Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.

I do like the story but.........

nathaniel April 25, 2020 12:09 am

if you're going to give me a strong female character, then give me a strong female character. Don't hold back. I've read a lot of comics that have successfully done this. I'm definitely not saying that MC here is not strong, but compared to other dynamic characters that I've come across, she definitely is not on the top.

Responses
    Soart April 25, 2020 2:45 am

    Could you recommend some strong fl mangas? Most of the ones I've read, they start off strong/ give off that vibe and then end up having to be rescued all the time, dependant and just plain weak

    nathaniel April 25, 2020 5:06 am

    My gold list : Amazing, amazing, amazing
    The Reason Why Raeliana Ended up at the Duke's Mansion
    The Investigator of Mueller
    Sengoku Komachi Kurou Tan!
    Raise wa Tanin ga Ii
    Light & Shadow
    Gokusen
    Emperor And The Female Knight
    Charlotte Has Five Disciples

    High Tier - Great MC, ok plot.
    Taming a Shrew
    Inso's Law
    You At First Sight
    July Found by Chance
    Reiri
    Living as the Tyrant's Older Sister
    Dareka Kono Joukyou wo Setsumei Shite Kudasai!

    Low Tier: Relatively great MC, relatively ok plot
    Beauty Pop
    Mejaz - Regulus in the World
    This Time I Will Definitely Be Happy
    Aura From Another Planet
    Hoshi to Kuzu - Don't Worry, Be Happy

    In Question:
    The Black Haired Princess
    Burning Effect

    Green_Witch April 25, 2020 6:50 am
    My gold list : Amazing, amazing, amazingThe Reason Why Raeliana Ended up at the Duke's MansionThe Investigator of MuellerSengoku Komachi Kurou Tan! Raise wa Tanin ga IiLight & ShadowGokusen Emperor And The ... nathaniel

    I fell in love and trusted your list just for mentioning Light and Shadow and Raise was Tanin plus Raeliana in your God Tier. I'm so going to read the rest!! Thank you!!!

    Green_Witch April 25, 2020 6:51 am
    My gold list : Amazing, amazing, amazingThe Reason Why Raeliana Ended up at the Duke's MansionThe Investigator of MuellerSengoku Komachi Kurou Tan! Raise wa Tanin ga IiLight & ShadowGokusen Emperor And The ... nathaniel

    I fell in love and trusted your list just for mentioning Light and Shadow and Raise was Tanin plus Raeliana in your God Tier. I'm so going to read the rest!! Thank you!!!ヾ(☆▽☆)

    NovemberHalloween April 25, 2020 4:08 pm
    My gold list : Amazing, amazing, amazingThe Reason Why Raeliana Ended up at the Duke's MansionThe Investigator of MuellerSengoku Komachi Kurou Tan! Raise wa Tanin ga IiLight & ShadowGokusen Emperor And The ... nathaniel

    I see that you're a woman/man of excellent taste! I approve! Lmao

    lucia_luce April 26, 2020 5:43 am
    My gold list : Amazing, amazing, amazingThe Reason Why Raeliana Ended up at the Duke's MansionThe Investigator of MuellerSengoku Komachi Kurou Tan! Raise wa Tanin ga IiLight & ShadowGokusen Emperor And The ... nathaniel

    Whoa honestly it's surprised me to see someone recommends beauty pop (by kiyoko arai, right?), that's my childhood favorite manga! I still have the hard copies but it's been so long since i last read it, what a memory

    Kubo April 26, 2020 5:46 am
    My gold list : Amazing, amazing, amazingThe Reason Why Raeliana Ended up at the Duke's MansionThe Investigator of MuellerSengoku Komachi Kurou Tan! Raise wa Tanin ga IiLight & ShadowGokusen Emperor And The ... nathaniel

    Thanks for the recommendations (⌒▽⌒)

    Evergreen April 26, 2020 6:17 am
    Whoa honestly it's surprised me to see someone recommends beauty pop (by kiyoko arai, right?), that's my childhood favorite manga! I still have the hard copies but it's been so long since i last read it, what ... lucia_luce

    Wow, I was just rereading that one recently after I remembered it. Feels different from when I was younger but still fun

    Evergreen April 26, 2020 6:31 am
    My gold list : Amazing, amazing, amazingThe Reason Why Raeliana Ended up at the Duke's MansionThe Investigator of MuellerSengoku Komachi Kurou Tan! Raise wa Tanin ga IiLight & ShadowGokusen Emperor And The ... nathaniel

    Also add Vanishing Twin, the mc's sister steals everything from her in the first half but she regains herself, overall kept me on the edge

    frozenspring April 26, 2020 6:40 am

    where would you put Cheating Men Must Die ?

    ItzTinSeL April 26, 2020 7:50 am

    Oh snap!!! I finally found myself a smart one!!

