The punishment the female characters have recieved so far has exceeded exponentially what the male characters have faced. So far we have seen three female chracters get raped, and it's just so distasteful. I don't want to see our main chracter win.
...Alrighty, you tell us then, which character in the story that's male and a main antagonist you would want a gruesome punishment for, and still be logical to the world setting?
Our MC definitely isn't winning in a true sense. He's still going to die young. He's a villain even when he's the protagonist, and gets his karma due.
Just because it sucks women are always gets the short end of the stick in literature, doesn't necessarily mean it's progressing unfairly in a story setting. That's just happenstance.
...Alrighty, you tell us then, which character in the story that's male and a main antagonist you would want a gruesome punishment for, and still be logical to the world setting?Our MC definitely isn't winning ... Tsukishiro
Correct me if I'm wrong but I've read the novel and SPOILER: the sisters are raped and forcibly placed in some beast's cage for babymaking. The crown prince who hurt mc's daughter equally literally finds himself a bride (his fucking cousin) and gets a happy ending. No male in this story really suffered while the female antagonists get a hell lot of bullshit. It's pretty evident that the author made it this way intentionally and it's not just happenstance. Even right now in the story you can see the unfairly placed consequences.
...Alrighty, you tell us then, which character in the story that's male and a main antagonist you would want a gruesome punishment for, and still be logical to the world setting?Our MC definitely isn't winning ... Tsukishiro
It's unfair and I don't see why you would say otherwise. It's a fictional story, you can do whatever you want to the characters no matter the gender as long as you WANT to. Author has a problem with women, you can literally tell. How are you going to cheat and end up happy while the other woman AND her sister become sex slaves for decisions you made?
...Alrighty, you tell us then, which character in the story that's male and a main antagonist you would want a gruesome punishment for, and still be logical to the world setting?Our MC definitely isn't winning ... Tsukishiro
Idk, maybe the crown prince, her stepbrother, or any of the other male characters who abandoned Juliette to die. The two girls literally carry only a fraction of the responsibility, and even less than the actual noblemen with the power to change her status from Priestess to Sacrifice. Also, Nasha and Marie aren't shown to be smart like the MC; they weren't the ones who orchestrated Juliette's downfall because they couldn't. Nasha and Marie, who were commoners, had the least amount of power and responsibility for what happened to Juliette, yet they are the ones going through the most brutal revenge plot, while the guys get a bit humiliated and then go back to their normal lives.
I'm fine with the main character being a monstrous villain; I'm not fine with the disproportionate amount of violence depicted towards women. And our MC does win if everything goes to his plan, and he faces no consequences for his actions. Also because him dying young (that is if he actually does) has nothing to do with his actions; I do not count it as consequences.
Correct me if I'm wrong but I've read the novel and SPOILER: the sisters are raped and forcibly placed in some beast's cage for babymaking. The crown prince who hurt mc's daughter equally literally finds himsel... deedee
I feel like my intentions are clearly being misread and misunderstood. So I'll reiterate in a different way. I'm not in anyway saying there isn't a disproportionate amount of violence towards women in fiction, but often times people complain about it in a way that implies something other than it just being a natural direction of the story's progression or setting. "Did it have to happen that way?", instead of "did it happen that way for a purpose".
For example, in the situation you brought up, Anri purposely made Jorga witness that depravity. Because often times women and children are victims of crime and such situations evoke sympathy or empathy. A knight like Jorga should have been disturbed by it, but it was used as a means to test Jorga's devotion to Anri. Ultimately his karma is that Jorga who witnessed women caged with beasts reincarnates as one himself.
I feel like my intentions are clearly being misread and misunderstood. So I'll reiterate in a different way. I'm not in anyway saying there isn't a disproportionate amount of violence towards women in fiction, ... Tsukishiro
And that's a common literary trope that is continuously criticised, where violence towards women is used to develop a male character's story. Rape is used as a shocking quirk in the story to demonstrate the depravity of the world and of the characters, with little regard for how it impacts the victims' lives.
I am engaging with why the author made these choices and what their purpose is. Context matters, but it does not excuse it. There is a reason why, when we see graphic depictions of violence, it's almost always the female characters, and that does not reflect well on the author. The author clearly demonstrates a strong distaste for women, and if not, a disregard for their humanity. As a revenge plot, we are supposed to feel catharsis when our main character does bad things to the antagonists; therefore, we are supposed to get some type of satisfaction in seeing these women suffer.
