Sorry, guys! During system maintenance, some functions like comment are unavailable.
Manga/anime writers lack of accountability
What's been pissing me off recently (and since forever) is some people's inability to hold mangakas accountable for things that *they've* written in their manga. And while I'm going to talk about manga/anime, this could hold true to korean/chinese media too, its just that I feel more comfortable critiquing Japanese media, as I grew up consuming it my whole life, and am half Japanese.
This is particularly true when it comes to the anime community, which in itself is a bit toxic, because so many western fans refuse to hold Japanese mangakas to the same standard as they would to any other normal person. They often use excuses like '[Mangaka] didn't know any better' or 'But in Japan, they don't know about it' or even the god-forsaken noncey line 'But in the Japan, the legal age of consent is-'. The last one pisses me off the most, because of how stupid it is. The legal age of consent in a country should not be the cutoff line for an adult person's age of attraction, and I'm sick of people arguing so. (Esp when grown ass middle aged men talk abt 'the youngest theyll go is 18' but we all know they only say that bcs the law doesnt let them go any younger)
Of course, you cant expect to hold people of another country to the exact same standards of your own, but this is about geniune common fucking sense. Mangakas are usually grown adults, and shall be treated as such. They do not need to be babied by anyone just of their ethinicity. They know damn well and good in this day and age when they write a piece of fiction that includes racist/sexist undertones, or scenes that are outright fucking nuts. They are, once again, GROWN ADULTS and can complete their own research to know if what they are writing is problematic.
This isnt about a particular mangaka, manga or anime, but just a buildup of annoyance. It also doesnt help when the manga and anime industry are built to protect predators, and even allow them to continue creating manga under pseudonyms, despite knowing that the person is a convicted criminal.
And no, you cannot 'separate the art from the artist' when art is an extension of the artist and a form of their self expression, therefore reflecting their own personal beliefs into their artwork. Examples of this are when you watch an old hollywood movie and find pro-isreali propoganda in it. Or even a modern one.
i hate the argument of "legal age" since when does thing being illegal or legal make it morally correct or incorrect? by that standard, writers from Iraq can write a romance between 9 yr old girl child and a 40 yr old man bc 9 yrs is the "legal" age for girls to marry there apparently (istg i cant make ts up what's wrong w those people in power T_T...... reply
Very well said! I dont only see this in mangas but newer manhwas as well — I recently talked abt this in as a reply to manhwa... and omg the uke looked like literal KID in that manhwa It is nonsense! And yes. Japanese mangas have it a lot to. Some yaoi mangas (and some bara) have kids doing the deed with each other — they wear highschool unifo...... reply
The only thing is that a lot of eastern companies/creators historically don’t gaf about western cancel culture. I know at least in Japan it’s viewed as stupid or idiotic. There have been previous attempts by western fans to hold Japanese creators and companies accountable or cancel them for certain things, but it’s really easy for them to ign...... reply