Ah yes, the classic “I have plenty to say, but I’ll just tell you to leave” strategy. Truly a groundbreaking contribution to the discussion. And calling anyone who criticizes romanticized rape a “fun police” definitely makes the argument disappear. I’m sure if you had an actual response to what I said, you would’ve given it by now.
I literally came here looking for a comment talking about how bad the plot is and I’m so glad I found yours. Like the actual plot is beautiful and it got me so excited and craving for more which makes it even more frustrating because why does it have to involve rape. I love bl with all my heart but this kind of thing genuinely breaks my heart every time. And like what you said, it’s even worse seeing how many readers actually condone this kind of plot. The whole romanticizing rape + stockholm syndrome thing is really making me lose hope of finding a beautiful bl. And the worst part is how they barely even show the trauma of the victim. They just brush it off and somehow turn it into romance? Like hello? It honestly leaves me feeling so broken. I’m just so glad I’m not the only one who feels this way. I so love smut but even a tiny bit of coercion is already such a huge ick for me. I just wish all authors would realize you can write smut and intense romance without romanticizing SA. It genuinely breaks my heart seeing it ruin what could’ve been such a beautiful story.
You know, whenever I talk about or defend the idea that people are normalizing this kind of thing, they always hit me with, “Why are you reading this? If it’s not your cup of tea, fuck off.” Or, more commonly, “It’s fiction. If you can’t differentiate fiction from reality, then you need to learn how to.”
The problem is that people should understand that fiction is often written to depict things that can happen in real life. Even when it’s fictional, it is still supposed to feel close to reality, especially when it deals with human experiences. That’s literally the point of fiction.
Rape is a human experience. It is not some fictionalized, hypothetical thing happening to another creature on another planet that has nothing to do with us. We are talking about something that actually happens to real people.
The problem is that authors often never portray rape in a way that reflects how it actually happens. If you look at how rape really happens, the victim isn’t secretly enjoying it or romanticizing it. They resist. They try to stop it. They do everything they can to get away from the situation. But you rarely see characters written that way when the rapist is supposed to be the ML, because then he would actually be portrayed as a rapist and would most likely be the villain of the story.
That’s what people are trying to ignore. Rape was never something that was supposed to be normalized. Even in the dark romance fiction people used to read, there was usually a clear distinction between portraying something dark and actually romanticizing it. Nowadays, we increasingly see stories romanticizing it, dressing it up as something cute, and then expecting the audience to accept it because the character is the ML.
And whenever someone tries to point that out, everyone gathers around, corners them, and treats them like they’re the ones doing something disgusting. Like, bro, we’re literally saying that this shouldn’t be normalized. Why is that such a fucking problem for you people?
Alright here it is: it's proven over and over by actual studies that what you enjoy in fiction has nothing to do with your real life preferences. Pal I've been reading toxic yaoi before you were born and I'm the nicest most selfless and empathetic person ever. What can happen tho is someone that was already violent being drawn to violent media but you can't turn violent because of what you consume. Now go ahead and dismiss everything I said because you don't like it
That applies to literally everything. You're basically saying fiction should only be sunshine and rainbows and advocating for censorship. The average yaoi back in the 90s was just rape without a single healthy story in sight but now thanks to people with your mindset we have plenty. You can just go there and read those instead
If you have to call yourself selfless and empathetic you probably aren’t. Especially if you deem yourself to be the most selfless and empathetic of all. Don’t be mad because someone is stating their opinion and you don’t like it. As the other person said, the problem isn’t rape in media, it’s the constant romanticization of it. Along with this, you can state your opinion on a subject without demeaning someone else. No one cares how long you’ve been reading yaoi for and you don’t hold authority over others simply because of it. Lastly, would you mind providing the title to one of these studies that specifically discusses the portrayal of rape in media and its effects on consumers? You state you have evidence that supports your belief and I would like to see it. Maybe you’re aware of something I’m not.
Ah yes, the scientific evidence known as “I've been reading toxic yaoi before you were born” and the peer-reviewed journal of “I'm the nicest, most selfless, empathetic person ever.” Truly groundbreaking evidence. Just because you claim you're empathetic doesn't mean everyone else magically reacts to fiction the same way. Your personal reading history isn't exactly a universal scientific constant.
