My opinion

I think some people can read something shitty, and still able to criticize other things that are shitty. It just depends on whether it’s on the same level of bad and if they can accept deserved criticism. But yeah, the title “step bro my cum bucket” is something I think I would probably criticize too. Even with some of the shitty stuff I’ve......   1 reply

I've never understood this particular line of attack. in the absence of a rating or commentary, something being on an "already read" list doesn't mean anything. it just means that they read it. that's not my issue with questionable stuff in stories, especially when it's being pirated. I'll often read stuff out of curiosity, but that doesn't mean I ......   reply

SAY IT LOUDER!!!! they'll be giving jinx a 5 stars rating, but oh boy, a mangaka makes a story showing the REAL side of a toxic gay relationship in an asian country (rural area specially)... and suddenly, they're the biggest experts in what's moral and what not   reply

It's a matter of preference. You can rate something highly because it's entertaining or relatable, even if it's not objectively well written. People are still allowed to critique other stories while having questionable titles in their own read list, let's be real, we've all rated a mediocre yaoi 5/5 lol. If that makes someone a hypocrite, we're all......   reply

My already read is full of stuff I have rated 1 star / negatively reviewed . lol I hope ppl aren't going to my page and assuming I like that shit just cus it shows up.   reply

I've never once thought to check someone else's reading list, especially not to win an argument   2 reply

Something being on already read doesnt equal that you liked it or even that you finish reading it tho. I mark shitty stories as already read to not risk forgetting and going to read it again months later like an idiot   reply