Marion’s character does have depth. It seems we interpreted the story differently but her character is having chivalry and compassion.
“How the hell would she have survived on the battlefield and lead her family and region without leading qualities and resolution and strength and willpower.”
To answer this, she did survive. Assuming the qualities needed for survival are what you mentioned…she must’ve had them since she survived. We also learned from her background that she did lead her people which is why they care for her.
She is a “strong woman” but that’s not bad at all? What qualities would you like her to have?
She does voice out her opinion to the ml and speaks of her values quite often. In one of rhe chapters, she did not let the ml stop her from saving people.
Furthermore, she is not a reader of some novel. She’s obviously going to be unaware of the ml’s personality since she has not seen it firsthand and does not know his background. We’re still early in the story so we do not know how she ended up by the king’s side and meeting victor.
I think you did not completely understand what i was saying. It is the typical trope of 'i am strong but i am also so very different from other women but ohter than that i have nothing that makes me a whole person" . Pick me + a very shallow description of a character. Mostly rooted in misoginy too. Like the men are all different. It is never associated with a man that "he is different than other men" (unless its the point to showthis but even then it is never the whole point of his character. )
And what annoys me is that she is supposed to be a leader. One with compassion and the brain and instic to lead and survive. And then she suddenly turns into a passive wifey-trope? That just does not make sense. Yes humans are conplex but the all her sides just feel like different characters and are not fused with another as to make a character. A leader so compassionate and focused on surviving and her people's survival may "make up her mind" but she would definitely think and miss her people! The ones she survived all those cold years together with. The laughter that made her want to survive and help each other. The bonds.
No mention of that whatsoever.
And a compassionate and strong leader would know how to set boundaries. Yes there may be diffculities in human interaction and insecurities with her new role, but a person like that would never just passively take it and sit at home. Maybe wait and analyze the situation. Maybe ask questions. Maybe find sth to do. Maybe research. Honing more or new skills. Like where is her Drive? Even if it were to live leisurely for a but that would be fine and understandable too but tnothing?
"Oh well she defended her people once and she told him her opinion once too!"
Good for her. But thatuch would ve expected ffrom a normal person too! And that is all?
I mean normally a huge part of a character whose whole purpose is survival is also later when they are safe to learn how to thrive and not just survive.
It annoys and hugely disappoints me cause she was made to be out this strong character just to be turned into another wife fantasy with no character, depth. With no understanding how sich characters and basicalls humans work. Its less that i have a picture in mind how she should behave or act or what is supposed to happen next and more like thats just not how humans work: be it their brains, physiology or mental state. It feels like another fantasy romance (which are absolutely fine) but they wanted someone who could defend themselvey so bam she was a warrior and now she is a pretty bird in a cage character. It started off so interesting and its just really disappointing and feels baiting people.

Will Marions character ever get any depth or make any sense?
Like victor is the typical " i want to have this person. Lock her away. And by doing that i take everything from her that made her "her"" kinda guy.
But she is just really badly written! Like no character at all! What abput the friends and family and comrades she had back home? Not once does seh talk abput missing them! Or do we really believe an heir and knight and one of the best warriors has sich bad instincts with people? And is so naive? Letting her independence be taken away just like that? Not one choosing intiative? How the hell would she have survived on the battlefield and lead her family and region without leading qualities and resolution and strength and willpower. No person would give that up just like that or be able to change their inner core just because they made up their mind "to pay the price"!Her only character trait is being "the strong woman who is different than other women". Wth is that??
The story had for the original idea but maaaaan ii am really disappointed with another weak and badly written female protagonist.
Maybe i am wrong and there will be growth? Is there growth?