Listen Im not a lily defender because at her grown age she has the naivety of a child but yall realize she doesnt owe anna anything? Shes made advances throughout the years and was constantly being rejected, and was blatantly rejected in chapter 4. And ik its fucked up to sleep w someone after constantly telling someone else you love them for years but at the end of day anna DID reject her. Not just that but lily was sold to the duchess, so she cant refuse any advances she makes her, and at her lowest she was manipulated by the Duchess (which is where the naivety plays its part). Its giving right person wrong time since the duchess is forcing them apart, plus anna has her morals which lily doesnt know about (which is mainly y shes rejecting her). Anywaysss the person who deserves the hate is the Duchess imo not lily.