yup
Nope. Remember FL took poison that would’ve killed her and her child anyways.
wasn't he the one who gave her the poison? between that, the punch to her stomach, and the beatings from the other inmates, there were multiple factors that could have led to the miscarriage. regardless, he still played a role in what happened.
Reread chapter 44. He didn’t tell her to drink the poison, he literally was just talking to her and she chose to grab it and drink it herself. The punch to her stomach was to get the poison out, otherwise she would have DIED by killing herself with it.
This whole entire thing happened because of the FL. She chose to run away, she chose to hide her identity, she chose not to speak up so he wouldn’t recognize her, she chose not to write her name as “rose.” Mind you, he only knows her as the criminal that physically DISABLED HIM. Why should he have any compassion to someone he believes harmed him. Y’all need to stop blaming MLs for the FLs dumb decisions. If the roles were reversed and FL was the one blinded and the guy was being punished, I can’t imagine how many excuses yall would give her smh
girl, i wasn't even talking about who's more at fault i was talking about the miscarriage. saying he played a role in it isn't the same as saying the FL did nothing wrong. you started listing every bad decision Rose ever made when my point was simply that multiple factors contributed to the miscarriage, and some of them involved him.
also, the ML literally hated the person who blinded him and made that very clear i don't know why people act like Rose hiding her identity was some completely irrational decision. whether it was the right choice or not, her fear made perfect sense given what she knew. i don't blame the ML in fact, i don't have any hatred or aggression towards him. he was a victim of his elder brother's scheming, and so was the FL. that's why i find it hard to paint either of them as the sole villain in this situation（/TДT)/
So did you read the part where I said FL took the poison herself? Him punching her saved her life. That poison would’ve killed her and the baby regardless if he chose to not punch her. I would say she unknowingly killed her own child before ever blaming him for it. Plus there’s a whole novel with spoilers that can provide all the answers with proof.
Does the novel ever say that the poison was the reason for her miscarriage? Because in the manhwa the miscarriage happened after she was physically abused by the other inmates
The novel does not state exactly what caused the miscarriage. It also doesn’t state that the prisoners beat her. At most insulted, spat, “stepped on or kicked near her.” So the manhwa brought it to a higher level of assault and changed it, than what was included in the novel.
It also states in the novel that her body was already in pain BEFORE the prisoners even did that. Even in the manhwa the FL felt her stomach hurt and her only thought was “were my organs damaged by the poison?” She didn’t have a single thought that the punch or the beatings from the prisoners was the cause of her stomach pain.
-
-
-
Anyways the point is, you shifted the blame to the ML and the prisoners and didn’t think about FL poisoning herself was a cause at all. I didn’t even say FL WAS the one to kill the child, I just stated the ML shouldn’t be blamed for that and that FL poisoning herself WOULD’VE killed the child had it been fully settled in her stomach. We can say no one knows the exact cause. But blaming the ML and prisoners isn’t the right answer. Also in real life, some miscarriages happen immediately after whatever harm came to the mother’s body- but majority of the time miscarriages take a while to happen so the exact cause may not be the thing that happened right before the bleeding. Also miscarriages often are not caused by outside physical factors and usually caused by the baby not being able to develop well. Which connects with what was said in the manhwa by the prisoner, who said FL was too weak and the baby wouldn’t have survived regardless in her condition.
so basically he unknowingly killed his own child!????