Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.

criminally underrated BL

These are some of my favorite reads that are unfortunately underrated. It's a crime that these works get less than 9 ratings but rapey BLs with little substance get all the praises and stars. If you haven't read these, please give them a chance!

Ps. Mind the trigger warning
All(90) / manga(90)

Kimiiro Eden

 8.7(374 voted)
Complete
Author(s): Aomoto Sari
Genre(s): Yaoi / Drama / Romance / Slice Of Life

4.5/5

[18+, romance, slice of life, found family]

TW: age gap, internal homophobia

+ strangers to lovers
+ slowburn
+ family feels
+ LGBT parents
+ tender consensual sex

I liked the natural progression of the MCs' relationship. It's neither rushed nor dragged on, and I think it complements the development of both characters well.

27 10,2021

Koi no Hanashi ga Shitai

 7.3(492 voted)
Complete
Author(s): YAMASHITA Tomoko
Genre(s): Shounen Ai

4.5/5

[PG, anthology, slice of life]

+ great writing and dialogues
+ simple, mundane, but gold

Yamashita Tomoko has the most beautiful and underrated works istg. I love all the stories in this one, they feel like something you can witness in every day life. Nothing complicated or convoluted, but the way the author presented them is what made them special.

28 10,2021

Orokamono no Ai no Uta

 8.7(441 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): Jyanome
Genre(s): Romance / Slice Of Life / Yaoi

4.5/5 so far

[18+, slice of life]

TW: child neglect

Because of a street fortune teller's (100% fake) premonition, MC is hellbent on finding his "destined person" despite already having one beside him. This manga isn't perfect by any means and i wish the plot was handled better, but i still really like it. The atmosphere of this story is good, the art is pretty, and the MC is somehow likeable even with all his weirdness.

11 11,2021

GATAPISHI

 8.6(177 voted)
Complete
Author(s): Arai niboshiko
Genre(s): Yaoi / Romance

[18+, romance, slice of life]

+ pretty art
+ endearing

Weird, but in a good way. The setting, the characters, the art, they made me feel nostalgic, and the whole manga has a good coming-of-age vibe. Both of the MCs (mostly tomoyuki) are dramatic, but it's a degree that kinda makes sense for 16 year olds. They live and love so recklessly and endearingly. I wish the characters were fleshed out better tho, it would be really good to see them explored both as individuals and a couple.

12 11,2021

Psychedelia

 8.9(170 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): Takahashi Hidebu
Genre(s): Drama / Supernatural / Yaoi

[18+, supernatural]

TW: blood

An interesting plot with beautiful art. I love the surreality conveyed by this manga, and i really wish it was longer / better explored. I'd like to know more about the characters! It would've benefit from another volume or denser chapters, but well, still a good read.

13 11,2021

Naka-san no Nagare

 8.6(350 voted)
Complete
Author(s): Basso
Genre(s): Slice Of Life / Yaoi

☆ 4.5/5

[PG, slice of life]

TW: mention of pedophilia, age gap (14 years)

+ established relationship
+ GREAT writing

You just can't expect less than stellar works from Basso. She writes the most mundane things--like a ramen shop owner who suffers from bad blood circulation or an art supplies employee who worries about hair dyes--so well that i didn't feel an ounce of boredom reading this. This is a masterful work that's so criminally underrated.

20 11,2021

Kocchi Muite Waratte

 8.8(936 voted)
Complete
Author(s): Ichikawa Kei
Genre(s): Yaoi / Romance / Comedy / Slice Of Life

4/5

[18+, slice of life, rom-com]

TW: dubcon because of alcohol

+ co-workers
+ manly couple
+ good dialogues and writing

I love the casualness of this manga. Everything flows naturally in a laid back manner and the two MCs' personality complement each other well. No idea why i didn't include this manga in this list before, but it's a pretty good read (go check out the djs too!).

20 12,2021

Sukebe no Seishun

 8.9(632 voted)
Complete
Author(s): HATA Takashi
Genre(s): School Life / Yaoi

4.5/5

[18+, rom-com, school life]

+ this couple is on crack
+ surprisingly sweet and thoughtful
+ consent and communication

I like it! Sure it has some questionable stuffs but at the end of the day it's a pretty uplifting highschool romance. I didn't expect the relationship to be so tender and caring. I also Love how laid back everyone is about two men dating, so refreshing to see.

22 12,2021

Sex Sales Driver

 8.9(142 voted)
Complete
Author(s): Sabamiso
Genre(s): Yaoi / Comedy / Smut

4.5/5

[18+, rom-com, slice of life]

What's up with the title?? Seriously, it's very misleading and has nothing to do with the plot. I almost dismissed it as one those unrealistic smut mangas, but I'm glad i gave it a chance because it was far from that. The MC is endearing (and Relatable), the story is wholesome, the relationship is healthy, the characters' dynamic is great, and more importantly: Haze is smoking HOT. Definitely worth a reread.

22 12,2021

Garakuta no Ai wo Hitobannjuu

 8.5(499 voted)
Complete
Author(s): Sagano
Genre(s): Yaoi / Comedy / Romance / Smut

4/5

[18+, rom-com]

TW: boss-subordinate, daddy kink, age play

The dynamic of this couple was truly the star of the manga. There are a lot of iffy tropes (eg power imbalance, sexual harrassment, age roleplay, etc) that would have turned me away if not because of how self-aware and into it both of the MCs were. They both fully consented and had so much fun with each other that i couldn't help but support their relationship.

28 12,2021

What can a LIST do?

You may feel your favorite manga should be gathered together into distinct categories for your own reference and, now, you can do this with a LIST. After you've created your list or lists, you can proudly recommend them to other manga fans to showcase and share your taste in manga.

Messages

Blubeagle May 20, 2023 11:33 pm

Great list. My all-time favorite romance is the one between the two in Yasashii Anata, so I'm delighted to find it here!

tofu July 23, 2023 4:53 am

Same! Been waiting for another one like it but there's nothing so far

Blubeagle July 23, 2023 11:35 am
Same! Been waiting for another one like it but there's nothing so far tofu

Truth! :)

YIKES March 7, 2022 5:23 pm

GOD TIER LIST MAN

tofu March 7, 2022 5:28 pm

Thanks!! Glad you like it