for Ideum to be the bridge so that these brothers makeup and be more closer to each another. idk if everyone will agree but both brothers suffered growing up, obv in different levels and mostly bc of their parents' fault. i think this could be a healing journey too, w Ideum as the catalyst who forces the brothers to face their faults and insecurities towards each other. I reallly want Jaeyi to have a big bro who supports him and Jiseong to be genuinely happy for his lil bro.
I can relate to that, i loved that he takes Jaeyi's side but it could backfire since lil bro is extra defensive and still figuring out his real feelings for Ideum. I don't want to wish it but Ideum maybe forced to confront his own life if something health-related happens to him. W all the stress that these brothers gives to him, he may rethink what he's doing is not serving him and will refocus to self-healing and self-love but this is BL so what do i know lol (⌒▽⌒)
The parents are definitely to blame for creating this dynamic. But I do think Jiseong started enjoying taking away things from Jaeyi because he resents the fact that he is healthy and gets to be outside. He sees it as a fair trade, it’s similar to how he thinks that his life is chill now because he is being rewarded for being sick.
Sooo true, Jiseong def took for granted the way Jaeyi kept silent w his bullying bc he knows at the end of the day, the sickest kid would always win the hearts of their parents. i think this arc will teach Jaeyi to confront his brother and his feelings if he wants to keep Ideum. i don't think Ideum will ever choose big bro but if brothers fight gets too toxic, its not healthy for them to be together imho
i refuse to believe yall gonna kill him just to prove a point. i understand the suffering but damn these whiny townspeople can't move away and start somewhere else?? you don't like the rules, gtfo. killing your source of safety aint sht. ( ̄へ ̄)
Why would Guwon murder them if they leave? Has it happened or has he said it before?
Guwon listens to Jinwoo tho. Several chapters ago, Jinwoo told Guwon he was wrong and Guwon immediately accepted it and changed his mind. Couldn't have Jinwoo continued teaching and changing Guwon for the better instead of doing whatever this is they're doing?
He kills disobedient people and outsiders. Like, he has no reasons to kill people's family members but he does anyway because they are not useful. Maybe he would not kill them but why risk it just so their family member's murderer stays happy?
And yes it would have been great if they did (Guwoon is adorable and very open to change) but if someone killed your family, I doubt you'd be willing to give them a second chance, especially if they did so in a way that's very unpredictable. They have no reasons to trust he's actually open to change. They don't know him like we do.
I love Guwon because he's adorable but terrifying. More than any character I've seen in a yaoi. You cannot reason with him UNLESS you're Jinwoo, which makes their relationship extra cute and sad, but also means he'd probably crush your loved ones' skulls and maybe yours too if he ever met you lol.
But the people Guwon killed either broke his rules or disobeyed him, as for the outside, either they were against him or he didn't find them useful. But none of those were people who got killed because they left town tho. Maybe I missed it but I don't recall there being a rule or Guwon threatening people that will leave the town.
"They don't know him like we do."
- Jinwoo does. Well not as much as us, the nigh-omniscient readers, but Jinwoo has seen Guwon was capable of change back in Chapter 21 (I think) where he made Guwon give up the medicine. Guwon never went back with his decision after that. That was proof he can change and Jinwoo was the one who witnessed it, and who can facilitate it. So yes, Jinwoo does.
No ofc but my point is they have no reason to think he won't! I know I wouldn't risk it... but, you're right : Guwon does provide them with a nice warm place, but it's as much their town (they're the ones making it run!) as it's his. So I think it's fair they want to keep it.
Yes but he killed Jinwoo's dad, and revealed that to him in the most cruel way. I think it's fair Jinwoo is feeling too disgusted with himself to think rationnally about the man who murdered his dad.
And imo even taking away all of this : getting revenge on their family's killer is a perfectly valid reason to do what they're doing right now, it's a way better reason than Guwon's reasons are to kill.
