why does everyone keep bringing up "omegaverse conventions" and "primal urges" to defend suah when it's shown that he consciously and deliberately crosses juhyeok's clearly stated boundaries even before they start having sexual contact?
...long post ahead....
setting aside that in the first place, we wouldn't engage with the problems and conflicts in stories and get so intrigued and invested in them without bringing our own ideas of morality or justice or fairness (among other things) into it, "it's omegaverse, of course it's different" is an odd line of argument/thinking to use for this story, anyways. even within the bounds of "this story is operating under its own moral system that's different from real life," people taking issue with characters' actions and behaviors are still engaging with the story's own moral terms, though? it's integral to establishing the stakes of the story, and raising or resolving tension. characters will knowingly push boundaries or recognize when they're being mistreated, and those instances get noted in the story itself. like here, for instance https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/you_are_my_world/uu/br_chapter-312336/pg-19/ clearly there are some moral and ethical standards at play in the world of the story, which match or are similar enough to real world standards (e.g. they have a concept of rape and nonconsensual behavior on the more intense end, and juhyeok's teammates tease him about how he treats suah on the milder end) that readers are expected to feel bad for suah at the beginning and at several points in the story after that.
suah's motivations are influenced by his childhood traumas, but the way he behaves in the present time of the story cannot be blamed on biological urges to excuse him from negative judgement on his actions when he's going out of his way to facilitate the circumstances where "succumbing" or "giving in to" his biological urges is possible at all. even if he can't bring himself to stay away like juhyeok wants, he didn't/doesn't *have* to keep scenting him, either.
people also want to say that suah's actions can be excused because it's "helping" juhyeok in life and in his athletic career, but that's ignoring how suah's "help" put juhyeok in a worse position to deal with pheromones on his own because suah kept scenting him without his input and against his stated wishes. look up the phrase "informed consent" in a non-google search engine. (assuming they're ethical in the first place) outside of emergency situations, even doctors aren't supposed to give patients tests and treatments without explaining that they're doing, why they're doing it, side effects, alternatives, etc., and the patient (or their guardian/advocate) has to CONSENT to said tests and treatments. and in emergency situations, they still have to get some kind of input from the patient/their loved ones if it's possible. sure, suah was trying to be helpful as a child without understanding the significance of what he was doing past "being helpful", but he was told and warned off about what he was doing and (we're explicitly told!) he continued to do it because it made juhyeok physically dependent on him and he wanted to force a connection between them after juhyeok distanced himself. you can say that the scenting helped juhyeok in his career as an omega surrounded by alphas especially when he didn't want to face up to being an omega, but 1) juhyeok never decided that he wanted that for himself and 2) that's neglecting to acknowledge that juhyeok would have been forced to deal with his omega nature if he'd been able to face the consequences sooner. and it's likely that as a kid, the consequences would have been more manageable than the trouble he's getting into now as an adult who hasn't learned basic skills like dealing with pheromones and heats. it's like abandoned domesticated animals in the wild or those newly minted adults-in-name-only who are helpless to take care of themselves and do basic stuff because their parents did everything for them. after a certain point, that "care" becomes harmful because it prevents them from building their own capabilities. yeah, juhyeok ran away from his omega-ness at first, but he would have been forced to contend with it sooner rather than later (and probably with lower stakes) if not for suah's interference.
omegaverse is often all about compromising the characters' bodily autonomy to indulge in smut, but avoiding the implications and aftermath of it feels like a boring cop-out, especially if it's central to the drama of the story.
