Okay so I just read the first chapter and...... I'm sorry but is this not pedofilia
Clearly it's your view and u wanna think that way he didn't raise seme , he is prince and soon to be king uke just stand by stay in his room by midnight playing cards for the last 5 years ... He surely developed feelings but better look at story is based in historical time we cannot put present day morals here when seme is clearly kid but mature enough to make a deal to survive cuz uke father is after killing him.
If it was written in historical times, historical but this story wasn't written in those times was it? Just because the theme of the story is historical, it doesn't mean that you can't have modern morals in it, the author is LIVES IN THE MODERN TIMES I would understand the fucked upness of it all if the author wrote this in the 1700s but that's not the case now is it?
Why are we acting like some morality when story is filled with more than age gap its has more problematic things rape and beating here than to see age gap as a cause ... If u think it's alright to read story which has pedo is alright then written by old author it's also ur problem cuz it's not even normal for old time to view it in present.... Either u read story or stuck to those fictional straight stories
I never said it was okay I said I would UNDERSTAND it a bit more if it WAS written in that time. I KNOW it has more problematic stuff in it than simply the pedo issue, YOU wanted to have a discussion ABOUT THE PEDO ISSUE. I KNOW the story is set in 16-1800s BUT I am arguing that the AUTHOR isn't from those times. YOU said that we can't apply modern day morals to this story to try to justify the gross age gap.
Age gap isn't that big it 8 years old age gap i don't know what's this but age gap issue but I m currently reading a story with 44 years of age gap you should read it's definitely masterpiece "no more eurydice" cuz they both adults but I can guess here this one seme was 14 and uke was in his early 20s but it's seme kid who made this kind of deal with him it's not uke eho did he is just saving his sister and mother from getting beheaded so can't blame uke if he stay with his plan and develop feelings overtime but he has no intention of going further with seme but just pathways it's sems who pulled him back with force and rape threatening to pull his sister and mother both in trouble if uke doens't listen to him hope thsy explains....
The age gap itself isn't the issue tho, it's the fact they met when one of them was an adult and the other was a child that's the issue here. The rest of the story is weird aswell with the rape and blackmail aspect but the reason I'm not focusing on that is because you started the convo about the age issue. Age gap is fine as long as both characters meet when they're BOTH adults not before then.
I swear the amount of times I read a BL and the smutt scenes are just the bottom repeatedly begging the top to slow down or stop is ridiculous.
And the birds in the comments not noticing how rapey that shit is makes me feel like I'm the crazy one for noticing that shit.
I mean some of these smutt scenes look borderline violent at times and bitches will be in the comments like "that was so hot" no TF it wasn't?!?!
Idk man, am I crazy? or does it seem like these authors don't know what consensual sex is?
Holy truth nuke. I'm also so tired of seeing rape/sexual assault scenes... it literally adds nothing to the story 95% of the time (unless it adds social commentary on how it affects victims or something but most of the time it doesn't). Look at how many good stories there are that don't have it.
It's so tiring trying to filter through and find stories with actual healthy relationships (I hate the ones with a billion misunderstandings that never get resolved because they won't communicate either). I don't mind some angst but some of these plots are so... and I'd rather see BOTH people in the couple enjoying themselves, not when it looks like one is being coerced most of the time. I've read so many of these in the past, but now I'm kind of over it tbh
EXACTLY!!!!!
It worries me because I used to read shit like as a kid and I thought it was completely normal, it wasn't until I got some sense that I realised how stuff like this can warp your perception of sex as a young child. But when you point that out all ppl have to say abt it is "it's just fiction" or "if you don't like it then don't read it" completely ignoring the fact that fiction can effect your view on reality.
Yuuuppp!!! Ive been on yaoi since I was a kid and the normalization of stalker behavior completely warped my perception of love and romance and to this day I dont feel secure in a relationship unless the person is like borderline obsessive and it's gotten me into shit situations. It absolutely affects how you think!! Dont like dont read is just deflection
It also bugs the hell out of me when they have sex immediately after the incident as well instead of actually digesting what had just happened to them. I remember reading something of similar concept except instead of getting down, they both just sat in the same room in a comforting silence, neither really knowing what to say or do. It's sad that literally writing about two characters sitting in silence has better writing than a majority of these "romances"
Exactly, tho I haven't personally gone through something like that, I can imagine that that would be a really traumatizing thing to go through so for them to basically brush past it after it happens like it was nothing is so.....
This is also why omegaverse, guidverse or any kind of verse where sex is the main plot point, kinda bothers me because it just seems to me like a way to give the characters an excuse to rape someone by basically blaming it on "pheromones" or something along those lines and it's oftentimes just repackaged misogyny
There are so many parellels with misogyny/ pushed heteronormativity in things like omegaverse
Never really liked omegaverse unless it was alpha x alpha (or beta) because personally, it's much more appealing when characters fall in love despite it not being what's considered the norm, despite the difficulties or differences.
