I hope nobody goes out of there way to hate on the artist. It's disappointing but since season 1 they have been open about how overworked they were and they continued season 2 because readers love her art style of CA. She did it for us too. I would definitely recommend reading the novel as well because it's actually really good.
Lmaoo y'all mentioning Zhenya but let me tell you this codename Anastasia novel actually express Taekjoo trauma, the effects of what he went through very well. Taekjoo never really forgave Zhenya and Zhenya karma is his forever fear of Taekjoo leaving him. He regret his actions and what he did to Takejoo and what's more is he doesn't restrict Takejoo. Do I think flashlight will give that same treatment in expressing regret from Aaron...hmmm idk hard to say but for y'all sake I'm praying that she will.
Okay so everyone can have their own interpretation but then again there is no consistency in it.
He never said he wouldn't go back to Tj. The reason he even went with Jo to visit Jo's aunt was because he believes that TJ didn't need him anymore because he made his own decisions to get involved in the organization conflict for TJ but TJ didn't want him to get involved and endangered him so he ghosted Ian and in hope that Ian will get his "freedom" because he thought Ian feeling was stemming from guilt. He doesn't even think of Jo while being with TJ. The bathroom his thoughts is basically just "damn I'm a terrible person for dragging Jo knowing damn well I still love TJ." The stars...there is no profound deep thoughts of Jo. The most thought he had is probably " Oh damn didn't the dude name Jo told me about this. Let me tell TJ." No one is even excusing of him of his flaws it's the fact y'all are either withholding or forgot a lot of little details of what he said. He was questioning why TJ has been MIA and he couldn't get a hold of TJ. When he kill those 4 men he walk out saying something along the line "oh taejoon don't need me anymore.
I'll genuinely never understand you people. Everytime you said your side of your interpretation on Ian and it's just you implying slutshaming in a form of "people are allowed to have different interpretation" good grief, maybe people are right no need for any critical thinking on the story because your ass will always find a way to reduce Tjian relationship and fault one of them heavily.
Hundred and thousands of stories from manga manhwa, you could literally apply the same logic and say that the love interest, the female lead, the mc doesn't deserve those love from the Ml but you're only applying that to Ian like he forced TJ to have those feeling. No one to talk about it if it doesn't justify their hatred for a character. Does the concept of people forming a bond even over something little like small talk is impossible? Honestly what did I expect from mangago user who probably hasn't even had a first kiss while watching men cum in each other ass. Shit the hypocrisy is insane. Being a TJ Stan myself how do you hate on Ian for having complicated feeling when the story itself is label as a love triangle and TJ and him didn't exclusively slept with only each other. So basically everything that you're saying about yw is still implying slutshaming mindset toward him and reducing him to that in justice for TJ. And I say this as a TJ lover also? TJ has always been a well written character and will always be compelling just as Ian is emotionally written. Had he been a top people wouldn't be this hypocritical









Oh man.. talk about predictable. Last update,I literally saw someone commented how the crazy fan gonna hurt suae and here come Eunhyuk the legendary yearner to save the day.
I mean, if you think about this entire story can be predicted if you read The Rose of Versailles
It's just predictable. The endgame is predictable, how the author gonna "redeem" Eunhyuk is predictable. You can read The Rose of Versailles or whatever and at the end of the day the story is still not deep or well written. Love it or whatever. Do whatever you want.¯_(ツ)_/¯
Uhhh yeah, I’m not really disagreeing with you.
Hmm, well maybe on the story not being well written. That’s to be seen. We can agree to disagree on that.
Objectively speaking, not really but hey beauty is in the eyes of its beholder. So sure agree to disagree.
There is no such thing as objectivity when it comes to fiction. It cannot be measured through a scientific lense. Manwha/books, etc require a human mind to read and interpret it, so literary value is always tied to the person themselves and is thus subjective.
Okay?? There is such a thing as objective criticism. Literary value being subjective doesn't mean we can't call a spade a spade. Does your literature professor not grade your work based on objective criteria? My evaluation of the story itself can be both subjective and objective cause the two can coexist. If literary analysis necessarily only involves subjective interpretation, then why would my evaluation become invalid. We can still evaluate characterization, narrative consistency, pacing, and how smoothly or effectively a story develops its own premise. I can recognize clichés, underdeveloped plot points, and underused narrative potential, then argue that they weaken the overall writing. Like I said beauty is in the eyes of it beholder but let not dismissed it to simply being subjective
A professor grading an essay based on a rubric isn't proving objective truth. They are evaluating your adherence to assignment criteria. What you consider 'underdeveloped' or 'weak' is still an opinion, not an objective fact. Claiming that your personal preference is an objective literary take doesn't make your opinion indisputable. If fiction could be objectively measured, every scholar would have the exact same interpretation and rating for every story. But that’s not the case. For example, two literature students can analyze the exact same work, reach completely opposite conclusions, and both be valid as long as their arguments are supported by the text. That is why literary analysis is inherently subjective, no matter how many analytical criteria you use. Professors don’t care for what your take is, rather they care how well you prove it using evidence from the text and logical reasoning.
