Super Anime Fan

ima just tell you right now it’s not his son, it’s obvious that mikasa and her mystery man (which is probably jean) are visiting eren grave when they’re older and she had a kid with him.

You don't know that. You're making an assumption with no evidence. What exactly is preventing this theory from being possible?

But it doesn't make sense for him to have sex with her then rob her memory of it? Isn't that rape? She might have consented during their erased time but if he didn't return it, then the her without the memory would have been the same as someone who didn't consent. If she just turned up pregnant, that would be weird.....as far as we can see, no memory of them being intimate was returned so.....

The characters literally look like mikasa and jean, mikasa has a ponytail with black hair like she did in ch 139, jean is wearing that hat that he’s always worn in season 4. Jean has always said he wanted to marry someone like mikasa and have a kid. If you have eyes and look on twitter you can see the zoomed in photo of how the characters revisited erens grave when they were much older and had children.

First, no, it's absolutely not rape. The act would have been consensual. Eren took his friends' memories because he needed them to think badly of him so they would be able to bring themselves to kill him. And he knew they would get their memories back after he died, hence why he spoke to them about his plan first, then erased their memories so they wouldn't know what he was doing until after the deed was done. And I'm sure pregnancy wasn't the intent. People have sex all the time without the intent of getting pregnant. Just because we didn't see the intimate moment didn't mean it didn't happen. Did we see Historia have sex? No, but revealing she was pregnant told us that something happened, and revealing that Mikasa's son is Eren's would simply mean that something had happened between them (which would be revealed in the possible sequel series). And in all likelihood, neither Mikasa nor Eren even knew she had gotten pregnant after they did deed.

It can still be debated of whether the characters look like Mikasa and Jean since we only saw the backs of their heads (I've heard some people say they thought it was Gabi and Falco). And in case you didn't notice, the woman did not have Mikasa's face scar, nor was she wearing the scarf, which she never took off and was even buried with. And Jean was hardly the only person who wore a hat. MANY people wore hats like that.

But that's neither here nor there. I'm not saying that Mikasa didn't end up with Jean (despite her never showing an ounce of interest in him even once and only treating him as a comrade in arms, barely even an actual friend), nor am I saying she didn't have other children with him (but if you think about it, she clearly never got over Eren, meaning she settled for Jean, and he always played second fiddle to Eren and always had Eren's shadow looming over him in their relationship; not an appealing outcome for Jean, knowing that your wife is always pining after her dead true love while only settling for you). But there is nothing that goes against the possibility that her first son wasn't Eren. That's called a theory, and as of now, it can neither be proved or disproved.

But getting off topic, the whole reason I brought it up was for the possibility of a sequel/spin-off series, as having the main character becoming the new Founding Titan and being the descendant of Eren and Mikasa gives him a lot of depth, character, and complexity. Maybe he'll even be able to talk to Eren through the whole time communication thing, and later in the series he'll learn from Eren in a big revelation that Eren is his ancestor. But even if there is no sequel, there is currently nothing that can disprove this theory. But if they do end up doing a sequel/spin-off, I think it would make for an interesting plot device and provide interesting and complex depth for the main character.

I went to rape because it's also possible Eren didn't return certain memories to Mikasa, since we never saw memories of them being intimate during the finale.

"But there is nothing that goes against the possibility that her first son wasn't Eren." But there is though? It's that we don't see any intimate moments and you're only assuming something could have happen, not that something did happen. You're relying on clues you're making up that will possibly be revealed in the sequel to solidify this theory when we don't really know if we'll even getting anything after this. I mean, yes it's a theory, anything goes, but also a theory that is not really connecting to me. It's really reaching for something. I personally don't even like the theory or people saying that the people visiting the grave was Mikasa and Jean so I'm not saying this because I'm for Mikasa and Jean, I just genuinely don't see any good connections.

Anyway, it's a theory though so I won't tell you it's wrong. All I can say is I don't see connections. If you find more solid clues to support this theory then that would make it more interesting.

Everyone got all their erased and tampered memories with. The reason Eren would have had to erase any intimate moments between him and Mikasa is because do you really think she would have been able to bring herself to kill him once they admitted their feelings for each other and consummated their relationship. That's why he had to erase their memories of his plan after he told them and paint himself as the villain in their eyes. Even them Mikasa barely was able to bring herself to kill him.

But wouldn’t one know when they have had sex for the first time? Like come on man. Even if he erases the traces of it. She would definitely have been able to feel something down there. Also, with the way they fought the last battle, if she had been pregnant with his child, it would have died in the womb with how aggressively they were fighting. So ya, it is impossible that it is Eren and Mikasa’s. Sorry to burst your theory bubble. ╮(￣▽￣)╭

Who knows how long after they had sex he erased her memories. Days, weeks. Plenty of time to recover. Even if he took off the next days and erased everyone's memories then, based on the extensive exercises and fighting everyone does, soreness is likely a very common thing they all face. In fact, there are sone woman who don't face any soreness after their first tine (usually they do though). Furthermore, for a woman who does vigorous activities, like a sportswoman or a fighter or a dancer, etc, it's actually very common to tear their hymen, often without even knowing. And if she was pregnant, depending on what stage of the pregnancy she was in, yes the fetus most definitely could have survived completely intact. So no, you didn't burst any bubbles or disprove any theories.

Bruh please, does not matter how many times you have done it. Be it the first time or not the first time, a woman will be able to tell if she had sex. There 100 percent will be a feeling down there, not just soreness, other sort of feeling down there. Unless you have had sex, you wouldn’t understand what I am talking about so ya. I feel like a parent explaining to a child about sex education.

Like I said, doing highly extensive exercises and stuff and getting pummeled by Titans is going to result in soreness. Even if it did happen the day after, what do you think she'll be more focused on, why she's sore, or why Eren disappeared and the war they're caught up in? And again, if Eren erased her memories after she recovered, there will be no soreness for her to wonder about since she'll already be recovered. And you do realize you're trying to use real world logic in a fictional world where ordinary humans are doing superhuman feats like their nothing, right?