i don't even have a problem with those actions being in the story, automatically, because characters having flaws and being selfish can make for interesting stories! it's interesting that juhyeok and suah's unexpected secondary genders undermined their childhood life paths and directly contradicted the way they expected to have/use each other to support their identities and self-worth! it's interesting that juhyeok rejects suah so strongly even as suah clings to him so strongly! it's interesting that suah doubles down on using their secondary genders to stay with juhyeok by using his leverage as an alpha over juhyeok, while juhyeok's drive to prove his strength and independence along with his denial of his secondary gender puts him in danger. there's even more that i could mention for both the characters and the omegaverse setting because there's a lot of interesting material there! we could even shake things up and really lean into the problems of juhyeok and suah's relationship (savior/hero complexes, anyone?), and go for an unhealthy or unstable relationship - https://www.mangago.me/home/mangatopic/21839597/
i don't need either suah or juhyeok to be perfect gentlemen in their actions towards each other, but there's a discrepancy in how their wronging or hurting each other gets treated by the narrative itself, and it favors suah quite glaringly. the narrative bends over backwards to paint suah in a sympathetic light or to implicitly excuse him after he does manipulative and boundary-crossing things, while neglecting to give juhyeok the same consideration. perhaps juhyeok seems more obviously sympathetic to the creator and so they spent more effort giving suah the sympathy plays to offset what he does, but i think the way people react so harshly to juhyeok and coddle suah in comparison derails that assumption.
even with the author's note, I'm not feeling as rosy or reconsidering my thoughts/criticisms about suah and his handling in the story like others here, because the way the story has been set up and developed so far dodges any serious or weighty development of the themes/ideas/dynamics it's working with.
the problem as I see it isn't just that suah is trash and the author unintentionally wrote him that way or had her intentions misunderstood, but that with the story developed along those lines until now, and going forward, the story is still going to gloss over how and why suah is trash. even with "primal urges" and dramatic pheromone bullshit in the mix, two people having different goals and motivations in a relationship will be consequential to the development and possible failure of that relationship. having one party in that relationship be willing to disregard the bodily autonomy and stated desires of the other party (even if it's "for their own good") the way that suah does in this story is something that takes more than a lightbulb moment and a few "sorrys" to really address and change convincingly, imo. those are some big and serious violations! some people are fine not getting into all that, but I think it'd be interesting to really grapple with that instead of just making suah "behave better" and be apologetic going forward. because otherwise, there's a shift in the character that pretty much comes out of nowhere in-universe.
and that's my gripe with much of the story. despite the creator's artistic skills and strengths in creating atmosphere and emotionally immersive moments, character and relationship developments kind of just happen. they're not completely unsignaled - there are details and moments you could point at to support those developments, but they're not as integrated into the narrative as they could be. by that, I'm talking about stuff like the changes in how juhyeok deals with his feelings towards suah and the more recent shift in suah where he's not jumping into sex and being outright coercive. if you're reading chapter by chapter on the weekly/10-day schedule as it releases (and if you're just impatiently reading for the sex scenes), then it's easy to miss that tendency towards a lack of exploration of why characters change their attitudes and actions, or depth as I see it.
it affects everything, but I think that lack/weakness is the most detrimental to juhyeok and his role in the story because even if he's a meathead who isn't very self-reflective or observant about his own and other people's feelings, he's still important to the relationship the story is centered on and so his emotional developments and interiority should be shown even if he's not necessarily going to verbalize or act on them like someone more emotionally aware would. like, you can argue that juhyeok's true feelings towards suah are shown through how he's so lenient towards suah by not making more of an issue about the nonconsensual scenting (even though that's legit a crime in-universe!) and still moves to protect suah even right after being coerced into sex and raped, but I don't think that's given enough focus or significance by the narrative to be a satisfying development of his emotions towards suah. instead, the story takes an "absence makes the heart grow fonder" turn that feels too suspiciously and conveniently placed and only makes me question just how distant suah and juhyeok were in the time between their secondary gender presentations and their current university life that that distance/absence wasn't enough to move juhyeok until now.