Things like pheromones or natural attraction just feel so bland and lazy
I've read a good amount of omegaverse, but honestly the emphasis on the fact that omegas are basically useless during their heat (aka period) and essentially only exist to attract "mates" for reproduction is just crazy misogynistic projection to me. Or how they force a character into heat at a random time in the worst situation and then get assaulted either by a random character or the ML.
Don't get me wrong, not all of it is bad, but holy shit... some of it is... well it was a choice. If it's used in a way to show how modern day societal views and discrimination on women can affect others, then maybe it's not so bad. But how many times do we see a strong omega? They are always portrayed as frail, weak, and basically a slave to their instincts which feels so weird.
These two are my holy grails of omegaverse tho and even they aren't perfect:
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/shima_chanchi_no_tsugaijijou/
https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/smyrna_capri/
It's actually one if the worst, I hate it so much. Like I would rather see some basic trope of meeting in class, at work, or on the train/bus 1000 times over those kind of scenes.
Not to mention that the amount of it in many series is kind of crazy?? Like do they think this kind of stuff happens a lot in real life... and do they seriously think that after being assaulted that the person is going to want to have sex with the person who "saved" them?? It seriously shows how romanticized it is in media and it's quite disappointing
Omegaverse was originally used for erotica (fanfic) fantasy but started getting more progression over the years although it still, heavily, keeps it initial concept as a smut fantasy. It's still kinda weird to me as a whole for many reasons because of things like mpreg. I have like, multiple views on that topic specifically, especially because on one side if you zoom out of all that it's just a large scale view of a patriarchal mindset of society,.. but in a homosexual smut fic. (of all things)
It's interesting to say the least but it's also a really weird topic of choice because you could literally write about such things in almost any genre and make a good point but out of all things they choose poorly written gay smut . Idk man
I feel like these things have potential in their own rights (on paper) but it's kind of hard for the authors to prove any point they're trying to make when even they themselves pushes their own "born to breed" narrative onto their characters for erotica purposes. (forced heats for smut etc).
I don't think I was able to like, process all my thoughts within just one comment but yeah. Hopefully this made sense and I'm not crazy
It's heavily romanticized. In general, depending on which character the person is mentally portraying themselves as, there's two different instances.
On one side, it's a saviour complex.
Save the heroin, they will have immense graditude and fall in love with you (and then everybody claps).
On the other side, it's a rescue fantasy.
A perfect victim, a damsel in distress that wishes somebody (insert hot love interest here) will swoop in to solve their problems for them. Somebody they can completely rely on without having to do too much themselves. A protector.
..
There's honestly more to it and this is just scratching the surface (not including the smut). For the savior side it's mostly seen in male centered media, of the MC saving a beautiful woman from a dangerous situation (alt. things like SA), she'll be greatful, realize he's "not like other men" but strong and reliable and eventually become infatuated and loyal to only him. Basically the typical male insert seen everywhere in shounen animes and even western media.
For the rescue side it's typically the same thing except it's just reversed roles with the MC being in the helpless and afraid position. Needing someone to rely on. The self insert seen in often in shoujo related materials (or media catered twords women) I feel like I could put much more in this section but honestly you probably get the gist of it.
Smyrna & Capri is one of my favs omegaverse. It's not a perfect one since you could say the beginning is dubcon, and the characters are reluctant or even regretful of their relationship at times. However, I think the way their relationship grows over time is great. It's technically Alpha x Alpha (although it does have mpreg), and the only Omega character I remember is kind of irritating to the plot tho I don't think it's due to their secondary gender but more of the personality of the character.
Maybe if omegaverse stories were purely smut and didn't try to expand on the societal views then I would see it differently. It's just that there are a lot of parallels to how women are treated in real life along with fighting for rights or equal treatment in comparison to Omega characters (male or female) that just makes it poor taste to me most of the time. When the Omega who was fighting for their rights gets assaulted or mated, suddenly forgets about wanting their independence/better treatment for their secondary gender, and plays a docile live at home partner after have multiple kids which is then showed to be like their only purpose and cycles back to the narrative that they were originally fighting against (that Omegas are only good to be bred). It feels like subtle messaging... (yes, I know breeding kink is a thing)
I really don't like how the ml speaks to the MC but then the MC has to apologise to him. Cuz he told you it was a bracelet and you found the bracelet why tf didn't you see if it was his? You weren't sure if it was his so you just... Didn't ask? But only the MC has to apologise...
well, our mc's everything is high end brands where as the bracelet is cheap plastic bracelet so he might not have wanted to mention that he found a bracelet in case our mc lashes out on him for thinking something that cheap could ever belong to him.