However, I cannot, because not only does the revenge far exceed the offences these women committed, but it's also not distributed equally to all guilty parties. None of the men responsible for hurting the main character and his family have really been punished, at least not as gratuitously, and they still remain empathetic characters.
Idk, maybe the crown prince, her stepbrother, or any of the other male characters who abandoned Juliette to die. The two girls literally carry only a fraction of the responsibility, and even less than the actua... Rora
The crown prince, sure. But how, in what way, and will that change the vibe of the story into another slop action revenge porn. Like, it's easy to throw the suggestion out there, but it would effectively change the story into something else entirely. If you're grossed out by the events, that's justified, but anything else is just demanding a sense of justice while ignoring the actual plot. Which is why I asked for a real alternative.
As unfair as it seems, Anri's primary goal was to make Juliette untouchable and to sit at the pinnacle of the kingdom so that the empire would end when she does. He made the goal clear from the beginning, and destroying the prince wouldn't do that. A little humiliated is a bit of an understatement. He knows his kingdom is at the mercy of Juliette and it could end tomorrow.
The story is based on a game world setting. Originally, Nasha is the one that wanted Juliette to be the sacrificed maiden. She wanted Juliette to die in her stead when she chose the Prince's route. Regardless who she chooses, someone gets the short end of the stick (usually Marie or Juliette). Nasha willfully doesn't give a shit about her family. Marie if you forgot, also wanted Juliette and Anri dead, when she tried to hire the thug.
And that's a common literary trope that is continuously criticised, where violence towards women is used to develop a male character's story. Rape is used as a shocking quirk in the story to demonstrate the dep... Rora
I understand the sentiments of finding criticism in overused tropes. But let me ask then, if you had swapped out the women and children for perhaps a group of random men being slaughtered, would it have had the same effect on the character? For Jorga, most likely it would've been far less effective to see a bunch of random dudes, as being a knight, he slays men in battle all the time. The scene was supposed to be a pinnacle crossroad for him, so how would you have portrayed it differently.
I feel that your comments towards the author is overreaching and over projecting when the reality is that in order to tell a simplified story, based on the setting they chose (one that precisely relies on common tropes of the villainess subgenre), they just simply resorted to basic concepts that can be universally understood. (In the first place it's not that type of revenge plot where you feel catharsis for the slain, it reads more like role reversal dissection.)
I'm not in any way saying your criticism is unfounded, but I think, it's more directed towards the overall expectations rather than a direct look at the content's intentions. Ultimately the story just isn't for you, if you wanted a story where men are gratuitously slain left and right, it's not here.
I understand the sentiments of finding criticism in overused tropes. But let me ask then, if you had swapped out the women and children for perhaps a group of random men being slaughtered, would it have had th... Tsukishiro
I think dumbing down my point to just wanting men to be the targets of violence ignores a fundamental part of my critique, and that gratuitous violence is only being directed at women. When violence happens in the narrative, the framing is very intentional. When violence happens to men, it's very short and not explicit. We don't see the blood or the fallout of the violence, because we are not supposed to derive anything from their violence. I wouldn't be making the argument that the author hates women if both the men and women in the story were violated and suffered the same way. And I don't mean literally, but also the framing. The women are physically tormented and shown deteriorating to the point where they are incapable of functioning as humans, while the men retain their humanity but are under the control of the main character. The author could have definitely created a situation where the male characters suffered fates similar to the female characters, or, in the verse, had the female characters end up in a state similar to the men.
Also, I think you are overestimating how smart the story is. Our main character doesn't have an equal adversary who challenges him, so is he smart, or is everyone else dumb? A lot of times, we get other characters calling our MC smart, but it's only because he knows the world and the game from his past life, not because he's outmanoeuvring them. And a lot of the violence depicted is an intentional choice of the author, with the reasoning at times being very contrived. Relegating the violence as necessary for realism doesn't work in the same story where our main character's asshole is so addictive that a man who hated him for years changes sexuality and becomes completely subservient to him. Like, you can't tell me this is for the sake of realism and not
The crown prince, sure. But how, in what way, and will that change the vibe of the story into another slop action revenge porn. Like, it's easy to throw the suggestion out there, but it would effectively change... Tsukishiro
It is sloppy action revenge porn. Our main character doesn't develop or grow; he easily overpowers and controls everyone so quickly. Also, this isn't the real world; the author can make the target whoever they see fit. And for some reason, they decided that the only characters in their story who are worth brutal, explicit violence are the women, while all the men are untouchable. That is a deliberate narrative choice I am critiquing.
