied by their supporters, despite supposely being all part of the lgbt+

    Labelling something "phobic", especially regarding these social terms (bi, straight, homo, trans...) avoid to question and discuss about the core problem of a matter. It directs the attention to a simplistic and gross aspect, while real problems aren't discussed. This is a way to shut the mouth of someone.
    If we're to give a simple exemple: you dislike sugar, I like sugar, "Omg you're a sugarphobic", while notions like eating too much sugar can give health problems to a person aren't adressed...

    I think you also know Sadistic beauty. In the main story, it's all josei. Author had to make "side stories" for the yaoi and yuri. Why didn't they just mix everything together, and voilou, if people like such mixture so much?
    The same, we can count on our 10 fingers the number of BLs where we can see such numerous and graphic hetero scenes with the male protagonists, and there's a precise explanation to that.

    MangaSanctuary November 29, 2023 11:21 am

    Labelling me "straightphobic" must be a desperate attempt or a very ignorant thing to say.
    I'm a woman, straight, so straight that I like to read stories where there are handsome boys only, exclusive relationships between the male MCs, gay smut scenes between them. This is called a BL, Yaoi, it's a category different from Josei, straight porn. This has been like this since the creation of Mangas; each category has codes and how things should be written, drawn and done... You won't see Shonen elements in a Shojo, otherwise it's a Shonen with a girl as the heroin, or a romance Shojo but destined to boys (Video Girl Ai).

    Though, despite being straight, there is a limit where even I can't tolerate too much invasion of the straight smut in a BL, particularly to that extend (4 chapters, the rawness, focused on the puss* and d*ck thrusting...), if we're reading a straight porn, I wouldn't say anything, but we're supposed to read BL and expect gay smut between our male protagonists. This is why we're reading yaoi content.
    Honestly, the authors could've make us understand the same thing (they're straight, bi...), even the fucking with the girls could be done and shown, but just not like that. (And really, it fell out of nowhere, no sign nor warning).
    And this, BL authors are very awared of that, that's why the number of Yaoi with straight sex can be count on 10 fingers and when there are, they're kept "discret", never graphic.
    I'm awared of the intention of CDA's authors when they show these aboundant, raw hetero scenes, and it is for the sexual tension etc, however you can't expect for everyone to just like these and eat them up like you do. Readers can find this uncomfortable, without being "straightphobic" or "biphobic", they expected to see male x male.



    The Man at Night:
    Dropped it months ago. But in the Man at Night, their line of work is expected to have the boys having paid intercourses with the female clients.
    In the hetero episodes, what is shown is the male protagonist goes with a girl, lying naked with her on a bed, hugs her, kiss her, the "before" and "after"... This is enough to make us understand well that they have/had sex. Not once we get to see their private parts thrusting into each other with body fluids coming out of the bodies; them "in full action" like in CDA.
    Author of the Man at Night is knowleable enough to show us in a subtul way what we need to understand.

MangaSanctuary October 9, 2023 9:31 am

Jinx is always in the popular Mangas, BUT seeing the comment section here, it is clearly not for the good reasons.
When was the last time someone speak about the current plot in an elaborated and respectful way?
I was never a fan of this Yaoi nor do I hate it, however seeing how has become this section, I feel sorry for the author. Aside the art, it shows they maybe ultimately failed to keep the readership interested whether in the plot or through the main characters.

If your goal was to show your direspect for that title, bravo you've successed. Though maybe some others would like to read comments about the actual story? (And I'm not speaking about the sudden new ship).
Even when it was hate comments or arguments about rape etc, it was still better than what we find now.

    aethlyic October 9, 2023 9:47 am

    I have just finished reading this..... and i really wanna hear about people's thoughts about the latest chapter but it gets covered with the arguments and drama.........

    MangaSanctuary October 9, 2023 10:44 am
    I have just finished reading this..... and i really wanna hear about people's thoughts about the latest chapter but it gets covered with the arguments and drama......... aethlyic

    Right! Between the nonsense posts, trollage and arguments..., it's difficult to discuss about the current plot. Too bad, because even if it's not a piece of litterature authors still pour efforts to produce a work. Whatever the like or hate or the 'it's just porn' if it's a bit argumented, but this not even that and some people are just here to seek attention.


