Is every S tier BL on here a 9.2?

I think all my favorite BL on here are rated 9.4 maximum, anything above that is mid, anything below 9.2 is also mid. Ones rated 8.6-8.9 are wildcards, because they're either well written, but have some nuanced divicive content that caused a knee-jerk reaction in people- or they are actually dogshit.
8.5 and below is a similar game, but the ratio of "dogshit" to "controversial but peak" increases exponentially with every point drop.
I think this is because turn your brain off mid series are easy to give 5 stars, but when a series makes you think you're more likely to give it a 3 or a 4 because you actually had to engage with it. Is this insane?