... it's fine if you disagree, I just like discussing different ways to read this awesome manga :3
"(they're the ones making it run!) as it's his."
- Actually no. That nice doctor that got killed said it himself that the Hounds is what's basically keeping the town together as they're the ones providing the town with constant supplies from the outside. That's why medicines are prioritized to the Hounds.
"So I think it's fair they want to keep it."
- I really wonder how tho without Guwon and the Hound's strength, skills, and experience. I guess we'll see soon.
"Yes but he killed Jinwoo's dad, and revealed that to him in the most cruel way."
- We're actually not still sure about that. Guwon still denies he did, and maybe I forgot, but Guwon doesn't lie. He's brutally honest if anything. Plus there's also Teach's amnesia about the event.
"getting revenge on their family's killer is a perfectly valid reason to do what they're doing right now"
- I still think it's way too stupid and reckless, and we'll eventually bite them in the ass sooner or later. They seem to have forgotten that the word is in an apocalypse, it's kill or be killed, ut I guess we'll just have to wait and see in the next chapters, but for me that's the overall vibe it's giving.
No that was in response to your previous statements, specifically:
"(they're the ones making it run!) as it's his. So I think it's fair they want to keep it."
So no they don't, and no it's not fair for them to keep it. Anyway,
As for Guwon killing his dad, it seems my previous reply got cut off. This was what's in there:
"The reveal is in Ch 24. Idk why I didn't see that at first, but yeah rereading it again, Guwon did kill his dad. It was just confused at first since he always says he didn't lie. But it seems his dad was killed for stealing resources from him. Doesn't really justify his killing but at least it does reveal Guwon didn't kill him randomly.
Even then, I still think their plan was stupid and reckless, and to some extent, selfish."
I won't argue again I think your read is fine, mine is just different. It absolutely is reckless though!! But I could never find them whiny for taking action agaisnt their family's murderer. Or be mad at them. I think they'd rather die at this point than keep living under him... kind of like when people revolt agaisnt a ruler.
No, this isn't a matter of either of our opinions. You asserted that, to quote you:
""(they're the ones making it run!) as it's his."
I'm merely showing you that the explicitly stated canon objectively deems that assertion to be at most false, and at least greatly exaggerated.
"I think they'd rather die at this point than keep living under him..."
- Then that just makes this whole rebellion nearly pointless and collaterally ruinous, when they could've just left the town and had themselves killed if that was their core sentiment in the first place.
Just gonna add : you're not arguing in good faith, which is why I'm no longer interested in having this discussion anymore. I have my reasons for disagreeing but there's no point in me sharing it because you've already made your mind that my reading is wrong and, I assume, stupid, simply because I think Guwon had it coming, even if I also adore him.
What an incredibly disappointing reply. I thought you'd be different, but turns out you're just another intellectually dishonest person.
That's not what arguing in bad faith means. I quoted the official translations, addressed your actual claims, and even acknowledged my own misunderstanding. You, meanwhile, have repeatedly misrepresented my position and even called me weird for an argument I never made.
You're accusing me of bad faith while ignoring my actual arguments and attacking positions I've never held. The irony is remarkable.
When your youngest kid had a valid crashout on his bday bc you cannot fvcking do a proper time management, you should have re-evaluated your parenting skills and notice your uneven treatment between your two kids. I'm the oldest from 6 siblings, the parent scenes triggered me bc i was heavily parentified to the point that i never expected to get gifts bc everything else is for my 5 siblings instead. This weakass parents only got 2 kids and still traumatized them wtf ヽ(`Д´)ノ (╯°Д °)╯╧╧
they're only "fuck buddies" rn but boyyy do i loved how they speak to each other, pretty upfront and less BS than other reads i know w similar trope... Also! that VC scene, finally got used properly for SOP lol
my guess is the Kuya of Jaeyi was the first love of Ideum, and he will be the catalyst to either level up or break their relationship ٩(๑❛ᴗ❛๑)۶







They're denser than the cake i just had