    Considering the difficult and heavy topic in chapter 34, where Dan was clearly molested and exposed unwittingly to another protagonist, I feel that author sensed it was too burdensome and maybe wanted to derive the attention to other characters (chap 35) and a lighter subject. Maybe drown the fish...?
    That's why we have now people who, after all the arguments about rape..., prefer to speak about the new side couple. Though the issue posed by chap 34 and the preview chapters still remain, and Dan blushing after what happens doesn't make sense - aside the "he may cares for me?", which is a total delusion for now.
    Of course the guy (JK) is handsome, you have sex with him daily, he paid and still helps you in a way that most people financially wouldn't/couldn't, but he also just uses you for his own profits and treats you less than a human, like a property.
    Dan is in a position worse than of a simple escort/prostitute, in the sense that he owes a Money that he will never be able to reimburse, which makes him particularly vulnerable and in no position to refuse the demands of the contractant (JK). Jeakyung gives him everything, a job, a house to live, paid off his impossible debt... The ML sure has a large hand when it comes to money and cares about his living conditions, but he has also become litterally his master, from where he can't escape. This reminds other plots with similar tropes. This makes a toxic situation that can take only 2 routes.
    But Jinx is even more difficult in the sense that, contrary to other stories that have pretty much the same pattern where the ML shows a clear interest into MC, JK still is the arrogant Assh*le that he from the beginning and the way he treats the Doc is still as rude.
    Will JK treats Dan better? Will he fall in love? Will he remain the same and only use Dan as a sex slave...? HOW and WHY are my questions, and these are important considering the great unbalance of their status and personalities and set up of story.

    aethlyic October 9, 2023 11:18 am
    Right! Between the nonsense posts, trollage and arguments..., it's difficult to discuss about the current plot. Too bad, because even if it's not a piece of litterature authors still pour efforts to produce a w... MangaSanctuary

    Right? With all the nonsense, i hope people would just ignore or move on but looking at the comments....... I think it wont happen anytime soon........

    MangaSanctuary October 9, 2023 11:29 am
    Right? With all the nonsense, i hope people would just ignore or move on but looking at the comments....... I think it wont happen anytime soon........ aethlyic

    Totally. That's because some pour water to the nonsenses or arguments. Worst case is that due to all the reports etc manga shut again the comment section.

    Tmsmyz October 9, 2023 12:59 pm
    Right? With all the nonsense, i hope people would just ignore or move on but looking at the comments....... I think it wont happen anytime soon........ aethlyic

    We have tried but I guess when we where throwing into a situation without knowing they spread misinformation on us at first. We were new to the page. I do feel stupid that I spent weeks trying to get through to the ones trolling me when I thought it was a miscommunication.

    They forced us into a pov vs pov. We don’t care about a pov vs pov. And if you read anything from back then I was fight them with forcing a pov on people than a pov vs pov. We stood up because Rose, a rape survivor was attacked. Her message was changed. Our opinions and pov were changed. We have heard the foulest things.

    I have been told to go kill my self many times. I stopped talking to many about September 14.I knew I was not going to get real communication on the story because they have silence many of the target audience voices. Many are hesitant to talk and I have been trying to make this is a safe place for all.

    Unfortunately, they are spreading misinformation about us. Tora was enjoying this story and one tried to stop him. Tora had to correct the information to the everyone in the thread that was a lie or people will be misinformed. He made a thread to the cyber bully to ask them to stop. The cyber bully has not stop.
    We have blocked them. We have mostly stopped engaging with them. We talked to each other not them and leave. I don’t know what you are seeing but we have tried to move on. We have tried to ignore them. We thought this over but it was started again. Don’t blame us. We do have the right to correct misinformation on us because people will get the wrong information. We do have the right to defend people from cyber attacks. However, I think when we know they are trolls or whatever we need to be like Manga Sanctuary and cut it off. We leave communication open and there is the fact somehow they think we are upset with their cowardly words. Some do think the pages and pages on different topics will happen again but we are not confused and we know what is happening on the page. It is easy for you but you are not getting defamatory statements with lies spread around that people are believing or hesitating to talk to us because they get conflicting information. You probably can talk about the story without a bully breathing down your neck with lies about you. I feel you don’t have a good picture of this.

