Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.

I just started this but already have a huge gripe. The current emperor helping her now is ...

Blurrionice September 25, 2026 5:23 pm

I just started this but already have a huge gripe. The current emperor helping her now is also the same one that sentenced her to exile for the crime she didn't commit. It seems like her harbors no resentment towards the emperor. I get the timeline is different but I would at least have been angry at the emperor (her own brother) for essentially signing her death warrant. I am super angry for her.

Responses
    Blurrionice September 25, 2026 9:39 pm

    Alright, I am going to lose it. Before the emperor learned the FL was abused, she was just the daughter of a vile woman. That plus a crime she didn't commit was enough to send a child to be exiled in Siberia. But now that they know she was abused, that somehow makes her more innocent than before??? Literally WHAT?! Oh my lord. She mentions the emperor being a good dude because he would send her supplies. HE SENT YOU THERE! She spends many years alone in an ice fortress to the point where she kills herself but he's a good dude because he sent me a couple supplies so I didn't die a different way. That is maddening. He sent an innocent child to their death. No. The emperor isn't a good dude. I get what her mother did was despicable but to blame her child, your own sister, and force her to survive in a harsh environment. Author is definitely tripping.
    This logic is perpetuated by the emperor's half-brother. He meets her and immediately condemns her for because of her mother. It is not until the emperor tells him that she was abused, so that somehow makes her more innocent than before. Just asinine logic.

    Hua LanXia September 28, 2026 8:12 am
    Alright, I am going to lose it. Before the emperor learned the FL was abused, she was just the daughter of a vile woman. That plus a crime she didn't commit was enough to send a child to be exiled in Siberia. B... Blurrionice

    This, seriously, I'm pissed because this. She was abused in the firts TL too, and nobody given a fuck for it. They just sent of an abused child to die because her abuser was a trash, wow what a surprise. But now because the little prince saw that she is abused like muracle everything is solved. Wtf.

    gigglesnort October 7, 2026 7:33 pm

    I get what you're saying but I think her being banished was also for her own protection. The emperor could do a lot but he's not able to stop every scheme and I think he knew she'd be in danger if she stayed. The emperor took the only option he had to keep her alive. Leaving her alone there was the biggest mistake. If he let her stay she would have been a target and he might have had a rebellion on his hands. He really didn't have good options to keep her safe at that point. Now he should have kept a better eye on how she was being treated by her mother in the first place, but he didn't and he was left with only bad options.

    Onesownbreathreachesthesky October 21, 2026 9:30 am
    I get what you're saying but I think her being banished was also for her own protection. The emperor could do a lot but he's not able to stop every scheme and I think he knew she'd be in danger if she stayed. T... gigglesnort

    Yup. This is one of those times where I understand that the person who is in the shoes of the emperor (in this case) truly didn't have any options other than bad ones here.

    Blurrionice October 21, 2026 4:43 pm
    I get what you're saying but I think her being banished was also for her own protection. The emperor could do a lot but he's not able to stop every scheme and I think he knew she'd be in danger if she stayed. T... gigglesnort

    So sending her to an uninhabitable region in solitude is "protecting her"? His "protection" was just killing her with a few extra steps. Was she just supposed to remain in solitude for the remainder of her life, never to be exonerated? Can that really be considered protection or wiping away the problem. Why didn't the emperor investigate this case while she was away? I'm sure he could have found a way to clear her name. Was she even asked by the emperor if she was involved in poisoning or did they just follow mob mentality? I feel like it wouldn't be impossible to figure out she was being abused. All her mother's maids knew she was abused. I really despise the argument "this was his only choice" because we were never presented with other possible solutions. He sent a child to rot away in a prison for a crime she never committed, that is what he chose to do. The fact she even regards him with any favor is a disserve to MC.
    So ultimately, if your sibling punished you with solitary confinement in a extremely harsh environment for a crime you never committed, would you be able to forgive them because "they didn't have a choice"? Even when your sibling is the most powerful man in the empire. Pretty sure he went with "we've tried nothing and are all out of ideas".
    Overall, i am angry MC didn't fault the emperor. She should have been angry at him instead of praising him for sending her supplies. I guess men really do get grace for doing the absolute bare minimum.

    Naz November 16, 2026 8:54 pm

    In 1st TL, no one knew what was going behind close doors as there was some kind of agreement in which the main royal family cannot interfere with the way the consorts were raising their children. That’s why no one knew the abuse both Maximilian and Valerie suffered (while Maxi wasn’t abused the same way Valerie was, he was still being emotionally manipulated by his mother into being her perfect little puppet, even if she loved him, her love was twisted as she loved power and statues more than her son). Valerie’s mother lied about Valerie’s care, not to mention the maids were in on it. They didn’t have the right to barge in without any evidence and Valerie was kept away from them, so there wasn’t anyway they could have known what was happening to her. Valerie’s mother poisoned both Empress Layla (which caused her miscarriage in the first tl) and Dowager Empress Karin, both beloved by the empire. The nobles were calling for Valerie’s head after the attempt on Karina. Even if the brother knew Valerie was innocent his hands were tied as he knew keeping her in the empire was putting her life at risk. He exiled her for her protection. He was waiting until it was safe to bring Valerie back. She was never meant to stay there permanently. That’s why in the last life, before he died, he told Maxi to bring Valerie back from exile. Sadly it was too late by the time Maxi arrived at the estate were Valerie was exiled to.

    The reason Valerie doesn’t hold resentment towards them was cause she understood why he did what he did. Both his mother and wife were poisoned, not to mention he lost his unborn child. She had no proof for her innocence and she was the daughter of the vile woman who caused it all. He showed mercy by exiling her. It was only after learning Maxi also regressed and he told her what happened did she learn that the brother never blamed her and all he wanted to do was protect her.