rose is truly a sick monster like yeah neil is trash but he doesn't even deserve all that! he could've tortured neil only..like why do u need to this to his whole blood line?
ig in rose mind he is also trying to get a revenge on edgar for choosing his brother over him and honestly this is natural between human beings to choose family also edgar wasn't interested anymore more in living and he was depressed so he just wanted to die
but rose could never understand it cause he is a forest monster and he doesn't have common sense.. and edgar is so stupid for not knowing this there were signs
It's kinda like a love story between 2 complete different creatures(?). They're made to think differently, they're so instinctively different to the point where it's difficult to even notice "signs" or understand what the other person is thinking at all.
This point reminds me of another story The Snake that Swallowed the Pomegranate; where 2 of the main characters are a dragon who falls in love with a human and despite loving him so much, he could never understand what he needs or wants and ends up hurting him instead while trying to give him everything he *thinks* could make him happy.
Plus ever since Edgar was born, everyone, including himself has been thinking "he's going to die", I don't think he was even aware that Rose could heal him? I don't think he *wanted* to die, more so he had just accepted it since long ago, "it is what it is" kind of common sense. So naturally other things like clearing one's feelings of guilt before he dies would become more "important".
Rose probably also cursed the entire bloodline because he's literally still angry. He's angry with the Otises, so he will continue to curse the Otises. Simple as that. I inferred that since even Charlotte described it as "his wrath".
All in all the whole curse is just pure tragic and unfortunate I feel.
It's kinda like a love story between 2 complete different creatures(?). They're made to think differently, they're so instinctively different to the point where it's difficult to even notice "signs" or understa... Nobody
i definitely agree with everything u said and i thought about it before u don't need to say it's not personal im totally okay with other opinions ♡ :) edgar life wasn't easy especially when he was ill and his brother always mistreated him. his aunt actually cared for him and she tried to help him but he refused.. and that's a pure stupidity tbh but he is probably an infp so that's why he accepted his brother bs and i don't like these characters at all
him still being nice to neil and telling rose to help him started everything and he truly should've known or at least read rose feelings cause edgar is a sympathetic person (like bro u r only good at being nice and sympathetic why didn't u use it with rose ughhh)
and i can't blame rose cause he is a monster who doesn't have any common sense but i still dislike him alot and its true that he is still angry
neil is trash too ofc but i don't see that he deserves all of this he hated poverty and his brother who took all the attention from him(sick behaviour ofc) but neil faced and still facing his choices and edgar? nothing he choose to die even when he had the biggest 2 chances and found his significant other who could actually help him but nooo let my abusev brother be happy..
i definitely agree with everything u said and i thought about it before u don't need to say it's not personal im totally okay with other opinions ♡ :)edgar life wasn't easy especially when he was ill and his ... lily
edgar was a victim at the beginning but when god gives u chances and u don't use them then u r literally dumb
rose is truly a sick monster
like yeah neil is trash but he doesn't even deserve all that!
he could've tortured neil only..like why do u need to this to his whole blood line?
ig in rose mind he is also trying to get a revenge on edgar for choosing his brother over him and honestly this is natural between human beings to choose family
also edgar wasn't interested anymore more in living and he was depressed so he just wanted to die
but rose could never understand it cause he is a forest monster and he doesn't have common sense..
and edgar is so stupid for not knowing this there were signs
It's kinda like a love story between 2 complete different creatures(?).
They're made to think differently, they're so instinctively different to the point where it's difficult to even notice "signs" or understand what the other person is thinking at all.
This point reminds me of another story The Snake that Swallowed the Pomegranate; where 2 of the main characters are a dragon who falls in love with a human and despite loving him so much, he could never understand what he needs or wants and ends up hurting him instead while trying to give him everything he *thinks* could make him happy.
Plus ever since Edgar was born, everyone, including himself has been thinking "he's going to die", I don't think he was even aware that Rose could heal him? I don't think he *wanted* to die, more so he had just accepted it since long ago, "it is what it is" kind of common sense.
So naturally other things like clearing one's feelings of guilt before he dies would become more "important".
Rose probably also cursed the entire bloodline because he's literally still angry. He's angry with the Otises, so he will continue to curse the Otises. Simple as that.
I inferred that since even Charlotte described it as "his wrath".
All in all the whole curse is just pure tragic and unfortunate I feel.
Aaa but of course there's nothing wrong with your perspective as well, just my two cents- ":
Didn't mean anything personal
i definitely agree with everything u said and i thought about it before
u don't need to say it's not personal im totally okay with other opinions ♡ :)
edgar life wasn't easy especially when he was ill and his brother always mistreated him.
his aunt actually cared for him and she tried to help him but he refused..
and that's a pure stupidity tbh
but he is probably an infp so that's why he accepted his brother bs
and i don't like these characters at all
him still being nice to neil and telling rose to help him started everything and he truly should've known or at least read rose feelings cause edgar is a sympathetic person (like bro u r only good at being nice and sympathetic why didn't u use it with rose ughhh)
and i can't blame rose cause he is a monster who doesn't have any common sense but i still dislike him alot and its true that he is still angry
neil is trash too ofc but i don't see that he deserves all of this he hated poverty and his brother who took all the attention from him(sick behaviour ofc) but neil faced and still facing his choices
and edgar? nothing he choose to die even when he had the biggest 2 chances and found his significant other who could actually help him
but nooo let my abusev brother be happy..
edgar was a victim at the beginning but when god gives u chances and u don't use them
then u r literally dumb