    Tmsmyz October 9, 2023 1:20 pm

    “ When was the last time someone speak about the current plot in an elaborated and respectful way?”
    We try a lot. We seek this. We want this. There are too many trolls/haters and hate-readers. I want to talk to the target audience that would engage with the real story. You talk to one of them they will slowly start to attack you and kink-shame you. They are here to attack people. I wished we understood this situation faster than we did.
    We never seen such a toxic page on Mangago.
    People don’t understand the full picture and are judging us. We never started anything. We have stood against their cyber bullying. We blocked most of them months ago. We have made posts like this and we have been attacked for it. We have been judged by making comments like this. , like “ You guys act like this is your full-time job, you guys are so committed lmao”. This really doesn’t understand the situation. That’s was cold-hearted. We have been called obsessed. No. We are just acting to cyber bullying we just received. They assured we are upset or something but they never effected us by their cowardly words. Long messages don’t mean I am upset. My natural responses are serious to them and they think I am upset. They don’t understand. We have repeatedly told them to leave us alone. A few say they are “uncomfortable” but they still return to cyber bully the next day.
    We need two topic sections. One for them and one for us.we want peace and talk about the story. The real story but false details of the story. Thank you for what you did.

    aethlyic October 9, 2023 1:41 pm
    We have tried but I guess when we where throwing into a situation without knowing they spread misinformation on us at first. We were new to the page. I do feel stupid that I spent weeks trying to get through to... Tmsmyz

    Oh sorry that happened to you. I wasnt aware of the whole situation and just finished reading this bl. I just skimmed through the comments and saw you saying stuff like 'top' 'dominant man' 'submissive bottom' so i thought the situation is not that serious

    MangaSanctuary October 9, 2023 2:43 pm
    “ When was the last time someone speak about the current plot in an elaborated and respectful way?”We try a lot. We seek this. We want this. There are too many trolls/haters and hate-readers. I want to talk... Tmsmyz

    Yes, I understand you tried to make this space a place where the target audience could speak more and be less bothered by the "haters". At least, this is what I understood before things get out of hand.
    Your mission was honorable, and I see why you feel like you should do this. It's surely because you like this story very much (I may be wrong), and think it deserves more love than hate.
    But the matter is that such work, like it was before for POTN, contains controversial and hot topics (gap in status, Rich, Poor and their dynamics, rape, domination, exploitation...), so of course such fights like we can see here were inevitable as long as there will be stories like that.
    So, as long as such provocative contents will be shown and people can comment, it will be pretty much impossible to keep the "haters" out; people who dislike these to speak or voice their dislike/disagrement.
    The comment section is here for people to share their opinions, like or hate, and I think even bad avis, if they're argumented, can help people to understand better the plot and comprehend certain things they might've missed/neglected. But in the end, it's more likely readers will stick to their original their opinion. We can only understand better their POV on a story, but we're not obligated to agree, and vice-versa.
    Things only get bad when people lose their cool and started to attack the other party personally.

    I hope things will calm down and people comment again on the story.
    And good or bad comments, it's still better for an author to get reviews on their work instead of being plainly ingnored. A story can be very dark, tortuous and the hero suffer alot, however if an author is enough talented, they can make it a master piece and in the end, people will like it even though the journey was painful.