If art could be objectively measured, the entire field of literary criticism wouldn't exist because there would be nothing left to debate.
Why do I always have to spoon feed people.
"Objectively speaking, not really but hey beauty is in the eyes of its beholder. So sure agree to disagree." I'm giving you validation that it can be well written to others.
Like, you're admitting that literary evaluation isn't an objective truth because people apply their own judgments and perspectives, so why is my evaluation invalid just because I call the writing objectively bad? If professors can evaluate the same work differently using their own criteria and perspectives, why does that mean objective criticism doesn't exist? You're acting like I claimed my opinion was indisputable when my point is that subjective judgment and objective analysis can exist and co exist because you claimed that their no such thing as objectivity.
This is finna go in circles. It's simple, really. I can say the simple truth that you're dismissing the existence of objectivity because you find the story well written and don't like that I called it poorly written, or I can choose to dance around to understand your perspective while you don't do the same to mine.
You're allowed to see it as well written. You don't have to defend it or prove to me that I'm wrong. I'm willing to understand your perspective on why you think it's well written hence the expression of beauty in the eyes of the beholder.Just as I can see a simple reason why you're dismissing objectivity, I can also see the flaws in the story. Hopefully I don't have to repeat myself
You cannot claim a story is 'objectively bad' and then get upset when people point out that is a literal contradiction in terms. You’re conflating objective analysis with objective quality. Objective analysis absolutely exists. It means looking at the raw facts of the text without bias, such as identifying that an author uses a passive voice, or that a plot point was resolved in one sentence… However, objective quality does not exist. The exact moment you label those facts as 'bad,' 'flawed,' or 'underdeveloped,' you are applying a subjective value judgment based on your personal expectations of what storytelling should be. You are trying to have it both ways. You claim you aren't saying your opinion is indisputable, but by definition, if something is 'objectively bad,' it IS indisputable. For example, If a bridge is objectively, structurally, unstable, it will collapse. That is an undeniable fact regardless of anyone's perspective. But a story cannot collapse physical. It can only fail to meet your personal standards or expectations. No one is pressed that you dislike the story. You are entirely allowed to think it's poorly written. But to say that your personal dislike is objective is factually incorrect.
Since you are so steadfast in your position, I highly encourage you to actually look into literary theory. You can look up the foundational rules of literary analysis at any academic institution or peer-reviewed journal. You will find that the entire academic consensus explicitly categorizes literary criticism as an evidence-based subjective discipline, not objective. You are quite literally arguing against the very definition of the field…
"For example, If a bridge is objectively, structurally, unstable, it will collapse" well that's a bridge not a story LMAOO.
Me make it simple, okay? Objectivity when it comes to literary criticism still stems from perspective. So objectivity does exist, and me saying that the story is objectively poorly written doesn't automatically mean I'm claiming it to be indisputable , especially when I've explicitly acknowledged that people can see it differently.
And that's the whole point, because I don't care to argue with you about whether the story is wellwritten or not. As I've already said, other people can see it as well-written, and that's fine.
For someone who confidently arguing about "objectivity" you sure do like to misinterpret and missed conversational cues, huh?
Saying 'objectivity stems from perspective' is, again, a contradiction. Perspective is, by definition, subjective. You cannot invent your own definitions of words just to avoid being wrong. I begin to wonder if you know what objectivity means, so I did you the favor of searching it for you. According to the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, objectivity requires dealing with ‘facts without letting one's feelings interfere with them’ and being ‘outside of the mind and independent of it.’ By definition, if a concept relies on human perspective, interpretation, and can be disputed by different people, it lacks objectivity. Furthermore, you missed the point of the bridge metaphor entirely... How, I don’t know. The reason a bridge is objective is because its structural stability exists outside of human opinion. A story only exists through the interpretation of the reader. If you say a story is 'objectively poorly written' but then say 'that doesn't mean it's indisputable and others can see it differently,’ you don't know what the word objective means. If a claim can be disputed by different valid perspectives, it is a subjective claim, period. You can try to insult my conversational skills all you want, but that will not reconstruct the English dictionary or literary theory.