Comments of Ouji-sama to Haiiro no Hibi

The story was decent for what it was. It's something that's been done a lot but not bad. The old style "preying mantis" art was jarring after reading so many modern mangas. LOL their legs and arms are so long and disproportionate. There's very little romance actually and zero sexual content (not even a kiss). It's fine. Would likely not read again.

Now that was good

Atsuko is a young high-school girl who leads a troublesome life. Working a scandalous job for the sake of survival, her reputation is in tatters and she is scorned by her peers. But one day she is noticed by one of three rich boys, Itaru, which she resembles in an uncanny way. Immediately she finds herself whisked away from her everyday life and into a new world where she is forced to take on the role as Itaru?s double and replace him as the ?Prince.?

I really like the plot. It was kinda deep and i really appreciate atsuko. Kinda hoping that they were twins, but nah.

I guess wholesome, some suspicious aspects but oh well

such a good storyyy loved itt

It was very good, i love it very much. I hope you guys try this out because it has a good story line and good ending, it made me cry a little ಥ_ಥ

That was sooooooo good!!! Just read it!

Atsumo~~~~~ I love you so much! You were so strong and still had to keep your facade even when it hurt you. And Ryo better keeps you happy coz he was being shitty!

This was so well written and the emotions were so well written and shown. I enjoyed the plot devices used and how it had a happy ending! I liked the dark art style but there were parts of the story that could have been expanded upon. Overall very well done though!

.
Meh
Art is ew. Plot is meh

Hmmkinda looks good

Ending sucked...let me unwind, no rant...The whole story was beautiful and it showed a really tough female lead which I LOVE...but the ending was kind of a let down....I think Atsuko didn't get closure...she endured too much for some guy who treated her like trash most of the manga...she's wan't home for 6months and things just went back to normal track when she returned?? like?? And Itaru literally walked in said a few words and every1 just accepts oh yeah he makes a cute girl...like whuat? If that's all it took, then what was the fucking struggle in this up si daisy life?? god I hated every single one of the male characters....I wish Atsuko hadn't accepted the money and made it big herself with her new confidence and skills (making teddy bears)....of all the places this manga could...it ended up throwing her in their grasp, paying itsuko rent and "comforting" that ass ryo, atsuko had a hard life too, harder than any of them, I don't see any1 trying to comfort her....as if "i love you too" could wrap up all emotions.....graaaaa I'm so angry....the ending is such a let down...

really enjoyed it
wish they had more scenes of the aftermath
maybe an epilogue

Girl is adorable the guy she’s filling in for is a fuckin jackass

number of chapters: 21