    Tmsmyz October 9, 2023 3:11 pm
    Oh sorry that happened to you. I wasnt aware of the whole situation and just finished reading this bl. I just skimmed through the comments and saw you saying stuff like 'top' 'dominant man' 'submissive bottom' ... aethlyic

    Thank you. It has been a mess. We are confused about many things about still. many people are aware of the situation and some only see our topics and judges us as if we are causing harm when we are trying to defend ourselves. I can’t imagine people are being offended by us defending ourselves and everyone who has been bullied here. Since supreme gentleman has target harassed anyone like that we did it differently because of some feedback. Normally, we would call it out and tell them not to attack others. It changed when three trolls entered. Tangina? Is the cyber bully after Tora. Tora as told them to leave him alone. The one with ^^ or whatever. I have rudely and hostility to her to leave me alone and she said I made her “uncomfortable” but she still goes. We left after they entered. We were trying to understand that person but we seen they were trolling. What you pointed out was serious it was a lesson learned message. I was being serious. I hope the op got the message. Tangina is making it a joke but that is sad they are so desperate for Tora’s attention and Tora wants nothing to do with them. Now if they stop cyber bullying that would be a different story.
    About this situation, it has gotten so bad, I had to start adding disclaimers to my topics saying haters will be blocked and spammed with “how to be a better person” articles. ┗( T﹏T )┛

    Tmsmyz October 9, 2023 3:49 pm
    Yes, I understand you tried to make this space a place where the target audience could speak more and be less bothered by the "haters". At least, this is what I understood before things get out of hand.Your mis... MangaSanctuary

    I hope people can understand what you understood. It is definitely out of hand.
    It is not really about the story. I like it but it is dull compared to many others. I have hid I like it to stay neutral to try to talk to them.
    To be honest, It’s could be better and better written. There are things that is needed to know in chapter 1 but not revealed until much later. It is executed poorly and that is causing all these problems. There are ones that are better at picking things up from the details she gives but they others don’t want to listen. They only want to attack and force their pov on others.
    I don’t mind the hate-readers. Just let us know. I don’t mind the negative comments. I scroll by most. Some are weird. I will correct story details:
    But the hate I am talking about and standing against is people getting bashed for having different opinions or kink shaming. There will be haters on the story. It’s okay.Some I am okay with them hating the story. But when they start attacking people that is wrong. Someone like the BDSM in chapter 34. They were called a disgusting freak.
    You can’t like this story, like Jk, or ship Jk or Dan without being attacked for that opinion. Even saying this isn’t rape but SA and abusive gets you attacked like you justify rape and defend JK. It doesn’t. It really is irrational thinking there. It is the attacking and forcing into their pov that I am against. Neither one is really the story. I am sorry if I made a mistake last time. Thank you for understanding.

    Mikaela October 9, 2023 5:16 pm
    I have just finished reading this..... and i really wanna hear about people's thoughts about the latest chapter but it gets covered with the arguments and drama......... aethlyic

    My thoughts: I REALLY want more chapters of potato and heesung to know heesung ain't a psycho lol.

    Torakaze October 9, 2023 6:16 pm
    My thoughts: I REALLY want more chapters of potato and heesung to know heesung ain't a psycho lol. Mikaela

    Me too.

    MangaSanctuary October 9, 2023 8:10 pm
    I hope people can understand what you understood. It is definitely out of hand. It is not really about the story. I like it but it is dull compared to many others. I have hid I like it to stay neutral to try to... Tmsmyz

    I hope so... And you're very welcome.
    I understand that you simply want for the fans of this series to have the freedom to communicate their like for Jinx, even if you find yourself some flaws to that plot.
    Like you told, this writing is lacking in some aspects, causing partly this fight between readers. If it had a better treatment of the scenario -more focused on the plot and less on the Smut (?), and less dragged to reach more chapters than necessary, we could have definitely a better understanding of the situation.
    It's a good thing that you tolerate the hate-readers or the hating that is unavoidable anyway in this kind of plots. Of course, it's better if the opinion were backed up with arguments and the readers react with less anger and passion, like that we can avoid arguments.
    Still, it's unavoidable for readers to not bash others for their tastes when the story contains controversial issues.
    Some people just can't sake such sexual violence, furthermore if they feel it's gratuituous and the perpetrator will get away and will likely be end game with the victim/MC. The anger is still fueled, in my opinion, by the poor writing of author, or simply their taste for such ending.
    The fact that it's fiction but readers still have their standards, and both arguments are right, can make the communication really difficult like here. And if we speak about BDSM, this is another sensible subject... Here it is important to know if Dan/MC was consenting to do this kind of sex/play (bondage). Was he consenting to be shown like this, unwillingly, to Heesung? For that latter, I very doubt. That's why for many commentators it's not BDSM. BDSM implies that both parties must be willing to play or engage in certain practices.