And you can argue, 'Oh, well, it wouldn't work well if literally any of the male characters received the same level of punishment as Nasha or Marie', and to that I say, then it's not a good story. The author controls everything in the world; they could create scenarios where the male characters face equal punishment. Just like they created a scenario where Anri gets into oriental cosplay for fan service. Maybe if they focused on the former instead of the latter, it wouldn't feel so misogynistic.
And Nasha and Marie are essentially motivated by the same goal as our MC. Nasha and Marie didn't want their loved ones to be the sacrifice and were willing to do anything to prevent it; damn, that's crazy. I wonder who else was like that? Also, Marie called the thugs to kill Juliette when she was drugged out of her mind and in immense pain. But my argument isn't that they are good people and don't deserve some type of punishment. So this is still irrelevant to my main point that the violence directed towards them is excessive and unfair.
It is sloppy action revenge porn. Our main character doesn't develop or grow; he easily overpowers and controls everyone so quickly. Also, this isn't the real world; the author can make the target whoever they ... Rora
Just a small correction...Nasha absolutely doesn't really care about Marie or her fam, we find out if she's taking Sig's route, Marie faces a bad end, and that Nasha could've dealt with the family debt but didnt. And Nasha was the one who purposely let the thugs in to try to kill Juliette. Marie being high off her rockers doesn't really absolve her of murder. They both don't care about other people. Even if you think Wickham (prince) or Sidguard didn't face the same level of punishment, what exactly did they do. They didn't purposely do anything to Juliette. Even Wickham apologizes for misunderstanding her all this time time. His main fault is that he is stupid.
Even if you think the crime is disproportionate, the situation is a little...
I think dumbing down my point to just wanting men to be the targets of violence ignores a fundamental part of my critique, and that gratuitous violence is only being directed at women. When violence happens in ... Rora
I think we're finally reaching a concensus here. Firstly, I'm a reader of this novel (not in translated form, in its pure original language). Anyone from the land of the rising sun knows it's a digest novel. It's meant to be short, uncomplicated and to the point of being a male villainess mirror. It was never penned to be some LOTR trilogy to get to that sort of detail, which is why I understand what led to its brevity. There's really no scenario I can think of that could swap out that Jorga scene which could be short and didn't involve a betrayal of a kin of some sort for the same magnitude of effect.
Thus I'm by no means calling this series smartly written or anything, it's quite compressed in detail. My main contention was the vibe of directly accusing the author of misogyny. The details in the novel for the gruesome scenes for women are just as short as they are for men. The only difference is the visual depiction in comic form, a wholy different creator. If anything the mental anguish of the men is more detailed in written form. Had this been a longer series I would agree with you that it's sloppy, but I'm not going to critique a short story for being short or contrived for the sake of progressing faster.
I inherently understand where you're coming from but it doesn't come off well intended as two parties who didn't read the same thing.
I wasn't expecting such a brutal death scene in the middle of a copy-paste villainess story. Besides that, this is your typical, generic story, with a character that doesn't have to work hard to get what she wants.
The punishment the female characters have recieved so far has exceeded exponentially what the male characters have faced. So far we have seen three female chracters get raped, and it's just so distasteful. I don't want to see our main chracter win.
...Alrighty, you tell us then, which character in the story that's male and a main antagonist you would want a gruesome punishment for, and still be logical to the world setting?
Our MC definitely isn't winning in a true sense. He's still going to die young.
He's a villain even when he's the protagonist, and gets his karma due.
Just because it sucks women are always gets the short end of the stick in literature, doesn't necessarily mean it's progressing unfairly in a story setting. That's just happenstance.
Correct me if I'm wrong but I've read the novel and SPOILER: the sisters are raped and forcibly placed in some beast's cage for babymaking. The crown prince who hurt mc's daughter equally literally finds himself a bride (his fucking cousin) and gets a happy ending. No male in this story really suffered while the female antagonists get a hell lot of bullshit. It's pretty evident that the author made it this way intentionally and it's not just happenstance. Even right now in the story you can see the unfairly placed consequences.
It's unfair and I don't see why you would say otherwise. It's a fictional story, you can do whatever you want to the characters no matter the gender as long as you WANT to. Author has a problem with women, you can literally tell. How are you going to cheat and end up happy while the other woman AND her sister become sex slaves for decisions you made?