if the creator was trying to illustrate juhyeok as a tsundere type character, she needed to play up the 'dere-dere'/loving side of his feelings towards suah as an adult BEFORE going into coercive sexual territory with suah and not have done such a great job showing juhyeok as someone who was clearly setting reasonable boundaries even if they were hurting someone else's feelings (sucks, but it happens) and having understandable reactions to having those boundaries trampled. having so much of the "good times" be from when they were very young children, and then never/hardly showing those childhood moments or even present-day moments where juhyeok feels warmly and loving/attracted towards suah outside of sex or suah's appearance makes it hard to take juhyeok's "burgeoning feelings" seriously. it just feels so flimsy in the face of all that pushing suah away!
for the next season, people are excited for a redemption arc for suah or chase arc for juhyeok (:/) or just a change in conflict, but how is any of that going to be satisfying or done well if it continues to sidestep recognition of the problems that necessitate a redemption and change in their characters? the creator's note is slightly encouraging for acknowledging the disconnect between the creator's intentions with suah and how he's been received by readers, but it also falls rather flat because it's unclear if the creator has an accurate understanding of the problems there to then address and correct it, going by what was said in the note and the change in suah and juhyeok in the last few chapters. i'm leaning towards, "not really"...
here you have a story about one character leveraging the unfair power imbalance of their world to force their interests on another character, who's resisting out of self-preservation to reach his goals even though it's denying his true feelings - which could be an interesting exploration of love, obligation, freedom and how all those things can get tangled up and interfere or support each other. but the more fucked-up conclusions about those things in this setting are being carefully neglected in favor of pushing an idealized, even sanitized version of it.
i'm not feeling convinced by anything happening relationship-wise here, and the apparent attempt to (begin) fix(ing) it in recent chapters doesn't help because it's not solidly rooted in what has happened previously with the characters, emotionally speaking. sue me for wanting to see complex emotional journeys, i guess.
why does everyone keep bringing up "omegaverse conventions" and "primal urges" to defend suah when it's shown that he consciously and deliberately crosses juhyeok's clearly stated boundaries even before they start having sexual contact?
...long post ahead....
setting aside that in the first place, we wouldn't engage with the problems and conflicts in stories and get so intrigued and invested in them without bringing our own ideas of morality or justice or fairness (among other things) into it, "it's omegaverse, of course it's different" is an odd line of argument/thinking to use for this story, anyways. even within the bounds of "this story is operating under its own moral system that's different from real life," people taking issue with characters' actions and behaviors are still engaging with the story's own moral terms, though? it's integral to establishing the stakes of the story, and raising or resolving tension. characters will knowingly push boundaries or recognize when they're being mistreated, and those instances get noted in the story itself. like here, for instance https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/you_are_my_world/uu/br_chapter-312336/pg-19/
clearly there are some moral and ethical standards at play in the world of the story, which match or are similar enough to real world standards (e.g. they have a concept of rape and nonconsensual behavior on the more intense end, and juhyeok's teammates tease him about how he treats suah on the milder end) that readers are expected to feel bad for suah at the beginning and at several points in the story after that.
suah's motivations are influenced by his childhood traumas, but the way he behaves in the present time of the story cannot be blamed on biological urges to excuse him from negative judgement on his actions when he's going out of his way to facilitate the circumstances where "succumbing" or "giving in to" his biological urges is possible at all. even if he can't bring himself to stay away like juhyeok wants, he didn't/doesn't *have* to keep scenting him, either.
even before rut/heat/hormones can be blamed for compromising their thoughts and actions, suah deliberately and consciously plots to exploit juhyeok's dependency on him for his pheromones/cum with the whole scenting thing. we see suah spell it out and everything that he is using juhyeok's dependency on his cum/pheromones - a direct result of suah continuing the nonconsensual scenting (a crime in-universe!) even after being told to stop - as his means of getting closer to juhyeok and developing the romantic relationship that he wants.