    The talent of author is definitely to exploit this frontier of what's acceptable and what's not, and in Jinx the limits are really blurred.
    I

    Morning Diamonds October 10, 2023 8:57 pm
    Oh sorry that happened to you. I wasnt aware of the whole situation and just finished reading this bl. I just skimmed through the comments and saw you saying stuff like 'top' 'dominant man' 'submissive bottom' ... aethlyic

    People are misunderstanding them and they are laughing at them who are getting bullied. Sept 14, There is a person who made a comment to Tm that claimed Tm was obsessed. He is not. Tora explained they were being harassed. October 1, a cyberbully started drama. That person on Oct 2 wrote a topic still kind of blaming them. She deleted that topic but she came back with a topic on the 8th. She blamed them that they "would take over the comment section with this rather than doing the actual purpose for it," They don't take many topics and they explain things relevant to the story. But how do you take over the topic section? She totally dismisses the cyberbullying and their real comments. Many of their comments are related to the story. I don't know what she is on. Many of their comments are on the people who read this story. she excused them of starting drama when they only stood up against it. She said "You guys act like this is your full time job, you guys are so committed lmao." https://www.mangago.me/home/mangatopic/14572933/


    Back to your comment, With that and with that person being the first time attacking someone (me) on this page. They handled it differently trying to show everyone a different side of them. When they would have responded how they have been. Something like "This is a disgusting comment please don't attack people. Let's have civil conversations about jinx."

    I heard a lot about TM over the years. He is kind, helpful, and honest. Tora is a sweetheart and gentle. They both love talking to people. It is sad to see them pull back and close off. I have seen their comments from 3 years ago to now, It is sad to see them gradually change. And the trolls are laughing at them.

    Them, blocking, and stopping talking to people harassing them is something neither does. It is something new they started when people started to cyberbully them here. Mi Amore isn't even talking. I was hoping she would come back since I am here now. Rose left and returned to mock the cyber bullies after the continuous treatment and they are being made fun of. She feels to blame since they defended her. This started then and has not stopped. But many are getting the wrong idea. Tora and Tmsm are not to blame. Sure they could have reworded their comments or made their stances better but they did know what was pushed on them until later. It is hard to fight what you don't know. Then it is just a sick fucked up mind game on them. They both stopped playing. They have actively tried to end this when they learned. They don't want people like you getting the wrong ideas because the trolls are salty. This is just the backlash of the trolls not being able to play with their favorite toys when their toys learn what was actually happening. They had multiple people telling them that people were spreading misinformation on them. They get attacked continuously.

    There are two who have attacked them and have openly admitted that they are being made of for how they are acting. They are just standing up to cyberbullying on them and others.

    Vidhuu's second comment https://www.mangago.me/home/mangatopic/14580406/?page=4

    If they are being made fun of... (sick mind game) https://www.aconsciousrethink.com/20563/why-people-make-fun-of-others/

    1. Insecurity (they put others down in order to make themselves look better).

    They are not harming. The ones laughing are harming themselves. This is something I learned from Tora.
    This is highly serious. It is a bunch of teenagers who are out to hurt people who got called out instead and just want to hurt the ones who called them out. They are trying everything to get Tora and Tmsm to stop and leave the page so they can keep harming people who love this story. Tora and Tmsm will protect the people and let them know. Tora and tmsm will share things about this story to help others that is what they do.

    MangaSanctuary October 11, 2023 8:28 am
    People are misunderstanding them and they are laughing at them who are getting bullied. Sept 14, There is a person who made a comment to Tm that claimed Tm was obsessed. He is not. Tora explained they were bein... Morning Diamonds

    Thank your for taking the time to write me all this. Although I wass't following the whole matter and don't take side, I think I know a bit what's going on.
    Years before I talked to Tmsmyz, yes they're a gentle person. Whatever the problem it's sad they retreat because of what happens in the Jinx comment section. I suspect that after going through all this, they might become a bit neurotic in the sense that they're now extremely defensive and can be agressive, while initially they were not. I'm actually worried about them and hope they're alright.
    For me, this story, which is not even a master piece in term of BL, shouldn't've bring people into such fight resulting some readers to shut themselves.
    For me the comment section is for everyone to share their view, love, hate... we can't avoid people to comment (especially regarding the nature of content here) and I think it's fine as long as readers explain with arguments.

