I keep coming back to to this manga.. And it never fails to make my heart ache. I'm very very very glad that she end up with Arata. I think I'll come back here again someday (づ￣ ³￣)づ
I read this over 10 years ago and I always get back to it especially when I read something where the guy I'm rooting for doesn't get the girl. This manga was the first where "the good guy" and "first love" and all that crap, didn't get the girl and the guy I was rooting for and thought he didn't stand a chance eventually got the girl! This will always have a special place in my heart
i read this manga like back in 2013 that the story is so beautiful and the art is so goog also, glad that i stumble here again, i miss hikaru and arata moments though i'm feeling sad for arata, its kind of true that not all of our firstloves do have a happy end
I still remember I used to rent this manga during middle school with my friends, such a great memory xD now I'm already 21 yet stumbling upon this made me felt nostalgic about Ikeyamada Go, she is definitely my first shoujo mangaka! I enjoyed her other series too
That’s your opinion I understand. But damn if the voting for the other brother won i would’ve been so pissed. Arata has given so much love to hikaru and to give up the happiness for hikaru is a lot to think about. And not to mention his childhood and how his brother got everything he could never gotten and how messed it made him. I’m very damn glad she got with arata.
That’s your opinion I understand. But damn if the voting for the other brother won i would’ve been so pissed. Arata has given so much love to hikaru and to give up the happiness for hikaru is a lot to think... JALLY
Yeah but for me it just pisses me off because they had her have all these sweet scenes with the sweet male lead (forgot their names, it's been awhile) and all because of one mistake (which could have been easily resolved) she suddenly switched lanes and entered "bad boy" male lead's lane and ended up with him like wtf?? In the end it just ended up like the stereotypical female lead ends up with arrogant bad boy male lead... it was also very sudden because Arata (was that his name?) hardly even showed up for a few chaps...
correct me if I got some things wrong, I read this like 4-5 years ago and just commented what I originally thought back then. I don't feel like rereading. Also, with the amount of dislikes on my comment I can tell people on this site really don't appreciate one's opinion..
Yeah but for me it just pisses me off because they had her have all these sweet scenes with the sweet male lead (forgot their names, it's been awhile) and all because of one mistake (which could have been easil... jaak-pon!
There was this voting thing that even I had to reread to understand. Voting between arata and whatever the other brother name was. That’s why it was mostly about them two until the end of the chapter where the voting ended with arata surprisingly winning even the author didn’t except that. And that’s how she ended up with arata. But I get what you mean if it wasn’t for the voting stuff.
There was this voting thing that even I had to reread to understand. Voting between arata and whatever the other brother name was. That’s why it was mostly about them two until the end of the chapter where th... JALLY
She really did a voting? People fucking bs picking typical dudes
Instead of ending up with arata she would’ve ended up with what you would’ve wanted. And the author wanted that too instead of arata but looking at how arata half brother only thought about his feelings I’m glad that arata got picked. People had a change of opinion when the arata half brother met up with his childhood friend.
When I read this a long time ago, even I thought it was stupid of the reasoning of their breakup. All because of that girl and her "injuries" and so he feels bad towards her. It's kind of a stupid move of him to break up with her just because of that girl over something like that. BUT you know, if the majority of the audience is happy then I guess it is what it is. I didn't mind that she ended up with the other brother later, only felt that the issue could've been solved easily and he didn't have to give in to that girl easily cause his feelings of guilt gave in and weak.
This manga... I read this so long ago like 10years+ ago... I was so young and the story really stuck to me. I'm so glad i would remember it from time to time and be able to read it again~
I don't like shojo mangas but I remember that I stumbled upon this a long time ago and it's one of the only stories that, now as a 25 year old who doesn't have a single romantic bone in her, I still go back to read from time to time. It has a way of warming one's heart and it depicts characters' growth and how they grow up into adults.
Topics
Ahhh I miss the feelings that only old shoujo manga gave me!
Wait.. did she really s** with that brown eyed twin? Before the break up????
Yes （￣へ￣）
Okay.. i dont like it(●￣(ｴ)￣●)
I keep coming back to to this manga.. And it never fails to make my heart ache. I'm very very very glad that she end up with Arata. I think I'll come back here again someday (づ￣ ³￣)づ
I read this over 10 years ago and I always get back to it especially when I read something where the guy I'm rooting for doesn't get the girl. This manga was the first where "the good guy" and "first love" and all that crap, didn't get the girl and the guy I was rooting for and thought he didn't stand a chance eventually got the girl!
This will always have a special place in my heart
i had exactly the same experience. i love this so much i think i cried of happiness when i first read the ending ♡ ⊹ what a good author
i read this manga like back in 2013 that the story is so beautiful and the art is so goog also, glad that i stumble here again, i miss hikaru and arata moments though i'm feeling sad for arata, its kind of true that not all of our firstloves do have a happy end
I still remember I used to rent this manga during middle school with my friends, such a great memory xD now I'm already 21 yet stumbling upon this made me felt nostalgic about Ikeyamada Go, she is definitely my first shoujo mangaka! I enjoyed her other series too
Team Arata!
Aww I wish there was an extra where we could see Arata and Hikaru's baby and their married days~
She ended up with the wrong guy.. smh
That’s your opinion I understand. But damn if the voting for the other brother won i would’ve been so pissed. Arata has given so much love to hikaru and to give up the happiness for hikaru is a lot to think about. And not to mention his childhood and how his brother got everything he could never gotten and how messed it made him. I’m very damn glad she got with arata.
Yeah but for me it just pisses me off because they had her have all these sweet scenes with the sweet male lead (forgot their names, it's been awhile) and all because of one mistake (which could have been easily resolved) she suddenly switched lanes and entered "bad boy" male lead's lane and ended up with him like wtf??
In the end it just ended up like the stereotypical female lead ends up with arrogant bad boy male lead... it was also very sudden because Arata (was that his name?) hardly even showed up for a few chaps...
correct me if I got some things wrong, I read this like 4-5 years ago and just commented what I originally thought back then. I don't feel like rereading. Also, with the amount of dislikes on my comment I can tell people on this site really don't appreciate one's opinion..
There was this voting thing that even I had to reread to understand. Voting between arata and whatever the other brother name was. That’s why it was mostly about them two until the end of the chapter where the voting ended with arata surprisingly winning even the author didn’t except that. And that’s how she ended up with arata. But I get what you mean if it wasn’t for the voting stuff.
She really did a voting? People fucking bs picking typical dudes
but to each their own ig..
Instead of ending up with arata she would’ve ended up with what you would’ve wanted. And the author wanted that too instead of arata but looking at how arata half brother only thought about his feelings I’m glad that arata got picked. People had a change of opinion when the arata half brother met up with his childhood friend.
When I read this a long time ago, even I thought it was stupid of the reasoning of their breakup. All because of that girl and her "injuries" and so he feels bad towards her. It's kind of a stupid move of him to break up with her just because of that girl over something like that. BUT you know, if the majority of the audience is happy then I guess it is what it is. I didn't mind that she ended up with the other brother later, only felt that the issue could've been solved easily and he didn't have to give in to that girl easily cause his feelings of guilt gave in and weak.
This manga... I read this so long ago like 10years+ ago... I was so young and the story really stuck to me. I'm so glad i would remember it from time to time and be able to read it again~
I don't like shojo mangas but I remember that I stumbled upon this a long time ago and it's one of the only stories that, now as a 25 year old who doesn't have a single romantic bone in her, I still go back to read from time to time. It has a way of warming one's heart and it depicts characters' growth and how they grow up into adults.
Man.. I hate that girl.. Poor arata.. You should be showered with lots of love