Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.

Hmm

Lizzie April 18, 2024 9:43 pm

That's the bad side of queer-baiting. The author wanted fangirls, so they wrote a fun ship that had a lot of flirting but didn't reach physical levels, and when the novel got popular and got enough attention suddenly those scenes were too much for the readers who can't handle two men together.

So very ick.

At least Cale has always been an ace king.

Responses
    KoolAidOnDrugs April 18, 2024 10:25 pm

    I lowkey fw queer baiting but only if one of them dont randomly get a love interest cause that shit HURTS. I see this a lot in gl media it's like a knife to the heart

    Lizzie April 19, 2024 12:58 am
    I lowkey fw queer baiting but only if one of them dont randomly get a love interest cause that shit HURTS. I see this a lot in gl media it's like a knife to the heart KoolAidOnDrugs

    I dropped stuff for that. Though my delulu self relies on fanfics. Lol.

    Silvermilk April 19, 2024 2:39 am

    But even when the novel got popular the author continued to include hjyj moments with physical intimacy. Do you mean the adaptation not being as faithful to the depictions as is the novel?

    Lizzie April 19, 2024 10:58 am
    But even when the novel got popular the author continued to include hjyj moments with physical intimacy. Do you mean the adaptation not being as faithful to the depictions as is the novel? Silvermilk

    Yes, certain scenes are omitted in newer versions. Though that's just what I got from the other commenters, so as I don't want to spread misinformation, I'll say that I haven't seen their source.

    feh April 19, 2024 1:38 pm

    i don’t think it’s queerbaiting… the novel is the romance but their relationship is beautiful weather you see it as romantic or platonic. raising a child that they converted together is already not you cishetero dynamic. there isn’t just two ways of things…

    feh April 19, 2024 1:39 pm
    i don’t think it’s queerbaiting… the novel is the romance but their relationship is beautiful weather you see it as romantic or platonic. raising a child that they converted together is already not you ci... feh

    * conceived not converted

    KoolAidOnDrugs April 19, 2024 3:27 pm
    i don’t think it’s queerbaiting… the novel is the romance but their relationship is beautiful weather you see it as romantic or platonic. raising a child that they converted together is already not you ci... feh

    Conceived? Hello?? The more I read into this pair the more it makes me double take ☠

    Lizzie April 19, 2024 6:21 pm
    Conceived? Hello?? The more I read into this pair the more it makes me double take ☠ KoolAidOnDrugs

    In a magical sense, it's humorous not bad and not romanticized either. (since there are other kids).

    feh April 20, 2024 12:23 am
    In a magical sense, it's humorous not bad and not romanticized either. (since there are other kids). Lizzie

    why would it be bad either way they literally both have been acknowledged as the parent and both their personalities affect sung han gyeol, and they both pull their weight in taking care of him… a novel doesn’t need to have romance to be queer, there are other themes as well. let’s start with how most s class people are basically agender, and how yoojin is written with an unapologetically maternal and nurturer archetype which is usually reserved for female characters. s classes that i raised would be a joy to analyse through a feminist and queer lens. queerbaiting is hibike euphonium or vanitas no carte, not this at all.

    feh April 20, 2024 12:28 am
    In a magical sense, it's humorous not bad and not romanticized either. (since there are other kids). Lizzie

    i’m sorry “it’s humorous not bad and not romanticised” is irking me because what does that even mean… han gyeol is not written in as a joke, he is yoojin’s son. the only joke is that he is annoyed by sung hyunjae… also it’s a weird thing to say, non-cishet pairs having kids is fine as long as its not serious or romanticised or whatever tf that means….?

