-For my first theory - I believe that regardless of whether or not they remember what happened right now, subconsciously they do without realizing it. I say that because of how Doha woke up, he realized that something was weird and said he felt like he lost something (aka Bada) and afterwards easily accepted his confession without even knowing him. He also has already been treating him with more care and attention than all of his other partners like that green eye guy who warned Bada pointed out, so this is very out of character for who he originally was. As for the rest of them, I say this for them because of their reactions to their supposed friend being missing and them not seeming at all concerned especially when interacting with said friend's literal cousin. You would think they would care more about his whereabouts and finding him rather than his cousin's lovelife with their other friend. Maybe I'm just reading too deep into it but Seongchan did literally betray them all and was willing to escape without them so I could see that betrayal causing them to be less concerned about him even if they don't remember it at the moment. We also see different shots of Doha watching Bada after he says something, it’s either him wondering how in the world Bada knows him as well as he does or he could be starting to remember things by triggers. These triggers could be things that Bada says or events that occur and I think that maybe this horror movie which seems eerily similar to what they all went through could be another. Either that and/or Bada gets triggered because the description of the movie is a little like their prior situation…
-Second theory- Someone trapped them there, not really sure why this would happen but going back to zombies in spaceland I could see them being put there because of a ritual. If I remember right, the reason they went there in the first place was to explore the abandoned house and they ended up getting trapped there. Then Doha and Seongchan dragged Bada in there with them. My memories are a bit fuzzy but I don’t remember how they got Bada in there if they were locked in by that gate thing, maybe I’m remembering incorrectly or Bada was already in there because he was coming to deliver Seongchan’s clothes. Moving on, the reason i think they were locked in there is because I think that the time loop likely existed before they even got there. The ritual at the end was made to put everything back to the way it was before, which removed the village and collapsed the tunnel, finally releasing everyone from the loop. It would make sense for them to have been lured with the idea of an abandoned house to explore because you know people like to do horror movie type things like that in real life so it’s not a stretch to assume fictional characters could be enticed by that idea as well. So they took the bait and were trapped there by someone who was already in there, since they are outsiders they could have possibly been able to leave and the people who were there before couldn’t so they found a way to trap them there in the time loop by physically blocking their escape.
-third theory to support the second - The tapes are what solidified them being trapped in the loop. Someone had to have made them for each of the characters, since none of the other characters remember we only have Bada to go off of and he was not part of the original crew. He was dragged in after, so there could be a chance that before his first tape was even created things happened that he can’t remember because there wasn’t a tape to save his memories. It also says that Seongchan took out his tape to reset him and Doha saved the game for him which helped him retain some real-world memories so there’s a chance that between the time he was dragged in and reset to having his memories saved again that there’s a gap because his memories essentially went back in time to when he first got there or skipped over it completely . The memory gap might not support the tape creation theory but it would explain why there are things we might just never know about what happened because Bada didn’t save the memory of it.
-fourth theory- Bada caused a glitch in the game, thus was put into an npc type role. He was never part of the original crew, hence why they were going to sacrifice him at the end because his character was never supposed to be there. But, that didn’t happen because he made Seongchan take his place. I think part of the reason Seongchan was sacrificed in the first place was because due to the fact he was trying to escape alone it was taking a long time for them to beat the game, I mean like if you think about it the amount of tapes at the end was genuinely wild it had to of taken a long time to finally get out and for the people who were trapped before them it would be hella annoying to have to wait longer because of one selfish guy. Anyways the reason I say Bada caused a glitch and the game to warp with him is because he was put into the npc role and also couldn’t kill the killer while everyone else could. If he was just an npc he might not have been targeted as much as he was either and I think that was their way of correcting this glitch or intruder but people kept putting his tapes back in which made him come back each time which kinda warped him into a character rather than just an npc. I also think the fact that he can actually remember stuff about what happens shows he’s a glitch too because the real characters couldn’t remember anything. I think the key to them getting their memories back as well is Bada because he could still be acting as the glitch. Doha could get his memories back the fastest because he’s the one spending the most time with Bada. He also is trying to keep Bada away from them and if he actually does remember some stuff it would kinda make sense for him to just want it to be him and Bada remembering because that’s a way only the two of them are connected, like he wouldn’t want to share that with anyone else even his friends.
That’s it for now, I’ll probably have more as the side stories come out but I need to do a full reread so I can make them more accurately. Likely we won’t find out what exactly is the cause because the creator did not say we would, they just said more smut scenes, Bada’s ptsd, and Doha’s reaction to it. I hope at least some questions are answered though and we find out if they get their memories back because it would be hell to be the only person to remember all the traumatizing stuff you had to go through because someone dragged you into it.

*SPOILERS FOR THE WHOLE STORY*
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Finally awaited side stories have arrived, which means more theories on what's going on. First of all, in the creator's note they say for their vision of the side stories "You'll also see Bada experience mild PTSD as a result of the game, and Doha reacting strangely when he sees Bada suffering." They also mentioned previously that they regretted not being able to convey fully what they wanted. The side stories are a chance to knock out both of these things and I do hope we get more clarity on the plot because I was left with a lot of questions. Before I begin I just wanna say I haven't gone back to reread just yet, it's on my bucket list but rn I'm just going off my previous comments of questions and theories.
Anyways, starting off with the movie theater poster. I've had a lot of different theories about how exactly this all started but seeing the house on the poster that looked similar to the house we see in the first chapter, well it reminds me a lot of the story for Infinite Warfare: Zombies in Spaceland.
If you don't know the lore for that, I linked a youtube video, it's 19 minutes of the cutscenes for each game: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwXv0xr2TpU If you don't want to watch it, a brief summary is that Willard Wyler is a film director who tricked 4 unsuspecting people into coming to his theater for his "big comeback" and performed a ritual that sucked them into a movie. You are playing as the characters and fighting zombies in each map, but there are easter eggs and a bossfight that allow you to complete the game. Once they defeat each map they are transported to the next, until finally they make it back to the theater. Not trying to go too deep here, but they are not the only people tricked, there are other actors who came before them and likely got trapped by the same ritual. Each of them are featured in their own game in the series and there is one that the lady is actually talking about how they are forced to continue over and over watching the same movie just reliving it every time (at one point she said she even killed herself a few times). The characters you play as also talk about having deja vu at certain times while playing which I feel like implies that just like the other actors they as characters are continuously going through this and maybe not exactly remembering because they are not fully integrated into the movie like the actors are.
Back onto Dreadful Night, I feel like there's a lot of similarities here. Being forced into a game/movie (will explain why I say movie for DN as well), having to repeat over and over, losing memories, horror themes, etc. For a refresher: At the end of DN, there was a ritual that occurred and the cultists said everything would return to its proper place and sacrificed seongchan. Then when they get to the tunnel someone says "the lockis gone" and they all walk through together, this is when everyone loses their memories except for Bada. Doha, in his pov noticeably realizes that there is something off. In the first ss chapters we already get some interesting info and that is: the village disappeared, seongchan is missing, Bada was never an npc, and supposedly no time has passed either. I also noticed that weirdly none of them seem too concerned about seongchan and there's several shots of Doha just observing Bada after he says stuff like he's trying to put things together.
I'll post my theories in the replies