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/you_are_my_world/uu/br_chapter-331470/pg-12/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/you_are_my_world/uu/br_chapter-319276/pg-67/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/you_are_my_world/uu/br_chapter-319276/pg-68/
people also want to say that suah's actions can be excused because it's "helping" juhyeok in life and in his athletic career, but that's ignoring how suah's "help" put juhyeok in a worse position to deal with pheromones on his own because suah kept scenting him without his input and against his stated wishes. look up the phrase "informed consent" in a non-google search engine. (assuming they're ethical in the first place) outside of emergency situations, even doctors aren't supposed to give patients tests and treatments without explaining that they're doing, why they're doing it, side effects, alternatives, etc., and the patient (or their guardian/advocate) has to CONSENT to said tests and treatments. and in emergency situations, they still have to get some kind of input from the patient/their loved ones if it's possible.
sure, suah was trying to be helpful as a child without understanding the significance of what he was doing past "being helpful", but he was told and warned off about what he was doing and (we're explicitly told!) he continued to do it because it made juhyeok physically dependent on him and he wanted to force a connection between them after juhyeok distanced himself. you can say that the scenting helped juhyeok in his career as an omega surrounded by alphas especially when he didn't want to face up to being an omega, but 1) juhyeok never decided that he wanted that for himself and 2) that's neglecting to acknowledge that juhyeok would have been forced to deal with his omega nature if he'd been able to face the consequences sooner. and it's likely that as a kid, the consequences would have been more manageable than the trouble he's getting into now as an adult who hasn't learned basic skills like dealing with pheromones and heats.
it's like abandoned domesticated animals in the wild or those newly minted adults-in-name-only who are helpless to take care of themselves and do basic stuff because their parents did everything for them. after a certain point, that "care" becomes harmful because it prevents them from building their own capabilities.
yeah, juhyeok ran away from his omega-ness at first, but he would have been forced to contend with it sooner rather than later (and probably with lower stakes) if not for suah's interference.
omegaverse is often all about compromising the characters' bodily autonomy to indulge in smut, but avoiding the implications and aftermath of it feels like a boring cop-out, especially if it's central to the drama of the story.
i don't even have a problem with those actions being in the story, automatically, because characters having flaws and being selfish can make for interesting stories! it's interesting that juhyeok and suah's unexpected secondary genders undermined their childhood life paths and directly contradicted the way they expected to have/use each other to support their identities and self-worth! it's interesting that juhyeok rejects suah so strongly even as suah clings to him so strongly! it's interesting that suah doubles down on using their secondary genders to stay with juhyeok by using his leverage as an alpha over juhyeok, while juhyeok's drive to prove his strength and independence along with his denial of his secondary gender puts him in danger. there's even more that i could mention for both the characters and the omegaverse setting because there's a lot of interesting material there! we could even shake things up and really lean into the problems of juhyeok and suah's relationship (savior/hero complexes, anyone?), and go for an unhealthy or unstable relationship - https://www.mangago.me/home/mangatopic/21839597/
i don't need either suah or juhyeok to be perfect gentlemen in their actions towards each other, but there's a discrepancy in how their wronging or hurting each other gets treated by the narrative itself, and it favors suah quite glaringly. the narrative bends over backwards to paint suah in a sympathetic light or to implicitly excuse him after he does manipulative and boundary-crossing things, while neglecting to give juhyeok the same consideration. perhaps juhyeok seems more obviously sympathetic to the creator and so they spent more effort giving suah the sympathy plays to offset what he does, but i think the way people react so harshly to juhyeok and coddle suah in comparison derails that assumption.
even with the author's note, I'm not feeling as rosy or reconsidering my thoughts/criticisms about suah and his handling in the story like others here, because the way the story has been set up and developed so far dodges any serious or weighty development of the themes/ideas/dynamics it's working with.