    Having read their exchanges and having talked to them, I think Tmsmyz, Tora and Ina have more in common (than me with any of them, lol) in the sense that they all like this story, while I just find this plot not better than others Rich x Poor, cliché etc. I think that if they take the time to discuss calmly they can get along fine, I mean, with Ina.

    About Vidhuu, they're not the only person that you have problem with, I've seen that Jojo too... I think they play a joyful game of ridiculing people, while they clearly don't give a fuck about what one have to say. That Cutekuomi machintruc is also the same. So I think it's better to just ignore these individuals, as they're the most vicious.
    I've actually reported their topics. I think their goal is to make you guys spit things, while not caring to reply, so don't feed furthermore these people's topic. Instead, let's report it when it takes a direction that benefits their plan. They're not the most visible, but their actions are the most malicious.
    I just told them that what they're doing to Tmsmyz wasn't cool, and got blocked for that.
    They block me for saying that but let you say so much, lol. Like I told, they want to make you spit "insanity", WHILE THEY'RE THE ONES POURING WATER to that insanity (if insanity there is it's due to them).
    I hope you understand my stand, which is of someone who considerer Tmsmyz as an old friend, even though our view on Jinx/Dispar can differ.

    Morning Diamonds October 11, 2023 9:54 am
    Thank your for taking the time to write me all this. Although I wass't following the whole matter and don't take side, I think I know a bit what's going on.Years before I talked to Tmsmyz, yes they're a gentle ... MangaSanctuary

    I am trying to still neutal as I am exterior pov with insights from them but it is not two sides here. If it is Tora and tmsm vs trolls/haters (not hate-reader). I am picking Tora and Tmsm's side. Now if it is someone that heard something and came here attacking them that stop when they learn they were mislead. They should not attack and they should had apologized but There is not really a side to take there. There are many sides here.

    Tora is neutral. He thinks the story is toxic but he does not like or love it. Tm likes it but thinks it is dull. He is on the fence about being neutral too. He likes Dan. I don't know who ina at the moment.

    Jojo in August followed Tmsmyz and talked about people saying she was delusional. About a week ago she unfollowed him and started to cyberbullied him and denies there are haters here while becoming one to stand with them. He had another one to unfollow and start to cyberbullied him. (fiends with jojo) He was in a place where he thought he could not trust anyone on here. Not even Tora. He was going to end his three year long friendship with Tora thinking he could not trust anyone.

    I give Cutekuomi and Vidhuu both a chance to fix this mess but they only wanted to be trolls. Rose was instant block too for what she did. That was funny. What most of them are doing is uncool. I think he has been cyberbullied since July I can understand why he defensive and I think he is only agressive towards the vicious ones. Especially the two that backstabbed him that will not leave him alone. He has not been himself since Jojo and fujo did what they did. It is not them. It is more he did not expect people to unfollow him to cyberbully him when they both have spoke up against the toxicity of this page. It was the act of it.

    It is funny they never blocked me. They think I am Tora or Tmsm or that I would be arugementive??? They misunderstand Tmsm when he tried understanding them but he didn't know he was talking to so many trolls. They are too malicious on this page. I think Tm is right in blocking and leaving. They are playing games with him. They claim he and Tora are taking over the topics area and they barely make topics. You are seeing what we are seeing with them. Thank you.

    MangaSanctuary October 11, 2023 10:53 am
    I am trying to still neutal as I am exterior pov with insights from them but it is not two sides here. If it is Tora and tmsm vs trolls/haters (not hate-reader). I am picking Tora and Tmsm's side. Now if it is ... Morning Diamonds

    Of course one can see their game and the fun they have through that.
    I don't know about Rose but I think they simply block me because they don't have the argument to back the fact they were ganging up against one person -Tmsmyz. They don't considerthe situation from in the whole, but simply made fun of someone's distress, that was ugly from them.
    Thanks for enlighting me about Tora and Tmsmyz's opinion on Jinx. About me I always found Jinx to be a cliché plot with overused tropes, btw the treatment of the plot is poorly done. We'll see what Mingwa has in their pocket to solve this problematic plot.

