I like the dad

Reading this comment was a Rollercoaster

I feel u. Especially the title of your comment.

Thank you!!

"misunderstandings between father and daughter are irritating. She makes her own scripts and films on her own and she never asks for an explanation, it's boring. She's not the real Juvelian so she should express herself more and have the same personality as in her old life."

What she does is rational though, her 'father' has been treating her like shit and even sent 'her' to her own death; I think people like you guys read too many tyrant Father-Daughter isekai manhwas in which (sometimes) the transmigrated daughter always thinks that "okay, I can change my behaviour 180° within a week and no one would suspect that this body got "possessed" and my new dad would instantly love me!"

Sometimes I wondered, if I lived in historical era and my cousin who is known to be a "villainess" suddenly changed her behaviour within one week, I'm pretty sure my family will fucking call a priest to get rid of whomever is possessing her.

And if she suddenly acts all "nice", people would think that she's possessed since it's a historical setting and do you want to see her getting exorcised??? This is called "baby steps".

It's easy to change your behaviour when they transmigrated when the said villains were still under 10 y.o; heck, even Athy was still scared that Claude (pre amnesia) would someday discard her even though they have spent almost 10 years together.

And WMAP is still the best transmigration manhwa 'til now, and I imagined if Athy transmigrated when the original body were in her 18 y.o., she wouldn't have survived. Claude would only get suspicious and suspect that she's practicing some black magic and kfc that would give him more reasons to kill her.

Imagine if you only knew your "dad" for a few months, if she did something too "OOC" then her dad would get suspicious too.

This is called "common sense".

You act as if Athy and Claude were the only reference in terms of Isekai !!!
And then you say it's common sense? What is common sense is not to sleep and spend the day with a stranger who came into your room at night through the window and who put his sword under your throat and who threw you out of bed in you. leaving bruises on the body !!
Moreover, to answer your question, if I had transmigrated in the body of this girl, I would have tried to get closer to the father, to communicate with him, to make him love me etc ... Since you yourself refer to Athy, remember that Athy did everything to make Claude love her, she spent time with him, and in the end he showed her love and she was no longer afraid of him . Juvelian makes films and as soon as her father does something, she doesn't see his good intentions, she doesn't even try to see them, for a girl of the 21st century, in my opinion she should have more common sense as you say !
And logic would dictate that if it is a girl who is afraid even of her father, she should be afraid of a stranger who put his sword to her throat !!

Sorry I reread my answer and I find it a bit aggressive when it was not my intention! Sincerely sorry. I understand what you mean but I think there is too much isekai with girls who have no common sense and it gets boring with force, but you are not wrong when you say that she shouldn't change right away but since her dad is different she should change too to see if she can improve their relationship.
It was just my opinion. I hope I don't sound too aggressive and sorry again.

Yes!! That's right!! People shitting on me for finding the misunderstanding irritating too

If I remembered, I only make a comment towards the first row of paragraphs (?) that you made. I didn't make a comment about the rest of your comment since I also think your point is true.

Im using Athy & Claude because it's the original Tyrant Father&Daughter webtoon. And it has quite the common sense too. And the better one obviously, more realistic compared to its other counterparts (I can say this bcs I think I've read enough bad isekai mangas and chinese isekai manhuas... god, I think I can vomit remembering that.)

I did mention that "it's easier to change your behaviour completely WITHOUT making people get suspicious of yourself IF you transmigrated when the original body's age is under 10 y.o.,".

I mean, even as a 5 y.o., Athy was scared that she would seem too "mature" for her age, and people would get too sus of her (hello, Lady Baby? Pls take an example from WMAP). Imagine if someone who's known as a Villainess for years suddenly changes her behaviour like a Saintess? I think most webtoons forget about this basic logic.

The more she aged, she still gets scared that someday Claude would discard her; and for Claude to actually love her, how many years did it take huh? Even years later, sometimes he still doesn't really know whether he really loves Athy or not. Caitel is even more honest with his feelings towards Ria than Claude.

Also, I've said it before, IF Athy transmigrated when the original body's age is 18 y.o. (when she got killed), she WOULDN'T HAVE SURVIVED. Heck.

"as soon as her father does something, she doesn't see his good intentions, she doesn't even try to see them, for a girl of the 21st century, in my opinion she should have more common sense as you say !"

That is called as being careful, dumbass. If I knew my "dad" is going to have me killed myself in the future, of fucking course I would get sus of EVERY MOVES he makes.

With that expresionless face he makes, I don't know whether he would kill me tomorrow or later.

We, as the readers, KNOW that the father wouldn't kill her BECAUSE we also see and read from his point of view. But she, who only knows that he is someone who is cruel enough to make her daughter kills herself, ofc wouldn't think like that. Especially bcs the novels ended right after she killed herself. She's left with no clue after she arrived in that world.

That's what an actual good FL of a good novel would do. Not saying this novel is good or anything though... still too early. You know, those novels with good ratings in goodreads.

Alright, enough for the essays. God, this is for some dumb webtoon, I think when my profs actually give me a work to review an actual literature novel I would've passed out lol.

Oh wait it's the same person they even used 2 accounts to fight my comment

Oh did you really write DUMBASS ??
I think we're going to have to clear things up right now, I wrote a comment and you don't agree, I don't have a problem with that but to call someone stupid because they don't not think the same as you on a webtoon ... ask yourself who is the real stupid! Just because you write novels about people's comments and try to make yourself look great by mentioning your teachers' literary reviews doesn't mean that your comment will addweight! Before allowing yourself to stop responding to other people's comments, then respect them even if you don't agree !!
Also, don't you dare to insult me anymore because in this game you won't win.

Alright, sorry, I was kinda sleep-deprived when I wrote that one insult lol. Sorry for not proof-reading that one comment.

Uhm no? I didn't try to make myself sound great by mentioning that? Just thinking why the heck I was so passionate in writing a long ass comment for a damn webtoon but not so when I really had to write one for my assignment.

And I actually mentioned that bcs when ur assignments included writing some reviews for books, even when reading a webnovel/toon, that fucking habits sometime came up..... and ended up like this. Esp at this kind of hour. Fuck. You kinda became an over-analyzed, sleep-deprived person.

Goodnight then~

You're either dumb or haven't been paying attention. Refer to chapter 2, FL clearly states that she was reincarnated into the novel BUT she lived and grew up as the real FL. ONLY just (four days ago) she remembered her past life from another world - this is essentially where she read the novel she is in. Up until that point she grew up with her Father acting cruel, being in a relationship with Mikhail etc. and going down the same path the FL would go down. The only reason she knows her timeline is bc she remembers (only now) her past life and reading it from that life. She still went through the same old shit from the novel she isn't a different person possessing her body NO she lived that life. If you read into trauma, behavioural science, psychology etc. you would understand that MC's actions are completely understandable & explainable.