Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.

Silvermilk is reading (All 0)

Silvermilk's Album ( All 1 )

Silvermilk's List ( All 1 )

Title Update Recommend
Favs(3) 2024-06-10 0

Silvermilk's topics ( All 134 )

Silvermilk June 17, 2026 6:52 pm

I really like this manga but I’d love some discussion on this, can someone explain to me why the world-building has it so that sexless people die young? Was it to make Hinase’s choice more urgent? Because I feel like the themes of sex and gender still resonate if that was an option. Maybe it’s to be more realistic? But the fact that’s just the absence of any non-binary identity while choosing a sex seems so odd. I really so like this story for touching directly upon gender in such an interesting way but the author’s intentions here are confusing me.

    MoisturizingCream June 18, 2026 9:15 am

    1) It is likely that all sexless people die young because they face the same issue with Hinase which is dealing with excessive amounts of female and male hormones which causes many complications and fatal if not treated. It's vague what being sexless or what the manga calls it "genderless people" have to deal with when it comes with endocrine issues and how it differs from intersex people. I never read all chapters so I don't know if intersex people were ever mentioned or even exist in the manga.
    2) It was definitely a choice to make being genderless deadly so it is likely for a cause of urgency because Hinase might have never chosen a sex or a gender without this possible cause of death.
    3) I'm not sure about what you mean by option. Do you mean choosing to remain without a certain sex or not identifying as girl or boy? Perhaps both. It's hard to determine what is realistic as everyone has their own definition to what is the norm or real. The author could have a very different idea on being realistic from being from Japan. To me I don't think it is realistic because it is fiction and uses its own logic. But it's genuine in its own way in demonstrating how transitioning may feel like and how faucets in identity or sexuality work.

    Silvermilk June 18, 2026 2:24 pm
    1) It is likely that all sexless people die young because they face the same issue with Hinase which is dealing with excessive amounts of female and male hormones which causes many complications and fatal if no... MoisturizingCream

    Both but I think the latter works best in this story, i just found it interesting that the author never considered any characters of just not conforming to either gender (even with a binary sex!) I’m pretty sure enby folks live in Japan if I’m not mistaken (though I’m not sure what the differences are versus non-JPN folks on how they are presented) but I can see how people reading the story can be mislead, though I enjoyed it. I don’t think the author was malicious by any means, I just think their world-building has some merits of criticism lol.

Silvermilk May 22, 2026 12:17 am

If you love the hyunjae yoojin ship you will LOVE this arc, this arc sold me on their chemistry it is AMAZING. I hope the manhwa does it justice cuz I'm so excited

    Kyokyo May 22, 2026 12:27 am

    Spill it pleaseeee.
    I will include you in my every prayer
    ლ(´ڡ`ლ)

    miws May 22, 2026 2:21 am

    Pls what chapter is this in the novel

    Zuki May 22, 2026 8:38 am
    Pls what chapter is this in the novel miws

    Hi there, this is around chp 180 to 181!

    Zuki May 22, 2026 8:43 am
    Spill it pleaseeee.I will include you in my every prayerლ(´ڡ`ლ) Kyokyo

    I'm not the person ur referring to but this arc really is good. I'm gonna spoil EVERYTHING in this arc so be careful I mean from the roof to the basement floor so BEWARE


    Shj is laying his chin on hyj's head as hyj confronts shj why he isn't invited. shj saying "you don't need an invite because your my item" and then in the birthday party itself, shj and hyj having a heated fight before shj becomes a gentleman.... And then some circumstances happen and 1/3 people sing happy birthday for shj and the only one is hyj who bought the cake...? (Wasn't a cake but they had to make do) and lit a candle in a Korean convience store lol ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭

    Silvermilk May 22, 2026 8:57 am
    I'm not the person ur referring to but this arc really is good. I'm gonna spoil EVERYTHING in this arc so be careful I mean from the roof to the basement floor so BEWAREShj is laying his chin on hyj's head as h... Zuki

    Yes you covered my favorite parts, plus shj changing hyj’s contact name to partner and symbolizing the shift in their relationship

    miws May 22, 2026 12:33 pm
    Hi there, this is around chp 180 to 181! Zuki

    Thank youu

    Kyokyo May 23, 2026 10:18 am
    I'm not the person ur referring to but this arc really is good. I'm gonna spoil EVERYTHING in this arc so be careful I mean from the roof to the basement floor so BEWAREShj is laying his chin on hyj's head as h... Zuki

    Omg thank you. I pray for your bed always comfortable, and your food always be delicious

    Kyokyo May 23, 2026 10:20 am
    Yes you covered my favorite parts, plus shj changing hyj’s contact name to partner and symbolizing the shift in their relationship Silvermilk

    Thank you. I pray for all the traffic lights always on go whenever you on the road

Silvermilk's questions ( All 2 )

Silvermilk June 19, 2026 5:31 am

I'm trying to find a manga that has that one panel where the best friend of the mc dresses up as a girl and it looks so good. I remember they had black hair and the artstyle was similar to fujimotos. The panel was trending on twitter a while back. Please someone help me find this title I am getting desperate and google is no help.

Silvermilk November 6, 2024 8:21 am

Can someone rec me good manhwa ab the triumphs of women’s rights/manhwa w/ feminist themes this election has got me so depressed (I hate this country)

Silvermilk's favorite ( All 0 )

Silvermilk's message board ( All 0 )

Any MC appreciation squad leader / side couples are usually not my thing (BUT I MAKE ACCEPTIONS)

Silvermilk follow ( All 0 )

> 1 people followed Silvermilk