Genuine Question. Pls be honest, would you rather...

So here's the context and everything. I hate this book called Jinx. You LOVE Jinx.

I created a topic saying I hate jinx and why.

You see my topic and u felt like I'm wrong because the romance is actually good in ur opinion.

Now, would you rather comment on MY TOPIC to express YOUR OPINION?

Or CREATE YOUR OWN TOPIC to express YOUR OPINION?

I must say, these ppl ganging up on me until this day with the topic I created over a month ago is kinda getting into me and got me thinking that maybe I am wrong. Nevertheless I just wanna hear some of y'all, not really looking for like comrades or buddies to agree with me or like justification.