Mai

Jennette has a father that gives her anything she wants, duke, and a brother that was by her side from childhood and takes care of her really good! and she had a lot of money to live with, unlike our MC that suffers discrimination.
has for her age, she does not act like 14 years old, she acts like 9 years old girl and even then she have no common sense of this age either.

Have you literally not seen her backstory? She knew that the dukes house wasn't her real family. She knew that the princess and king were her real family. Obviously it seems that the people in the duke house didn't care for Jenette as much as she felt that way. Regardless she just always wanted to be happy with Athy. She even helped Athy when she could've just left her to die by Claude.

so what if she knows? blood does not make you family, again common sense really. even people that have zero blood relation can still be your family if you see them that way. I doubt they didn't care, especially the bro - it shows many times that he did care for her, took care of her, and was there for her.
but nooo he is not family cause...blood. okay whatever.
the problem with her character is not the fact she wants family or not, the problem is that her character is BORING! never change, saying the same thing over and over and over and doing nothing about it will not make her a good character, she mostly very shallow and her backstory is the most shit filler I saw. she feel like a filler, think dumb like 9 years logic filler. her way her thinking work is not like 14 years at all, not only about family but about common stuff! she so dumb in the most unnormal way and give nothing to the plot other then :
whine, be a filler, give filler chapters, be a pain in the ass.
I ask you what did she give to the plot other than bring fillers chapters? or being the side kick friend that is just there and useless.
that is a big problem with her character.
when did she ever help Athy? Athy never really needed her help in the first place actually. and from what I remember, when she know Athy and her father have a fight and Athy suffering she was busy showing off how much fun she had with Athy father! yeas that what a good friend do, making her friend feel worse! so she is not even a good friend either ╮(￣▽￣)╭

Have you not seen how manipulative the Duke is?? He literally just uses her as a tool to get into the imperial family. He doesn't love her whatsoever. He couldn't care less about her actually. All he ever did was give her a life of luxury. If you believe that money buys happiness then you're extremely mistaken. Athy grew up with money and she isn't happy? So Jenette has to be? That's double standards. Jenette believed that she would grow up and marry Isekial. And guess what? He falls in love with Athy. Literally left her to dust. She didn't resent Athy at all. She could've schemed against Athy with the duke but no, she always stayed by her side and tried to make Athy happy. So she is Shallow for never resenting Athy? Never hating her despite craving to be in her place?? She genuinely just wanted to get loved truly by them. She was so happy to spend time with them together and she always thought of Athy as a sister who she genuinely cared about. You can't blame her for being repetitive when she was always in the dark. She's been nothing but manipulated left and right by the duke family and then got abandoned by the man she loved. Athy never told Jenette anything. She doesn't know. All she knows is that something bad is happening. Please inform me of what she can do. Ask her father? No, she knows he is using her. Asking Athy? No, she won't tell her anything. Digging around? No, she literally has no access to do that. She is in a position where she can't sneak around because it'll only get her in trouble. Why can't they both be happy?? Just because Jenette is immature? Tell me how well you'd handle everything in her position. Yeah, she probably shouldn't of bragged about meeting Claude but she was so happy because she believed to be finally reunited with her real family. She just wants to be happy with them. All the things Jenette has done were absolutely none of her fault. She had no idea she was doing those things. How could she? Athy always covered up the truth. Look at things from Jenettes perspective instead of staying hooked up on Athys. They both deserve happiness. Being immature doesn't mean she is any less deserving of a happy ending. She really just wants to be friends with Athy. Jenette isn't trying to steal Athys position whatsoever.