Nobody is saying reading dark fiction automatically turns someone violent. That's a strawman. The point is that media can influence attitudes, perceptions, and what people become desensitized to and I've seen far more empathy from people who can read dark fiction while still recognizing when the behavior being portrayed is fucked up. Meanwhile, some people reach an SA chapter and suddenly their empathy goes on vacation because “but it's fiction
“You're advocating for censorship” is an impressive conclusion to reach from “I'm criticizing the way this is portrayed.” Criticism is not censorship. If you can create whatever fiction you want, other people are equally free to say, “This writing romanticizes something horrific, and I don't like how you're framing it.” You don't get creative freedom and a magical immunity from criticism.
And “go read something else” is such a lazy response. If your defense of a piece of media is basically “don't criticize it, just leave,” then what exactly are you defending—the story or your inability to handle criticism? Nobody is demanding sunshine and rainbows. Nobody is saying rape can't exist in fiction. We're criticizing the framing, the romanticization, and the way readers sometimes excuse it.
And bringing up “90s yaoi had rape too” doesn't refute anything because nobody said it didn't. The point is the sheer difference in scale, accessibility, and exposure. Back then, if you wanted some obscure toxic/rape-heavy material, you generally had to actively seek it out, find a physical copy, and actually pay for it. You weren't scrolling through your phone and having algorithms shove edits, recommendations, clips, and discussions about it onto your screen when you weren't even looking for it.
So comparing “it existed in the ’90s too” completely misses the point. Existence isn't the issue. Mass accessibility and exposure are. If you're going to compare then and now, maybe compare how many people are being exposed to and consuming this content instead of telling everyone how long you've personally been reading it.
And seriously, “I've been reading toxic yaoi before you were born” is not an argument. That's a reading-history flex, not evidence. Your personal experience doesn't make your interpretation universal.
You don't have to stop reading it. You just have to accept that other people are allowed to look at the exact same thing and say, “This is fucked up.” That's not censorship. That's literally criticism.
Well, same. Whenever someone criticizes it, they suddenly bring out the “empathy” card. If fiction supposedly doesn't affect their minds or reality at all, then why are these people getting so turned on by fictional characters who literally murder and rape people in their so-called fucked-up stories? Apparently fiction has “no effect” until it's time to get emotionally and sexually invested in a fictional psychopath. Make it make sense.
And if they're such empathetic people, why does that empathy mysteriously disappear the second someone says something negative about their precious fictional character? Suddenly they're insulting and cursing at actual people in the comments over a character who doesn't even exist.
How are we supposed to critique things then? Do we just never speak our minds? Your point makes no sense. Not a single person has brought up morals except you. If you’re that worried about censorship why not go ahead and look into it a little more? Plenty of excellent stories that portray rape are being challenged/banned and have been for a long time. For instance, Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson depicts SA and faces many censorship’s because of its content and themes. Instead of being mad at someone for not liking an element of a story you like, why not focus on larger issues?
Media psychology already debunked the outdated “hypodermic needle model,” so no, reading one toxic story won’t magically turn someone into a bad person. But the opposite claim—that fictional preferences are completely sealed off from real-life psychology—isn’t supported either. Uses and Gratifications, Narrative Transportation, and Cultivation research all show different ways that psychological traits influence media choices and that repeated, immersive media exposure can interact with attitudes and perceptions over time. So “I read toxic fiction and I’m still a good person” doesn’t prove fiction has absolutely nothing to do with reality. Here, your own Google search proved the point. And of course, you probably won’t read this either.

The “it’s fiction, learn to differentiate reality” argument is so tired. I KNOW it’s fiction. Fiction can still normalize and romanticize harmful behavior. And let’s be honest, the ML being attractive absolutely affects how people excuse what he does. There are literally real-life cases where attractive criminals received massive public sympathy because of their looks.
The issue isn’t rape simply existing in fiction; it’s how it’s repeatedly sexualized, romanticized, and excused when the perpetrator is the attractive ML. Authors rarely show the actual psychological aftermath either: PTSD, fear, withdrawal, difficulty trusting people, and long-term trauma. They skip that reality because actually portraying it would make it obvious how horrific rape is instead of making it look like “dark romance.”
And please don’t hit me with the “people watch murder mysteries and don’t become murderers” argument. Murder and rape aren’t interchangeable, especially when one is being repeatedly romanticized as part of a dark romance. And the normalization literally shows in the comments when people say, “MC deserved it.” Imagine saying that about an actual victim. Then when someone calls it out, you ask, “Why are you taking fiction so seriously?” THAT is exactly the problem. You’ve become so desensitized to it that rape is being treated like a casual plot device.