    It's my lucky day. | ‹:)~❁

    Divanyak April 26, 2020 5:32 pm
    My gold list : Amazing, amazing, amazingThe Reason Why Raeliana Ended up at the Duke's MansionThe Investigator of MuellerSengoku Komachi Kurou Tan! Raise wa Tanin ga IiLight & ShadowGokusen Emperor And The ... nathaniel

    OMG YOU HAVE THE SAME LIST AS ME!! OMFG I FIND A FELLOW COMRADE

    nathaniel April 26, 2020 5:38 pm
    Also add Vanishing Twin, the mc's sister steals everything from her in the first half but she regains herself, overall kept me on the edge Evergreen

    Haven't read it but from what I can tell, it seems to be an exhausting read. I will definitely try it but I might not have the patience to finish it. With stories like that (seems to be revenge-plot), I would rather watch a movie so that I can finish it in one go (like Lady Vengeance or I Saw the Devil - they are exhausting to watch but takes only a small portion of your time). Additionally, it's from Lezhin and I do have a bias against Lezhin. Almost every comic that I read from this publisher had a disappointing or lackluster ending which is fine if the story isn't deep. However, in this story that you recommend, I have to say that it has to have a satisfactory ending. So, I am gonna ask you this, does this story have a satisfactory ending?

    nathaniel April 26, 2020 5:41 pm
    where would you put Cheating Men Must Die ? frozenspring

    I honestly like the MC but.......... other than her, there is nothing else in the story that I can commend. I have stopped reading it a long time ago because I just found it to be repetitive. If the world-building had some substance to it, I might have continued.

    frozenspring April 26, 2020 7:32 pm
    Haven't read it but from what I can tell, it seems to be an exhausting read. I will definitely try it but I might not have the patience to finish it. With stories like that (seems to be revenge-plot), I would r... nathaniel

    hmmm, not sure you will like Cheating Men Must Die. It is a quick transmigration manga.
    The MC is sent on missions in different storybooks. She needs to complete her mission in order to save that storybook world. Many of the missions do involve getting revenge on the story's Male Lead (ML) but MC does so much more. She is so smart, powerful, and meets/makes so many different friends. The series hasn't ended yet but certain arcs/worlds have been completed. Since the series is a quick transmigration it doesn't feel like there is a bigger overall plot yet. I would suggest maybe picking an arc your be interested in and trying it. Personally I like the 2nd arc the most.

    Arc 1:(ch 0-20)
    king's consort in an ancient Chinese setting- MC gets a cute son!

    Arc 2:(ch21-37)
    Movie queen- MC gets a lifetime of love!
    -love this Arc (๑•ㅂ•)و✧

    Arc 3: (ch 38-59)
    Vampires in a world with Vampire hunters

    Arc 4:(ch 60-85)
    Rich married lady vs transmigrator during the setting of the republic of china
    -personally I don't like the husband and transmigrator ending but love MC and best friend's ending

    Arc 5: (ch 86-106)
    modern-day highschool bullying- people have mix feelings about the story's ML's ending

    Arc 6:(107-idk not translated yet)
    A cultivator who loves her senior brother (studied under the same master)

    This series may not be for you. But I would like to recommend some other series you should keep an eye on.

    Crimson Karma has a similar set up as Emperor And The Female Knight but less cute. It has a strong female soldier. She is trying to learn how to become human not a tool.

    Reminiscence Adonis has a female swordsman that got sent to the past-second chance. It is a longer series so the plot can seem a little slow since the author is doing character and relationship building.

    The Evil Lady's Hero -questionable how strong MC is since the story is just starting but she is no pushover. She is a water mage/healer.

    This Girl is a Little Wild- MC was a hero but her soul was sent into another girl's body when facing off against demon king.

    May I Ask For One Final Thing?- MC otherwise know as "mad dog"- she is super strong.

    Evergreen April 26, 2020 8:04 pm
    Haven't read it but from what I can tell, it seems to be an exhausting read. I will definitely try it but I might not have the patience to finish it. With stories like that (seems to be revenge-plot), I would r... nathaniel

    First, it's a thriller so I can guarantee it's snot boring. Second, I agree I don't wanna invest myself in some long pointless story, movies seem good. Third, the ending is different depending on who sees it, for me I would have preferred a more happier and satisfying ending. But its NOT the typical revenge plot AT ALL. The mc has the best life and the sister is always being compared to her. So the sister tries to take over her life, framing her and stealing her friends and boyfriend. That's the 1st season and everyone was pulled to her side and the mc was left alone. In the second season she gets herself together to reinvent her life. She's not looking for revenge precisely cuz she still cares got her somewhat maybe not, but the plot unfolds with the people around the sister's fake personality naturally being drawn into her.

    nathaniel April 27, 2020 1:05 am
    hmmm, not sure you will like Cheating Men Must Die. It is a quick transmigration manga.The MC is sent on missions in different storybooks. She needs to complete her mission in order to save that storybook world... frozenspring

    Actually, the comics that you mentioned are on my reading list, except for reminiscence adonis.

    For the record, I have read Reminiscence Adonis and even today I stand by the idea that it has one of the best MCs out there. However, I think I got bored with the plot after a while. I may or may not come back to it in the future.

    I still have reservations regarding crimson karma, the evil lady's hero and May I ask for One Final Thing because it's still early. On preliminary review, the MCs seem to be wonderful.

    I definitely agree that This Girl is a Little Wild belongs to my Gold List.

    nathaniel April 27, 2020 1:06 am
    First, it's a thriller so I can guarantee it's snot boring. Second, I agree I don't wanna invest myself in some long pointless story, movies seem good. Third, the ending is different depending on who sees it, f... Evergreen

    Great, I'll check it out.

    Soart April 27, 2020 5:50 am
    My gold list : Amazing, amazing, amazingThe Reason Why Raeliana Ended up at the Duke's MansionThe Investigator of MuellerSengoku Komachi Kurou Tan! Raise wa Tanin ga IiLight & ShadowGokusen Emperor And The ... nathaniel

    Thank youu!! Zooming off to read them right now (づ ̄ ³ ̄)づ!!

    Znah April 30, 2020 3:35 am
    My gold list : Amazing, amazing, amazingThe Reason Why Raeliana Ended up at the Duke's MansionThe Investigator of MuellerSengoku Komachi Kurou Tan! Raise wa Tanin ga IiLight & ShadowGokusen Emperor And The ... nathaniel

    Wah thank u soo muuchh