    It is in fact very low and ugly of Jojo and Fujo to act like this, it's understandable that Tmsm feels like this. Even if your stance about the story is radically different from someone you follow, is there a need to turn against them? NO. Also, if they followed Tmsm that's because they like what Tmsm's content. Why can't they just ignore all the fights in the comments?
    There will alaways people or pretend friends who backstab you for in life, real friens are rare, but hopefully not everyone is like this.

    Mind you that if they don't block you, it's surely because they want you to spit some nonsense (not saying you're doing that), so don't feed them too much with comments they don't even bother to reply. That Jojo is a jerk, specially if they were "friends" with Tmsm, and more if they're here to harass them.
    With such people who provoke with petty remarks but not responding like they should, there's nothing to do that ignore them. They don't deserve our time or energy.

    MangaSanctuary October 11, 2023 2:38 pm
    Of course one can see their game and the fun they have through that.I don't know about Rose but I think they simply block me because they don't have the argument to back the fact they were ganging up against on... MangaSanctuary

    OMG I must be tired... rereading, I realize there're many mistakes in my writing, sorry guys and hope you understand what I mean. English is actually my third language ╥﹏╥

    Tmsmyz October 11, 2023 2:53 pm
    Of course one can see their game and the fun they have through that.I don't know about Rose but I think they simply block me because they don't have the argument to back the fact they were ganging up against on... MangaSanctuary

    Rose is defending me. Rose is the rape survivor that we defended. She left. She felt bad that I was told go KYS a few times and how I was treated. So, she came back to mock cyber bullying to ones cyber bullying us. They don’t like that seeing how they act. She was hoping it would get them to stop. Some did but for some it seemed to escalate the issue. ╥﹏╥

    I don’t know if they realize it but they are ganging up on me and I only standing up for myself and others. I also tried to talk to them when I was so confused. When I learned it was them playing with me. I backed off and they started more drama and being more aggressive.
    However, they have more intense hate for Tora but he bounces off and on.
    He is a real friend. I think they are jealous of our friendship that they almost ruined. No, that I almost ended from petty actions. But I would had fixed it a few days later. I was not close to JoJo or fujo. It was not them. It was how crazy that was. This is a crazy situation and being blame for it is even more ridiculous. If you seen everything that has been said to me, you would see am I handling this better than many people would’ve. I wished it didn’t happen. I am glad it was not someone who would have committed suicide having dealing with 30 + of them attacking daily at the beginning. It was awful. Then they are saying go KYS. It is criminal. I wished this was a legal site. I would report them. I still may. This is dead wrong and serious.

    In light of everything, I am thinking about being friends with Tora off of here. If anything this has caused a real life friendship between Tora and me. I didn’t realize how close me and Tor as became. I am okay. Thank you. I am okay just confused and concerned about them in what has happened in their life to gang up on a harmless stranger in vile acts.

    Tmsmyz October 11, 2023 2:55 pm
    OMG I must be tired... rereading, I realize there're many mistakes in my writing, sorry guys and hope you understand what I mean. English is actually my third language ╥﹏╥ MangaSanctuary

    I understood. I think.

    You are okay. Third language? It is hard to learn so many?

    MangaSanctuary October 23, 2023 11:41 am
    I understood. I think. You are okay. Third language? It is hard to learn so many? Tmsmyz

    Let's say, you need to concentrate more when writing and it can feels exhausting because it's not natural as you would write in your language.
    Grammar, punctuation, syntaxe... are also not really the same.

MangaSanctuary September 30, 2023 1:30 pm

Before Aoba couldn't stand Arashi, then the instant after he jumped on him O_o
If it wasn't so fast-paced it'd be better. The "big bro" is hot and classy and "lil bro" is cute and dumb. Though big bro gives creep vibes for sexually assaulting him like this.