    KoolAidOnDrugs April 20, 2024 6:45 am
    In a magical sense, it's humorous not bad and not romanticized either. (since there are other kids). Lizzie

    Y'all attacking this person ruthlessly..I misunderstood and quite literally thought it was mpreg or sum mb LOL They prob meant their relationship is not in a romantical sense but wdym not bad

    feh April 20, 2024 2:54 pm
    Y'all attacking this person ruthlessly..I misunderstood and quite literally thought it was mpreg or sum mb LOL They prob meant their relationship is not in a romantical sense but wdym not bad KoolAidOnDrugs

    their original comment was also misinformed… the author didn’t write “a fun ship” to queerbait because they wanted fangirls… it’s so disrespectful to such an incredible novel.

    here’s the author’s comment:

    "han yoohyun was designed to be han yoojin’s destination(목표), as the lingering regret of his life(삶의 미련), while sung hyunjae was developed to be the path(과정) to that goal, as a self-assured embodiment of his ‘ideal self’. without even names assigned then, that was their foundational framework.

    han yoohyun and sung hyunjae’s sex were determined in alignment with the main character’s own designation. this was because with the premise and plot, if they were opposite sex to each other, it seemed like interpretations would skew too heavily sexual only. i judged that having them be the same sex as each other was more likely to result in diverse interpretations of the text. "

    Silvermilk April 20, 2024 7:25 pm
    their original comment was also misinformed… the author didn’t write “a fun ship” to queerbait because they wanted fangirls… it’s so disrespectful to such an incredible novel. here’s the author’... feh

    Omg I didn’t know Geunseo nim had written that,, that’s so cool…thank you so much for the comment!

    Yeah it also irks me a little when people throw around the word queerbait because it influences other readers esp since there’s SO much more to hyunjae/yoojins dynamic that we haven’t even like touched upon. And the manhwa omitting certain lines doesn’t necessarily make the whole story queerbait, it just makes an inaccurate/ineffective adaptation. It’s like calling the Mo Dao Zu Shi donghua adaptation queerbait lmao.

    Tldr I love whatever the hell their relationship is and can’t wait for the birthday arc

    feh April 20, 2024 7:48 pm
    Omg I didn’t know Geunseo nim had written that,, that’s so cool…thank you so much for the comment!Yeah it also irks me a little when people throw around the word queerbait because it influences other read... Silvermilk

    you get it !! their interpretation and perception of queer media is so narrow minded…

    KoolAidOnDrugs April 20, 2024 7:56 pm
    Omg I didn’t know Geunseo nim had written that,, that’s so cool…thank you so much for the comment!Yeah it also irks me a little when people throw around the word queerbait because it influences other read... Silvermilk

    Just realised queerbait is such a strong but simple word to describe deep, meaningful relationships. There's this manwha which stated it was shounen-ai for 2 weeks and suddenly changed to action. It didn't change their relationship from gay to ungay-it's up to us to interpret it. If I remember correctly it's about this old guy who's a vampire and sucks this guy's neck seductively..pretty homosexual to me

    KoolAidOnDrugs April 20, 2024 7:58 pm
    Just realised queerbait is such a strong but simple word to describe deep, meaningful relationships. There's this manwha which stated it was shounen-ai for 2 weeks and suddenly changed to action. It didn't chan... KoolAidOnDrugs

    Deleted half of it bruh*
    Anyway, you've enlightened me! Relationships don't always need labels

    Silvermilk April 20, 2024 8:55 pm
    Deleted half of it bruh*Anyway, you've enlightened me! Relationships don't always need labels KoolAidOnDrugs

    LMAO from the gist of it, it just clicked to me you were talking about “I need to suck blood tonight” or Yabun ni Kyuuketsu Shitsureishimasu xD that’s one I really like as well.

    Anyway I’m glad you took something meaningful away from this thread! Even if I seldom participated lol

    KoolAidOnDrugs April 21, 2024 10:20 am
    LMAO from the gist of it, it just clicked to me you were talking about “I need to suck blood tonight” or Yabun ni Kyuuketsu Shitsureishimasu xD that’s one I really like as well.Anyway I’m glad you took... Silvermilk

    Omg thanks forgot the name lolol. Love how it's not even shounen-ai now but yaoi

    KoolAidOnDrugs April 21, 2024 10:22 am
    Omg thanks forgot the name lolol. Love how it's not even shounen-ai now but yaoi KoolAidOnDrugs

    Omg people are still arguing about it