the problem as I see it isn't just that suah is trash and the author unintentionally wrote him that way or had her intentions misunderstood, but that with the story developed along those lines until now, and going forward, the story is still going to gloss over how and why suah is trash. even with "primal urges" and dramatic pheromone bullshit in the mix, two people having different goals and motivations in a relationship will be consequential to the development and possible failure of that relationship. having one party in that relationship be willing to disregard the bodily autonomy and stated desires of the other party (even if it's "for their own good") the way that suah does in this story is something that takes more than a lightbulb moment and a few "sorrys" to really address and change convincingly, imo. those are some big and serious violations! some people are fine not getting into all that, but I think it'd be interesting to really grapple with that instead of just making suah "behave better" and be apologetic going forward. because otherwise, there's a shift in the character that pretty much comes out of nowhere in-universe.
and that's my gripe with much of the story. despite the creator's artistic skills and strengths in creating atmosphere and emotionally immersive moments, character and relationship developments kind of just happen. they're not completely unsignaled - there are details and moments you could point at to support those developments, but they're not as integrated into the narrative as they could be. by that, I'm talking about stuff like the changes in how juhyeok deals with his feelings towards suah and the more recent shift in suah where he's not jumping into sex and being outright coercive. if you're reading chapter by chapter on the weekly/10-day schedule as it releases (and if you're just impatiently reading for the sex scenes), then it's easy to miss that tendency towards a lack of exploration of why characters change their attitudes and actions, or depth as I see it.
it affects everything, but I think that lack/weakness is the most detrimental to juhyeok and his role in the story because even if he's a meathead who isn't very self-reflective or observant about his own and other people's feelings, he's still important to the relationship the story is centered on and so his emotional developments and interiority should be shown even if he's not necessarily going to verbalize or act on them like someone more emotionally aware would. like, you can argue that juhyeok's true feelings towards suah are shown through how he's so lenient towards suah by not making more of an issue about the nonconsensual scenting (even though that's legit a crime in-universe!) and still moves to protect suah even right after being coerced into sex and raped, but I don't think that's given enough focus or significance by the narrative to be a satisfying development of his emotions towards suah. instead, the story takes an "absence makes the heart grow fonder" turn that feels too suspiciously and conveniently placed and only makes me question just how distant suah and juhyeok were in the time between their secondary gender presentations and their current university life that that distance/absence wasn't enough to move juhyeok until now.
if the creator was trying to illustrate juhyeok as a tsundere type character, she needed to play up the 'dere-dere'/loving side of his feelings towards suah as an adult BEFORE going into coercive sexual territory with suah and not have done such a great job showing juhyeok as someone who was clearly setting reasonable boundaries even if they were hurting someone else's feelings (sucks, but it happens) and having understandable reactions to having those boundaries trampled. having so much of the "good times" be from when they were very young children, and then never/hardly showing those childhood moments or even present-day moments where juhyeok feels warmly and loving/attracted towards suah outside of sex or suah's appearance makes it hard to take juhyeok's "burgeoning feelings" seriously. it just feels so flimsy in the face of all that pushing suah away!
for the next season, people are excited for a redemption arc for suah or chase arc for juhyeok (:/) or just a change in conflict, but how is any of that going to be satisfying or done well if it continues to sidestep recognition of the problems that necessitate a redemption and change in their characters? the creator's note is slightly encouraging for acknowledging the disconnect between the creator's intentions with suah and how he's been received by readers, but it also falls rather flat because it's unclear if the creator has an accurate understanding of the problems there to then address and correct it, going by what was said in the note and the change in suah and juhyeok in the last few chapters. i'm leaning towards, "not really"...
here you have a story about one character leveraging the unfair power imbalance of their world to force their interests on another character, who's resisting out of self-preservation to reach his goals even though it's denying his true feelings - which could be an interesting exploration of love, obligation, freedom and how all those things can get tangled up and interfere or support each other. but the more fucked-up conclusions about those things in this setting are being carefully neglected in favor of pushing an idealized, even sanitized version of it.
i'm not feeling convinced by anything happening relationship-wise here, and the apparent attempt to (begin) fix(ing) it in recent chapters doesn't help because it's not solidly rooted in what has happened previously with the characters, emotionally speaking. sue me for wanting to see complex emotional journeys, i guess.
gold star for anyone who gets this far XD