Idk, maybe the crown prince, her stepbrother, or any of the other male characters who abandoned Juliette to die. The two girls literally carry only a fraction of the responsibility, and even less than the actual noblemen with the power to change her status from Priestess to Sacrifice. Also, Nasha and Marie aren't shown to be smart like the MC; they weren't the ones who orchestrated Juliette's downfall because they couldn't. Nasha and Marie, who were commoners, had the least amount of power and responsibility for what happened to Juliette, yet they are the ones going through the most brutal revenge plot, while the guys get a bit humiliated and then go back to their normal lives.
I'm fine with the main character being a monstrous villain; I'm not fine with the disproportionate amount of violence depicted towards women. And our MC does win if everything goes to his plan, and he faces no consequences for his actions. Also because him dying young (that is if he actually does) has nothing to do with his actions; I do not count it as consequences.
NOOOOO MY FAT THUMB PRESSED DOWN, I MEANT TO UPVOTE. SORRY
I feel like my intentions are clearly being misread and misunderstood. So I'll reiterate in a different way. I'm not in anyway saying there isn't a disproportionate amount of violence towards women in fiction, but often times people complain about it in a way that implies something other than it just being a natural direction of the story's progression or setting. "Did it have to happen that way?", instead of "did it happen that way for a purpose".
For example, in the situation you brought up, Anri purposely made Jorga witness that depravity. Because often times women and children are victims of crime and such situations evoke sympathy or empathy. A knight like Jorga should have been disturbed by it, but it was used as a means to test Jorga's devotion to Anri.
Ultimately his karma is that Jorga who witnessed women caged with beasts reincarnates as one himself.
I think that's dramatic irony.
And that's a common literary trope that is continuously criticised, where violence towards women is used to develop a male character's story. Rape is used as a shocking quirk in the story to demonstrate the depravity of the world and of the characters, with little regard for how it impacts the victims' lives.
I am engaging with why the author made these choices and what their purpose is. Context matters, but it does not excuse it. There is a reason why, when we see graphic depictions of violence, it's almost always the female characters, and that does not reflect well on the author. The author clearly demonstrates a strong distaste for women, and if not, a disregard for their humanity. As a revenge plot, we are supposed to feel catharsis when our main character does bad things to the antagonists; therefore, we are supposed to get some type of satisfaction in seeing these women suffer.
However, I cannot, because not only does the revenge far exceed the offences these women committed, but it's also not distributed equally to all guilty parties. None of the men responsible for hurting the main character and his family have really been punished, at least not as gratuitously, and they still remain empathetic characters.
The crown prince, sure. But how, in what way, and will that change the vibe of the story into another slop action revenge porn. Like, it's easy to throw the suggestion out there, but it would effectively change the story into something else entirely. If you're grossed out by the events, that's justified, but anything else is just demanding a sense of justice while ignoring the actual plot. Which is why I asked for a real alternative.
As unfair as it seems, Anri's primary goal was to make Juliette untouchable and to sit at the pinnacle of the kingdom so that the empire would end when she does. He made the goal clear from the beginning, and destroying the prince wouldn't do that. A little humiliated is a bit of an understatement. He knows his kingdom is at the mercy of Juliette and it could end tomorrow.
The story is based on a game world setting. Originally, Nasha is the one that wanted Juliette to be the sacrificed maiden. She wanted Juliette to die in her stead when she chose the Prince's route. Regardless who she chooses, someone gets the short end of the stick (usually Marie or Juliette).
Nasha willfully doesn't give a shit about her family. Marie if you forgot, also wanted Juliette and Anri dead, when she tried to hire the thug.
I understand the sentiments of finding criticism in overused tropes. But let me ask then, if you had swapped out the women and children for perhaps a group of random men being slaughtered, would it have had the same effect on the character? For Jorga, most likely it would've been far less effective to see a bunch of random dudes, as being a knight, he slays men in battle all the time. The scene was supposed to be a pinnacle crossroad for him, so how would you have portrayed it differently.
I feel that your comments towards the author is overreaching and over projecting when the reality is that in order to tell a simplified story, based on the setting they chose (one that precisely relies on common tropes of the villainess subgenre), they just simply resorted to basic concepts that can be universally understood.
(In the first place it's not that type of revenge plot where you feel catharsis for the slain, it reads more like role reversal dissection.)