It seems Daichi was a bit that guardian that kept Aoba from touching Arashi, but now that Daichi married, the wolf Aoba enter in the sheepfold.

MangaSanctuary September 29, 2023 12:49 am

This is so adorable, I'm already invested

MangaSanctuary September 25, 2023 10:51 am

Really... A beautiful art WASTED on a horse shit plot, if we can ever call this a plot.

I think that the novel must be already something by itself, but for an artist to go of their way to illustrate and draw the whole thing, especially with this pretty art, this is unforgivable.
Mc and ml, like the rest, are RIDICULOUS CHARACTERS void of any treatment and logic and have no means other than serving the vulgar smut. Ml is disguting despite his good design and grabs his dick at every occasion, pee on people like a vulgar dog. He's an empty shell, we know nothing about him aside he's rich... The content is outrageously gross and deadening.
I won't even start how cliche of a story this is.

Unless the Yaoi community is populated by weirdos who enjoy seeing such images, I don't think this world need any more fictions that remain us how people with money can treat and degrade people of lower classes.
What's the mean of art and stories, honestly? Dark or luminous/wholesome, its main purpose - and above this, DUTY - is to make us think, make us grow, or entertain us in a way that bring us something... But this kind of story fail to do any of this, and I wonder if the fact that it please to a minor part of readers that like this kind of stuff is worth the trouble of spending months/years to work on something like this.

MangaSanctuary September 23, 2023 6:13 pm

This is so adorable, I like this manhua with my whole heart <33

MangaSanctuary September 25, 2023 9:36 am

Kim Dan is not even treated as a human anymore. How miserable and shameful he will feel, for a boy like him, when he will discover what's really happened.

If the Jaekyung doesn't fall rapidly for Kim Dan and treat him better, I'm afraid the only relationship they'll bound to have is Master - Servant, which is terrible for the poor guy, because their dynamic is so UNEQUAL and Kim Dan is not in any position to refuse anything to JK. This will be so sad to see, like we can witness in this kind of toxic relationship where there's one that's denial about their true feelings for the other. Kim Dan will be forever his servant butler as well as sexual slave and treated as less than a human, while JK can enjoy his life as he wants, even fuck with other people or take a lover... all the while reminding that Kim Dan is his possession whenever someone shows interest into the guy. It's already + 30 chapters and their relationship doesn't progress much and turns in circle. When you think it's getting better, no, it's back to square 1. How things are and especially how arrogant and a big EGO is JK, any improvement or Character Development of that ML will seem so fake. Sorry to say, cause we know how everyone is waiting for the CD of JK. Aside his good looks and all the money he has, he doesn't seem to have any other human qualities.
Though maybe the author already has a super CD for the guy in her hat and we'll be all magically amazed the moment she'll pull it out? Lol

MangaSanctuary September 22, 2023 8:18 pm

The story like the art style, like the characters, are all a big mess... What a train wreck. It started as fine, the art was pretty fine and I rooted for Yeesu, but now he's just a big hoe that goes with both father and son, GROSS. But what can we expect from the author of "Into the Rose Garden"? Was this supposed to be funny? "Story" is gross, art and proportions are all over the place. This hurt the brain, heart and eyes to even look at this. Are these artists and authors really motivated to produce something worth reading?

MangaSanctuary July 18, 2021 2:43 pm

The difference in size is so ridiculous it looks like a fuck*ng shota. Maybe the purpose was to make an animalistic version of humans, but yeah the result is super weird.

    ZelAn July 19, 2021 12:21 am

    The Uke looks like a child

    MangaSanctuary July 19, 2021 1:05 am
    The Uke looks like a child ZelAn

    When he's alone he looks like an actual young man in some panels, but when he's with one these guys, he suddenly looks like a child, yeah.

    ZelAn July 19, 2021 1:55 am
    When he's alone he looks like an actual young man in some panels, but when he's with one these guys, he suddenly looks like a child, yeah. MangaSanctuary

    Yes agreed, he looks typical stereotypical Uke tbh and the cover makes him look like their kid

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.