okay you just bs all over the place so I put in points:
1. say what you want, but Isekial did care for her like a sister! but noooo he isn't family, he is air! okay smartass XD and so what if he did in love with Athy? he never saw her in romantic light from the first place, but as a sister! has for money, dude are you for real?!! since when Athy EVER HAD money?!! are you dumb or what? did you forgot Athy was an abandoned princess?!! by the way, not everyone will end the way you want to in life! Isekial does not have to do what she wants or fall in love with her cause she wanted too, sometimes people will not see you the way you want them too, it's not the end of the world! stop acting like a brat!
2." She could've schemed against Athy with the duke but no" - no buddy, she is not smart enough for that or have enough personality.
3. " tried to make Athy happy" - how did she try? what action she ever did to do that other then be a filler character? I ask you for real, what ACTION did she ever did for her other then to try to steal her dad or only think about herself only? if she really cared she would have shut up in those moments Athy and her dad had a fight, but nope she does not care at all.
4. she is not "only" Shallow, she is empty from personality! and that is the problem! don't expect me to care for a character with zero personality. what her personality again: being naive, being dumb, being nice - that's it! that all her "personality" sorry this could not be called personality. go look for how to build a character's personality.
5. "hating her despite craving to be in her place" again she does not hate anyone cause she has zero personality. she gives NOTHING and yeas at least hating her shows her that she is human, but nope. even that she does not have. to not hate someone does not make you good, if just make you boring.
6. manipulated MY ASS! she is too dumb to even get anything around her, like I said she even worse than the logic of a 9 years old child. and even a child has more common sense and logic then her! don't act like she could never know anything or get when people use her, she can but she too dumb and naive in such a dumb way for that. and by that she hurting Athy and everyone!
and by the way, Athy does not have to tell her State secrets, in particular, not about her father's situation which is supposed to remain secret!!! it's fucking dumb to even expect Athy to do this shit just to stay "friend" with this bitch that does not give a damn about her at all. Athy actually told everything almost apart from her father situation so don't like Athy did something wrong! who is she to demand to know EVERYTHING about the kingdom?!!! a real friend will trust her and not force her to talk about things she can't talk about! but again she isn't a real friend to Athy anyway sooo.. ╮(￣▽￣)╭
7. what she can do: first of all don't trust strangers that give candy - the guy at their house. yeas it's not that hard and don't talk to creepy people. she can look for a job, learn new skills or things she can work, learn what her hobbies is, buy a business when she has enough money, MOVE OUT, THERE ARE SO MANY THINGS SHE CAN DO YET SHE JUST SIT AND DO NOTHING! letting the Duke do all the work and follow all his orders like a dumb doll she is.
8. probably shouldn't of bragged about meeting Claude - geez you think? and don't try to make excuses for her!! it annoying! I know you try your best to justify her and her useless existence in this story, but it does not work here. again cause she do more harm and no god for anyone.
8. "She just wants to be happy with them," I ask you again WHAT DOES SHE DO TO BE HAPPY? other then to sit all day and trust creepy people that if she had any logic, would know they are bad from a first glance. even a doll have more personality than her, again why should I care if she happy or not?? she only follows what people order her to do, and no most 14 years old do not do that!

Did you receive my response?? For me I didn't send it but hopefully you got it cause I spent like an hour on it and I refuse to retype that.

no 0-0 your response is empty so I guess you didn't have anything to say

Fuck that. I literally typed up like for a whole hour and that shit didn't send. LMAOO I'm so mad.

god damn, this whole argument was fucking entertaining. I'm on maychan's side, but I applaud you for the effort mrs.mai! I don't want to get myself into trouble so imma leave, bye y'all! (〜￣△￣)〜

I'm gonna retype it. Give me like 3 more hours. Lmfaooo

lolol I’m on your (Mai) side but honestly I don’t think you can change their mind. Once their mind are made up on hating Jeanette, they will keep on hating and coming up with every excuse they have to keep on hating. You’ll just be spending your time talking to a freaking wall. Good luck.

Ahh thank you! I still wanna try though. I believe my next argument will be super good. I just gotta get my remotiveation to type it. Last time I spent an hour on it then it got deleted so I'm not too thrilled about it.