I'm not in any way saying your criticism is unfounded, but I think, it's more directed towards the overall expectations rather than a direct look at the content's intentions. Ultimately the story just isn't for you, if you wanted a story where men are gratuitously slain left and right, it's not here.
I think dumbing down my point to just wanting men to be the targets of violence ignores a fundamental part of my critique, and that gratuitous violence is only being directed at women. When violence happens in the narrative, the framing is very intentional. When violence happens to men, it's very short and not explicit. We don't see the blood or the fallout of the violence, because we are not supposed to derive anything from their violence. I wouldn't be making the argument that the author hates women if both the men and women in the story were violated and suffered the same way. And I don't mean literally, but also the framing. The women are physically tormented and shown deteriorating to the point where they are incapable of functioning as humans, while the men retain their humanity but are under the control of the main character. The author could have definitely created a situation where the male characters suffered fates similar to the female characters, or, in the verse, had the female characters end up in a state similar to the men.
Also, I think you are overestimating how smart the story is. Our main character doesn't have an equal adversary who challenges him, so is he smart, or is everyone else dumb? A lot of times, we get other characters calling our MC smart, but it's only because he knows the world and the game from his past life, not because he's outmanoeuvring them. And a lot of the violence depicted is an intentional choice of the author, with the reasoning at times being very contrived. Relegating the violence as necessary for realism doesn't work in the same story where our main character's asshole is so addictive that a man who hated him for years changes sexuality and becomes completely subservient to him. Like, you can't tell me this is for the sake of realism and not
It is sloppy action revenge porn. Our main character doesn't develop or grow; he easily overpowers and controls everyone so quickly. Also, this isn't the real world; the author can make the target whoever they see fit. And for some reason, they decided that the only characters in their story who are worth brutal, explicit violence are the women, while all the men are untouchable. That is a deliberate narrative choice I am critiquing.
And you can argue, 'Oh, well, it wouldn't work well if literally any of the male characters received the same level of punishment as Nasha or Marie', and to that I say, then it's not a good story. The author controls everything in the world; they could create scenarios where the male characters face equal punishment. Just like they created a scenario where Anri gets into oriental cosplay for fan service. Maybe if they focused on the former instead of the latter, it wouldn't feel so misogynistic.
And Nasha and Marie are essentially motivated by the same goal as our MC. Nasha and Marie didn't want their loved ones to be the sacrifice and were willing to do anything to prevent it; damn, that's crazy. I wonder who else was like that? Also, Marie called the thugs to kill Juliette when she was drugged out of her mind and in immense pain. But my argument isn't that they are good people and don't deserve some type of punishment. So this is still irrelevant to my main point that the violence directed towards them is excessive and unfair.
Just a small correction...Nasha absolutely doesn't really care about Marie or her fam, we find out if she's taking Sig's route, Marie faces a bad end, and that Nasha could've dealt with the family debt but didnt. And Nasha was the one who purposely let the thugs in to try to kill Juliette. Marie being high off her rockers doesn't really absolve her of murder. They both don't care about other people.
Even if you think Wickham (prince) or Sidguard didn't face the same level of punishment, what exactly did they do. They didn't purposely do anything to Juliette. Even Wickham apologizes for misunderstanding her all this time time. His main fault is that he is stupid.
Even if you think the crime is disproportionate, the situation is a little...
I think we're finally reaching a concensus here.
Firstly, I'm a reader of this novel (not in translated form, in its pure original language). Anyone from the land of the rising sun knows it's a digest novel. It's meant to be short, uncomplicated and to the point of being a male villainess mirror. It was never penned to be some LOTR trilogy to get to that sort of detail, which is why I understand what led to its brevity. There's really no scenario I can think of that could swap out that Jorga scene which could be short and didn't involve a betrayal of a kin of some sort for the same magnitude of effect.
Thus I'm by no means calling this series smartly written or anything, it's quite compressed in detail. My main contention was the vibe of directly accusing the author of misogyny. The details in the novel for the gruesome scenes for women are just as short as they are for men. The only difference is the visual depiction in comic form, a wholy different creator. If anything the mental anguish of the men is more detailed in written form. Had this been a longer series I would agree with you that it's sloppy, but I'm not going to critique a short story for being short or contrived for the sake of progressing faster.
I inherently understand where you're coming from but it doesn't come off well intended as two parties who didn't read the same thing.